Photo via National Post

Josh Dehaas: A Carney oil blockade would be playing with fire, even if constitutional

Read the original at National Post ↗
Cite

Special to National Post. (2026, September 3). Josh Dehaas: A Carney oil blockade would be playing with fire, even if constitutional. National Post. https://nationalpost.com/opinion/josh-dehaas-a-carney-oil-blockade-would-be-playing-with-fire-even-if-constitutional

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

National Post · collected 2026-09-03 · by Special to National Post analysis

Quick Summary

The article discusses Ontario Premier Doug Ford's suggestion that the federal government block oil exports to the United States as leverage in the trade war, and whether such a move would be constitutional. According to the Constitution Act of 1867, Parliament has residual powers to make laws for Canada's peace, order, and good government, which could potentially override provincial control over natural resources. The article cites several Supreme Court decisions that suggest Ottawa may have strong arguments in favor of imposing embargoes or taxes on Alberta oil exports.
Written by AI on 2026-09-03, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

As of September 4, 2026, a tentative trade deal between Canada and the U.S., aimed at avoiding damaging tit-for-tat tariffs, collapsed just hours before its deadline. This breakdown triggered President Donald Trump to impose new 50% tariffs on $28 billion worth of Canadian exports. Prime Minister Mark Carney responded by announcing Canada's intention to match these tariffs dollar for dollar to protect domestic workers and businesses. The escalating trade tensions have led to the U.S. Justice Department ordering a freeze on all antitrust work with Canada, exacerbating the economic conflict between the neighboring countries.

The dispute has also spurred a "Buy Canadian" movement among consumers who are actively seeking out locally made products over American alternatives as part of their show of solidarity amid the ongoing trade war. Additionally, retaliatory tariffs have been imposed on various goods including dairy, motorcycles, and alcoholic beverages, further complicating economic relations between the two nations. This conflict comes amidst broader political tensions highlighted by President Trump's repeated rhetoric about annexing Canada. Despite historic close ties, both countries face significant challenges in resolving their trade disputes amicably.

Written for “U.S.-Canada Trade War Escalates” on 2026-11-20, grounded in this article and the 53 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

20 outlets covered “U.S.-Canada Trade War Escalates”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

National PostThis outlet3 Sep

The article discusses Ontario Premier Doug Ford's suggestion that the federal government block oil exports to the United States as leverage in the trade war, and whether such a move would be constitutional. According to the Constitution Act of 1867, Parliament has residual powers to make laws for Canada's peace, order, and good government, which could potentially override provincial control over natural resources…

Josh Dehaas: A Carney oil blockade would be playing with fire, even if constitutional (this article)13 articles from National Post on this story
CBC11 Sep

The article reports on the election promises of major parties in Quebec's 2026 election, specifically focusing on child care and family benefits. Coalition Avenir Québec is promising a back-to-school supplement of up to $250 per child, a tax credit for up to 75% of school-day child-care fees, and conversion of 10,000 private child-care spots into subsidized ones. The party estimates that over half a million children…

See what Quebec's major party leaders are promising during the election campaign →7 articles from CBC on this story
The Globe and Mail9 Sep

U.S. President Donald Trump has issued an executive order banning imports of Canadian alcohol, motorcycles, and some dairy products in response to Canada's countertariffs. The ban affects a broad range of alcoholic beverages, including beer sold in cans and bottles, rye whisky, and various types of wine. A recent poll by Nanos Research found that 80% of Canadians support or somewhat support dollar-for-dollar…

Morning Update: Adversity ahead →7 articles from The Globe and Mail on this story
Time11 Sep

Lynn Henderson, a 47-year-old Canadian consumer from British Columbia, is one of many Canadians boycotting American products due to the ongoing trade dispute between the two countries. According to a Build Canada poll, 69% of respondents reported choosing Canadian products despite higher prices and 55% said they had stopped buying specific American brands. The "Buy Canadian" movement has been revived amid a…

'Buy Canadian': Meet the Consumers Boycotting American Products as Trade Rift Widens →3 articles from Time on this story
Toronto Star6 Sep

Prime Minister Mark Carney announced that Canada's counter-tariffs will take effect on Tuesday on $28 billion worth of U.S. products, a response to the United States imposing tariffs on Canadian goods. Financial conference Scotiabank's global banking and markets financial summit starts on Wednesday, amid growing concerns about the Canadian economy due to the trade war with the US. Transat A.T. Inc., an airline…

Five things to watch for in the Canadian business world in the coming week →3 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Global News9 Sep

The escalating US-Canada trade dispute has taken center stage in Quebec's provincial election campaign, with major parties offering competing visions on how to protect jobs and businesses from tariffs. The CAQ leader, Christine Fréchette, unveiled measures aimed at shielding Quebec's economy, including prioritizing Quebec-made goods and changing the public procurement process to favor Canadian firms over US…

Trade war takes centre stage in Quebec election campaign →3 articles from Global News on this story
Show 12 more outlets
The Guardian8 Sep

Canada has imposed retaliatory tariffs on $20bn worth of US imports, effective at 12:01am on Tuesday, in response to US President Donald Trump's decision to impose a 50% tariff on Canadian goods. The targeted sectors include steel, dairy, appliances, and electronics, with tariffs ranging from 15% to 50%. Tensions between the two countries have intensified, with Trump criticizing Canada's trade practices and making…

Canada’s retaliatory US tariffs take effect as trade dispute grows →2 articles from The Guardian on this story
The Independent6 Sep

American tourism organizations are trying to woo back Canadian visitors who boycotted the US due to President Trump's comments about making Canada the 51st state and the ongoing trade war, which has resulted in import taxes of up to 50% on Canadian products. According to Statistics Canada, Canadian residents made 25 percent fewer return border crossings and spent $2.4 billion less on travel to the US last year…

