One of the most sobering things in the week since the devastating attack on MP Helen Haines is how many of our politicians expressed that this appalling violence was “a shock but not a surprise”.
asserted
violence → express → politicians
They had been dreading the real-world consequences of the decline of our public debate and, with that, our democracy.
asserted
They → dread → that
Degrading our leaders has turned into a sport, and increasing personal threats mean a dangerous new world.
asserted
threats → degrade → world
Last week, The Age hosted two global leaders at its Melbourne Assembly, the former mayor of New York Bill de Blasio and pioneering urban planner Carlos Moreno, who lives in Paris.
asserted
who → host → Paris
Both came with experience of how anger towards society can turn into unthinkable acts of political violence.
asserted
anger → come → violence
They arrived in Melbourne as Paris was burning.
asserted
Paris → arrive → Melbourne
Even those accustomed to the French and their love of a protest have been shocked by the scale of violence.
asserted
those → accustom → violence
As we were sending journalists to France to cover the riots, we were also sending journalists to Wangaratta, where the community was coming to grips with the unimaginable.
asserted
community → send → unimaginable
The morning after the alleged attack on Helen Haines, de Blasio challenged those in the room – don’t let this happen again.
asserted
this → challenge → room
We can all agree on that, but what do we do?
asserted
we → agree → what
In a common story for this country, I’m an import from the UK who has made Australia home.
asserted
Australia → ’m → UK
One of the things my family and I have loved about Australia is the wonderful lifestyle and the respectful and carefree nature of our society.
asserted
family → love → society
However, it’s become clear that our geography and good nature is not enough to protect us from the assault on our national fabric from social media algorithms tuned to divide, and AI models with hallucination built into their operating systems.
asserted
geography → become → systems
What we do know is that for a society to solve difficult problems, we need to start with facts as the basis for debate.
asserted
we → know → debate
Every day, across our mastheads and TV newsrooms, Nine sends journalists to gather those facts, sometimes at great risk to their own safety.
asserted
Nine → send → safety
We train them.
asserted
We → train → them
We put them through rigorous verification processes.
asserted
We → put → processes
They abide by agreed rules for access to our institutions, including parliament and the courts, while also maintaining a healthy tendency to get up in the face of authority.
asserted
They → abide → authority
Sometimes we get it wrong, and when we do, there are consequences, as there should be.
asserted
we → get → ?
It is the media’s role in a democracy to inform and to hold power to account.
asserted
It → inform → account
On the flipside, social media and algorithm-driven feeds, mainly from outside our country, are shaping the debate in Australia every day.
asserted
media → drive → Australia
They amplify fringe grievance narratives, erode trust in public institutions and lock users into polarised echo chambers.
asserted
They → amplify → chambers
The Australian Federal Police has warned that AI is accelerating and lowering the skills required to manipulate and radicalise individuals online.
asserted
AI → warn → individuals
By which rules do they abide?
asserted
they → abide → ?
And what are the consequences when they get it wrong?
asserted
it → get → ?
The sad fact is there is no accountability or consequences for the damage being done to our public debate.
asserted
fact → be → debate
Can we put the genie back in the bottle when it comes to social media?
asserted
it → put → media
It’s an uphill battle.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Do we need to embrace new technology?
asserted
we → need → technology
At Nine, we use social media just as we use AI.
asserted
we → use → AI
Like most businesses, we are navigating how to do so in a responsible way.
asserted
we → navigate → way
We must learn the lessons of the past, otherwise we will be doomed to repeat them with each technological evolution.
asserted
we → learn → evolution
We are playing catch-up in response to past complacency, regulating these tech platforms to protect our children from harm and fight back against the damaging effects on our society.
asserted
We → play → society
And the next policy challenge is clearly around artificial intelligence; how should we regulate it and what guardrails must be put in place to make sure it benefits us, the Australian public, not just a handful of Silicon Valley billionaires?
asserted
it → regulate → billionaires
From changes to copyright to construction of data centres, we require our leaders to look to the long term.
asserted
we → require → term
We will get only one chance to get this right.
asserted
this → get → chance
If the Australian Parliament rushes into watering down our copyright regime in the hope of a data centre boom, there will be no going back.
asserted
Parliament → rush → boom
Once the content is devalued, we risk Australian voices and local accountability being lost.
asserted
voices → devalue → ?
The facts, which have never been more important, could be sacrificed.
uncertain
which → sacrifice → ?
We’re at a point in time in which we need to choose what kind of society we want.
asserted
we → ’re → society
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
