Chiefs, Opposition call for Alberta government to drop appeal of decision that quashed separation petition
Province says it won't be doing that
asserted
it → drop → that
With the Alberta referendum now in the books, some First Nation chiefs are calling on the provincial government to drop its appeal of a judge’s decision to quash the citizen petition on separation.
asserted
chiefs → call → separation
“I mean, now that the referendum’s happened, the issue’s moot,” said Siksika Nation Chief Samuel Crowfoot.
asserted
Crowfoot → mean → ?
“[Premier Danielle Smith] said up and down that she's not going to pursue another referendum.
asserted
she → say → referendum
Well, I think now’s the chance for her to put action to those words and to drop that appeal.”
asserted
her → think → appeal
Crowfoot says doing so could help repair the relationship between First Nations and the province — a relationship, he says, right now is “fractured.”
uncertain
he → say → Nations
"The people said it straight out: we are not going to go through a separation.
asserted
we → say → separation
So my question would be is: why hang on to a process that the Alberta people gave her no mandate to speak on?"
asserted
people → hang → mandate
Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation Chief Allan Adam said.
asserted
Adam → say → ?
At issue is a petition led by pro-independence group Stay Free Alberta to prompt the province to consider a referendum question on separation.
asserted
petition → lead → separation
It garnered more than 300,000 signatures earlier this year.
asserted
It → garner → signatures
NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi echoed the chiefs' calls at a news conference Friday morning.
asserted
Nenshi → echo → conference
“Certainly the First Nations are spending money on lawyers, we taxpayers are spending money on lawyers, let’s listen to what Albertans said on Monday and just drop it,” Nenshi said.
asserted
Nenshi → spend → it
The province, however, says it won't be doing that.
asserted
it → say → that
Justice Minister Mickey Amery said in a statement the government believes the "decision contained errors of law."
"Citizens should not have to meet a duty to consult to gather signatures from fellow citizens on a citizen initiative petition," Amery said.
asserted
Amery → say → petition
The legal picture so far
Four First Nations — Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation, Siksika Nation, Blood Tribe and Piikani Nation — challenged the process involving Stay Free Alberta’s citizen petition.
asserted
Nations → challenge → petition
In May, Justice Shaina Leonard ruled that there had been a failure to consult with the First Nations, and she overturned Elections Alberta’s approval of the petition.
uncertain
she → rule → petition
Because of that ruling, the government’s question on the Oct. 19 referendum ballot asked if Albertans supported the province starting the legal process to hold a second, binding referendum on separation.
asserted
province → ask → separation
The government launched an appeal of Leonard’s decision.
asserted
government → launch → decision
Mitch Sylvestre, who led the petition drive, is also appealing it.
asserted
who → lead → it
Crowfoot said he does not expect Sylvestre to drop his appeal.
asserted
Sylvestre → say → appeal
“So, we’ll handle Mitch’s, but Danielle should drop hers on the part of the government of Alberta,” he said.
asserted
he → handle → Alberta
Mitch Sylvestre hold boxes of signatures before submitting them for a separation referendum to Elections Alberta in Edmonton on May 4, 2026.
uncertain
Sylvestre → hold → May
For his part, Sylvestre says he would like to see the government continue its appeal.
asserted
government → say → appeal
“I think, moving forward for democracy here in Alberta, it's very important that they have to appeal that,” Sylvestre said.
asserted
Sylvestre → think → that
“Because, I mean, this is a very contentious question, but there's gonna be other questions that somebody's going to disagree with.
asserted
somebody → mean → that
And, you know, all of a sudden, I can see that it won't be long they won't be able to ask any questions.
asserted
they → know → questions
According to unofficial results, Albertans voted 75 per cent in favour of the province remaining a part of Canada.
uncertain
province → accord → Canada
What could happen next?
uncertain
What → happen → ?
Because there are two appeals, the process would continue regardless if the government dropped its appeal, said Kathleen Mahoney, professor emeritus at the University of Calgary's faculty of law.
asserted
Mahoney → be → law
Continuing its appeal could also give the government more clarity going forward, she said.
uncertain
she → continue → clarity
“They may want to know exactly when in a government process that affects Indigenous rights a consultation has to take place,” she said.
uncertain
she → want → place
Constitutional experts have told CBC News that if an appeal is granted, the petition could indeed move forward.
uncertain
petition → tell → News
“If the [appeal] court agrees with the court below, it's over,” Mahoney said.
asserted
Mahoney → agree → court
“But if the court decides that the consultation could have taken place later in the process, well, then we're into a different scenario.”
In the latter case, it would trigger a requirement for the government to deal with the initial citizen petition, she said, but there is no timeline set for when that would need to happen.
uncertain
that → decide → petition
The Aporia
