Prime Minister Mark Carney’s threat to hold the Palestinian Authority “to account” for not holding elections this year is not a joke, but it’s certainly laughable.
Just what is Carney and his Liberal government going to do?
asserted
Carney → hold → what
Call Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and tell him he’s being a very naughty boy?
asserted
he → call → him
Carney had been prime minister for a mere four months when, in July 2025, he announced that he intended to recognize the state of Palestine.
asserted
he → announce → Palestine
Perhaps he was being impetuous to please the pro-Palestinian faction of his party, or because it was the cause du jour, or to bolster his credentials and appear decisive.
asserted
it → please → credentials
But it did help those who are intent on demonizing Israel, while encouraging the pro-Palestinian marches and the air of antisemitism that comes with them.
asserted
that → help → them
And with recognition came money — lots of it.
asserted
money → come → it
In June, Canada pledged $100 million to help international organizations and NGOs deliver assistance to Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.
asserted
organizations → pledge → Bank
In September, Carney announced $100 million more.
asserted
Carney → announce → million
In total, Canada has now pledged $600 million to the Palestinians since Hamas committed the October 7 massacre.
asserted
Hamas → pledge → massacre
In May, Carney had a phone call with Abbas, in which he “underscored Canada’s unwavering support for a negotiated two-state solution” and conveyed the importance of further reforms to “strengthen accountability, governance and democratic institutions, in which Hamas can play no part,” according to the Prime Minister’s Office.
uncertain
Hamas → have → Office
Carney’s recognition of Palestine was predicated on several conditions, including Abbas holding elections.
asserted
Abbas → predicate → elections
But to absolutely no one’s surprise, Abbas reneged on the promised legislative and presidential elections.
asserted
Abbas → renege → elections
The Palestinian Authority decided to cancel next month’s elections and to re-schedule them for September next year.
asserted
Authority → decide → September
But there’s no guarantee they will go ahead, and every likelihood that they won’t.
asserted
they → ’ → ?
Abbas doesn’t appear too keen on elections.
asserted
Abbas → appear → elections
He was elected in 2005 for a four-year term, but 21 years later he shows no inclination of stepping down.
asserted
he → elect → inclination
Carney is now left looking weak and powerless after being outfoxed by Abbas.
asserted
Carney → leave → Abbas
The prime minister demanded three conditions for recognizing Palestine: reform of the PA, elections in 2026 and demilitarization.
asserted
minister → demand → 2026
Not one of those conditions has been met.
asserted
one → meet → conditions
Recognizing the state of Palestine was part of “building the promise of a peaceful future for both the state of Palestine and the State of Israel,” Carney said last year.
asserted
Carney → recognize → Israel
Well, things aren’t looking that peaceful.
asserted
things → look → ?
The PA had provided “direct commitments” on holding elections, said the prime minister.
asserted
minister → provide → elections
Making matters worse, our government seems to think that even though the Palestinian Authority has not held elections in more than two decades, the current delay is somehow Israel’s fault.
asserted
delay → make → decades
Foreign Minister Anita Anand issued a joint statement alongside her counterparts in France, Australia and the United Kingdom last week, expressing deep regret and disappointment that the elections had been postponed.
asserted
elections → issue → regret
They asked Abbas to reconsider and pointed out that, “An entire generation of Palestinians has reached adulthood without the opportunity to choose their elected representatives.”
asserted
generation → ask → representatives
But astonishingly, they then blamed Israel, seemly accepting the Palestinian excuse that the elections were postponed because of “obstacles posed by Israeli measures,” by saying, “We reiterate our call on Israel to refrain from actions that could impede the conduct of elections, including the practical arrangements necessary for all Palestinians to participate.”
uncertain
Palestinians → blame → arrangements
Canada has recognized Palestine, given out hundreds of millions of dollars, led an international pile-on against Israel and very, very nicely asked Abbas to hold elections.
asserted
Canada → recognize → elections
It’s almost as if the PA president doesn’t give a hoot about what Carney and the rest of the world thinks, as long as he stays in power.
asserted
he → ’ → power
In a press conference on Wednesday, Carney said he was holding the PA “to account” but didn’t say how or when or what he would do.
“There are many things that are not working within Palestine and there are many who are responsible for that,” Carney said.
asserted
Carney → say → that
Also not working is recognizing Palestine, which achieved nothing good but gave succour to terrorists, antisemites and protesters.
asserted
which → work → terrorists
The Aporia
