Photo via Washington Examiner

Justice Kagan compares Boulder’s climate lawsuit to ‘big tobacco’ lawsuits

Read the original at Washington Examiner ↗
Cite

Birle, J. (2026, October 5). Justice Kagan compares Boulder’s climate lawsuit to ‘big tobacco’ lawsuits. Washington Examiner. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/supreme-court/4754328/justice-kagan-compares-boulders-climate-lawsuit-big-tobacco-lawsuits/

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Washington Examiner · collected 2026-10-05 · by Jack Birle

Quick Summary

During a Supreme Court hearing on Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, Justice Elena Kagan compared Boulder’s climate lawsuit against oil companies to the lawsuits filed against tobacco companies in the 1990s. The case focuses on whether Boulder’s lawsuit can proceed under state law or is preempted by federal regulations regarding air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Shanmugam, representing Suncor Energy, argued that both the Clean Air Act and constitutional principles preclude the lawsuit from going forward, but Kagan questioned why these cases should not be allowed to proceed similarly to how tobacco lawsuits were permitted decades ago.
Written by AI on 2026-10-05, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

The Supreme Court opened its new term on Monday by hearing arguments in Suncor Energy v. Boulder County, a landmark case that could determine whether states and local governments can sue oil and gas companies for climate change damages. The case, which began in 2018 when Boulder County sued Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy, accuses these companies of contributing to climate-related harms through their fossil fuel operations. The lawsuit aims to hold the companies financially responsible for local climate impacts using state tort laws.

If the Supreme Court allows such lawsuits, it could set a precedent for similar cases across the nation, potentially affecting industries that emit carbon and leading to increased costs for consumers due to higher legal liabilities. Conversely, if the court rules against Boulder County, it would limit states' ability to use their courts for addressing national policy issues like climate change through tort law, thereby protecting manufacturers from an expanding patchwork of lawsuits based on complex environmental problems.

Written for “Supreme Court Climate Case” on 2026-11-20, grounded in this article and the 35 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

12 outlets covered “Supreme Court Climate Case”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Washington ExaminerThis outlet5 Oct

During a Supreme Court hearing on Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, Justice Elena Kagan compared Boulder’s climate lawsuit against oil companies to the lawsuits filed against tobacco companies in the 1990s. The case focuses on whether Boulder’s lawsuit can proceed under state law or is preempted by federal regulations regarding air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Shanmugam…

Justice Kagan compares Boulder’s climate lawsuit to ‘big tobacco’ lawsuits (this article)9 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
CBS News6 Oct

The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments regarding an attempt by energy companies to prevent a lawsuit filed by Boulder County and the city of Boulder, Colorado. The plaintiffs aim to hold these companies responsible for damages caused by global climate change. Eight justices participated in the hearing.

U.S. Supreme Court wrestles with bid by energy companies to block major climate suit →7 articles from CBS News on this story
Fox News10 Oct

Energy policy experts warn that a Supreme Court decision in favor of climate change lawsuits against oil companies could lead to the bankruptcy of these firms and significant increases in gas prices. The case, Suncor v. Boulder, centers on whether federal law preempts state legal claims seeking damages from fossil fuel producers for alleged climate-related harms. During oral arguments, Justice Clarence Thomas…

Supreme Court climate case could bankrupt oil companies, send gas prices soaring, experts warn →5 articles from Fox News on this story
NPR5 Oct

Today marks the start of a significant Supreme Court term with arguments in a major climate change case where Boulder, Colorado is suing Suncor and Exxon Mobil for misleading the public about fossil fuel harms. Meanwhile, Brazil's presidential race will head to a runoff between Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and Flávio Bolsonaro after neither candidate secured enough votes in the first round.

SCOTUS hears major climate change case. And, Brazil's presidential race goes to runoff →3 articles from NPR on this story
NBC News5 Oct

The Supreme Court's new term starts with a case where oil companies seek to dismiss lawsuits filed by cities like Boulder, Colorado, claiming the companies should pay damages for climate change impacts. The lawsuit against Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy alleges these firms misled consumers about greenhouse gas effects, while the defendants deny wrongdoing and argue that federal jurisdiction, not states, is…

New Supreme Court term begins with a climate change case seeking to hold energy companies liable →3 articles from NBC News on this story
Reason5 Oct

The Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments in the case of Suncor Energy v. Boulder County on October 9th, where fossil fuel companies are arguing that all state-law-based tort lawsuits regarding climate change damages should be preempted by federal law. This could have significant implications for environmental and climate policy in the United States. The author will discuss this case at two events: one at Penn…

Unpacking the Suncor Oral Argument →2 articles from Reason on this story
Show 6 more outlets
Los Angeles Times5 Oct

During a Supreme Court hearing, justices expressed skepticism about allowing state-based lawsuits against oil producers over climate change damages. Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Elena Kagan suggested that such claims might be preempted by federal law under the Clean Air Act. The case involves Colorado’s ruling that Boulder County can sue for damages in local court, which could impact similar pending litigation in…

Supreme Court sounds wary of state-based climate change suits against oil producers →2 articles from Los Angeles Times on this story
The Straits Times5 Oct

The US Supreme Court is set to hear arguments in Suncor v Boulder on October 5, where plaintiffs from Colorado are suing oil companies for damages related to climate change. The case involves claims that ExxonMobil and Suncor knowingly caused and concealed the dangers of fossil fuels, resulting in significant financial losses due to extreme weather events. At stake is whether federal law pre-empts these state-level…

US Supreme Court hears bid to shut the door on climate suits →
ABC News (US)5 Oct

The Supreme Court's new term starts with significant cases involving climate change, gun rights, and immigration policies. In the climate change case, energy companies Suncor and ExxonMobil seek to block lawsuits in Boulder, Colorado, where local officials claim these companies should contribute financially to damages caused by climate change. The court will also examine challenges to state laws banning certain…

Supreme Court term begins with cases on climate change, immigration and gun rights →
Toronto Star5 Oct

The Supreme Court's new term begins with significant cases addressing climate change, gun control, and immigration policies. Energy companies like Suncor and ExxonMobil are challenging lawsuits in Boulder, Colorado, which seek to hold them financially responsible for damages caused by climate change. Additionally, the court will consider challenges to state laws banning assault-style weapons and Trump's deportation…

A new Supreme Court term begins with cases on climate change, immigration and gun rights →
The Guardian5 Oct

The US Supreme Court will hear arguments on Monday concerning Suncor Energy’s and ExxonMobil’s bid to block climate damage lawsuits brought by Boulder County. Local officials argue that these oil companies should cover some of the costs associated with climate impacts, while the companies assert federal law prevents state courts from handling such cases. If the court rules in favor of the fossil fuel industry, it…

US supreme court to hear big oil’s bid to block climate damage lawsuits →
CBC6 Oct

The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments on whether local governments can sue oil and gas companies for climate damages in state courts. Boulder, Colorado, is suing Suncor and ExxonMobil to recover costs from climate-related disasters like the Marshall Fire, which caused $2 billion in damage. Chief Justice John Roberts expressed concern about a potential flood of similar lawsuits across the country, while Justice…

What U.S. Supreme Court judges said at a hearing on climate damages from oil and gas →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • The case involves whether state courts can hear lawsuits against energy companies for damages related to climate change.13
Quoted from the coverage (2)

About a dozen states have banned semiautomatic rifles like AR-15s, which are often called assault weapons.

4 outlets

Justice Elena Kagan compared the climate change lawsuits to previous claims against tobacco and opioid companies brought by states on behalf of their citizens.

4 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • CBS News and The Guardian present different perspectives on the potential impact of the Supreme Court's decision, with CBS focusing on the procedural aspects while The Guardian emphasizes the broader implications for climate accountability.13

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • CBS News and The Straits Times both frame the case as a bid to shut down climate change lawsuits, but CBS focuses more on the procedural aspects while The Straits Times highlights the broader implications.12
  • ABC News frames the Supreme Court's new term with multiple high-profile cases including climate change, immigration, and gun rights, whereas Fox News emphasizes the potential financial impact on oil companies if the court rules in favor of local governments.45
The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 36 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 6% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
Washington Examiner
Leans left Hedges 12 of 56 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Straits Times
Leans left Hedges 6 of 19 claims Outlet record 64/100
Washington Examiner
Leans strongly right further right than this Hedges 2 of 34 claims Outlet record 67/100
NPR
Hedges 8 of 52 claims Outlet record 60/100
NBC News
Leans left Hedges 7 of 33 claims Outlet record 78/100
Washington Examiner
Hedges 9 of 22 claims Outlet record 67/100
Washington Examiner
Hedges 7 of 40 claims Outlet record 67/100
Reason
Hedges 2 of 10 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Guardian
Leans left Hedges 5 of 36 claims Outlet record 64/100
Washington Examiner
Hedges 2 of 20 claims Outlet record 67/100

Story

Supreme Court Climate Case
Environment · 36 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
18
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
6%
1 of 18 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
67/100
Washington Examiner's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
36
Environment
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-05 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Washington Examiner · 5185 article(s) · 11 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 11 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Jack Birle
54 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 earlier this year in Trump v. Slaughter that the president could fire officials at most independent agencies within the executive branch, but held 5-4 in the case Trump v. Cook that the Federal Reserve was uniquely insulated from the broad at-will firing power the president enjoys over the executive branch.
The Supreme Court will hear a major Second Amendment case over state assault weapons bans next month, but Justice Clarence Thomas is calling on the high court to consider another major legal war over gun laws in the coming terms.
“Implicit bias training” is a type of diversity, equity, and inclusion program, which proponents argue educates people about bias they may have against different races or people of the opposite sex, while opponents claim it pushes a hard-left view of race and sex.
President Donald Trump has touted plans to renovate East Potomac Golf Links and build a “World Class Championship Golf Course,” posting plans last month that would remove the popular public access and paths along the golf course on Hains Point.
The Supreme Court announced Friday it will hear a case over the legality of President Donald Trump’s January 2025 executive order that largely barred people from applying for asylum at the southern border.
A Utah judge ruled on Monday that Tyler Robinson will go to trial in 2028 on murder charges related to the September 2025 killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
As Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS) narrowly trails her Democratic challenger Scott Colom by just a few hundred votes in the unexpectedly close Senate race in Mississippi, Republicans are now hoping a Supreme Court loss on late-arriving mail ballots earlier this year will help save their senator from being the latest victim of the blue tsunami.
President Donald Trump’s first term in office was highlighted by the avalanche of judicial nominees he was able to get confirmed to the bench, but with Democrats set to take control of the Senate in January, the race is on to push through nominations before time runs out next year.
The coalition of Catholic schools argued that asking them to admit families who do not follow Catholic teachings would sacrifice their beliefs, which they say violates their First Amendment rights.
The coalition of Catholic schools argued that asking them to admit families who do not follow Catholic teachings would sacrifice their beliefs, which they say violates their First Amendment rights.
Also by Jack Birle
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 54 articles by Jack Birle →

Topics

Boulder Constitution Suncor the Clean Air Act the Supreme Court

Subjects

Boulder GPE · 6× Kagan PERSON · 5× Shanmugam PERSON · 4× the Supreme Court ORG · 4× Suncor ORG · 3× Congress ORG · 2× Kavanaugh PERSON · 2× Colorado GPE · 1× Elena Kagan PERSON · 1× Suncor Energy v. ORG · 1×

Narrative

“We don’t have to reinvent the wheel because we’ve said this multiple times, and Congress presumably, when doing the Clean Air Act and doing Clean Air Act amendments, has relied on this Court’s precedents establishing that this kind of pollution is a federal law matter unless Congress speaks otherwise,” Kavanaugh said.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-05
The case is expected to have sweeping ramifications for similar lawsuits that climate activists and Democrat-led jurisdictions have attempted to bring against oil companies, either broadly allowing them to continue or barring them as a matter of federal law.
2026-10-05 · Washington Examiner
Justice Kagan compares Boulder’s climate lawsuit to ‘big tobacco’ lawsuits · assertive framing

Claims (18 extracted, 1 hedged)

Justice Elena Kagan likened Boulder, Colorado’s lawsuits against oil companies for alleged climate change damages to the litany of lawsuits filed against “big tobacco” in the 1990s, as the Supreme Court considered Monday whether to allow Boulder’s landmark lawsuit to proceed. asserted
lawsuit → liken → 1990s
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County over whether the lawsuit is preempted by federal law or not permissible under the Constitution, or if it can proceed to trial in state court. asserted
it → hear → court
The case is expected to have sweeping ramifications for similar lawsuits that climate activists and Democrat-led jurisdictions have attempted to bring against oil companies, either broadly allowing them to continue or barring them as a matter of federal law. asserted
them → expect → law
During Monday’s oral arguments, Kagan questioned Suncor’s lawyer, Kannon Shanmugam, over what prevents Boulder’s lawsuit from going forward, whereas major lawsuits against “big tobacco” and opioid makers were allowed to proceed on what she said were seemingly similar claims. “In multiple respects, this suit appears to be based on the old 1990s tobacco suits that were brought by states and local governments, basically saying that big tobacco had made representations, misrepresentations, which had caused people to to overuse the product, causing harm to those governments,” Kagan said. uncertain
Kagan → question → governments
“I suppose the opioid litigation more recently follows the same model. asserted
litigation → suppose → model
So, if this is Chapter 3, were Chapters 1 and 2 also preempted?” asserted
Chapters → preempt → ?
Kagan added in her question to Shanmugam. asserted
Kagan → add → Shanmugam
Shanmugam rejected that Boulder’s lawsuit was similar to big tobacco lawsuits, saying it is not a new chapter but rather a “different book.” asserted
it → reject → lawsuits
The lawyer for Suncor highlighted differences between the two lawsuits, to which Kagan responded by claiming that she was “waiting to see the distinction,” noting that “this complaint talks a lot about misrepresentations” made by the oil companies. asserted
complaint → highlight → companies
Justice Brett Kavanaugh later followed up on Kagan’s question, asking why Shanmugam did not just assert that the Clean Air Act prevents states and counties from bringing forward lawsuits about air pollution, rather than attempting to make an additional constitutional argument. asserted
Act → follow → argument
“I thought the answer was that this Court has consistently said that air and water pollution are different in our federal enclaves,” Kavanaugh said. asserted
Kavanaugh → think → enclaves
“Why are you resisting that?” asserted
you → resist → that
Shanmugam had argued throughout the hearing that Boulder’s lawsuit should be dismissed both because the Clean Air Act gives the federal government jurisdiction over the regulation of greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, and because the Constitution does not allow states to regulate matters beyond their borders. asserted
states → argue → borders
Shanmugam heavily emphasized the constitutional argument, leading to pushback from the justices who believed the Clean Air Act was likely the stronger argument. asserted
Act → emphasize → justices
“We don’t have to reinvent the wheel because we’ve said this multiple times, and Congress presumably, when doing the Clean Air Act and doing Clean Air Act amendments, has relied on this Court’s precedents establishing that this kind of pollution is a federal law matter unless Congress speaks otherwise,” Kavanaugh said. asserted
Kavanaugh → have → pollution
The high court appeared split on whether to allow Boulder’s lawsuit to move forward, but a majority appeared open to striking down the lawsuit as preempted by the Clean Air Act. asserted
majority → appear → Act
Because Justice Samuel Alito recused himself from the case, an eight-person bench will decide the case for the Supreme Court, leaving open the possibility of a rare 4-4 deadlock. asserted
bench → recuse → deadlock
The Suncor case was the first the Supreme Court heard in its new term, and the justices are expected to issue a ruling as soon as early 2027. asserted
justices → hear → 2027
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support