The US wants to win Canadian visitors back, but tourists say ‘it’s a wasted effort’ →2 articles from The Independent on this story
Reason11 Sep

Canada has imposed a 50% tariff on aluminum ferrules used in pencil manufacturing as part of its retaliatory measures against US tariffs. This specific product was swept into the conflict because it is made of aluminum, which is subject to the same tariff under US Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930. The Canadian countermeasures match US tariffs dollar for dollar and rate for rate, resulting in a de facto 50% tax…

A 50% Tariff on Pencil Parts? Welcome to the U.S.-Canada Trade War. →2 articles from Reason on this story
Fox News5 Sep

The US Justice Department's antitrust division has been ordered by its chief, Lynda Marshall, to pause all work with the Canadian government amid intensifying trade tensions between the two countries. According to a report, officials were instructed to halt cooperation on cases and policy issues starting from Wednesday, but the DOJ disputes this claim, saying only that a meeting was delayed for preparation. The…

DOJ ordered to freeze antitrust work with Canada as trade tensions intensify →
ABC News (AU)6 Sep

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney ended comprehensive trade negotiations with the US two weeks ago, and Canadians are now bracing for potential economic consequences. Canada is already facing tariffs on key exports such as steel, lumber, and automobiles. According to a recent poll, three-quarters of Canadians approved of Carney's decision to walk away from trade talks. Trade consultant Kelly Ann Shaw notes that…

The US-Canada 'divorce' and the $1.2 trillion fallout →
The Free Press8 Sep

A columnist for This Week in Canada argues that Americans are unaware that Canada views them as enemies, citing recent surveys showing a significant shift in Canadian attitudes towards the US. According to a Leger survey, 41% of Canadians now see the US as an "enemy country", up from 26% since June 2025. A Politico poll found that nearly half of Canadians consider the US a bigger threat to world peace than Russia…

This Week in Canada: America Is Our Enemy and Doesn’t Even Know It →
BBC8 Sep

Canada has imposed retaliatory tariffs on US goods worth nearly C$28bn ($20bn; £15bn) as of Tuesday, in response to the ongoing trade tensions between the two countries. The counter-tariffs, which range from 15% to 50%, affect hundreds of American products, including steel, furniture, and clothing. Despite both sides expressing a desire for a deal, US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer suggests that Canada is…

Canada braces for prolonged trade war as counter-tariffs on US take effect →
ABC News (US)9 Sep

President Donald Trump has issued proclamations to ban certain Canadian goods, including alcohol and dairy products, from entering the US starting September 29. The banned items include sparkling grape wine, whey protein, and non-alcoholic beer, among others. A total of 50% tariff will also be imposed on additional goods, such as golf carts and bamboo furniture. Trump's move comes in response to Canada's retaliatory…

Trump ratchets up trade war, moves to ban many Canadian goods from entering US →
Semafor9 Sep

A senior Trump administration official said that despite escalating tensions, the countries will try to negotiate an offramp from their trade dispute. The US has imposed new tariffs on Canadian goods after Canada retaliated with its own tariffs, further escalating the trade war between the two nations. A key North American trade pact, the USMCA, is now likely to be renewed, as it faces opposition due to the ongoing…

US-Canada trade war escalates amid tit-for-tat tariffs →
Al Jazeera9 Sep

Al Jazeera's Yasmeen ElTahan reports on the ongoing US-Canada trade war from an explanatory angle. The article doesn't provide specific numbers or a concrete timeline, but it appears to be ongoing. The trade war is affecting various products, including toilet paper, which has become unexpectedly entangled in the dispute.

The losers of the US-Canada trade war →
Los Angeles Times9 Sep

A trade war between the US and Canada has escalated as Ottawa's retaliatory tariffs on American goods took effect, imposing duties of up to 50% on over $20 billion in U.S. imports. President Trump had previously imposed tariffs on Canadian exports, prompting a breakdown in trade talks between the two countries. In response to the new tariffs, Trump threatened to remove access for Canadian businesses to key American…

Canada's tariffs go into effect, spotlighting soured relations with U.S. →
NPR11 Sep

The US-Canada trade war is causing headaches for auto-parts makers due to tariffs on aluminum and steel, which have been enacted by both countries since August and January respectively. Canada has imposed retaliatory tariffs on various US goods, including steel and aluminum, adding to the uncertainty faced by major carmakers. According to analysts, the smaller businesses that supply big companies with thousands of…

The U.S.-Canada trade war is creating a headache for auto-parts makers →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 27% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
National Post
Leans right further right than this Hedges 2 of 5 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Globe and Mail
Leans strongly right further right than this Hedges 3 of 28 claims Outlet record 51/100
National Post
Leans left Hedges 6 of 32 claims Outlet record 60/100
CBC News
Leans right further right than this Hedges 14 of 89 claims Outlet record 72/100
National Post
Leans left Hedges 3 of 34 claims Outlet record 60/100
“Article A discusses the possibility of Prime Minister Mark Carney blocking oil exports to give Canada leverage in the trade war, while Article B mentions a finance minister announcing that the federal gasoline tax will not be re-imposed”

Story

U.S.-Canada Trade War Escalates
Economy/Business · 54 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
26
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
27%
7 of 26 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
60/100
National Post's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
54
Economy/Business
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-03 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

National Post · 1242 article(s) · 2 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 2 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Special to National Post
104 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
As the incoming B.C. Conservative government prepares to deliver on its promise to repeal the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA), Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, president of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, stated this week that doing so would be a “declaration of war.”
Buying through us may earn us a commission, which supports our work.
Based on a leaked draft “EU-Canada Joint Summit Statement,” much progress is expected to be made at the summit in areas such as defence and security, critical resources and digital research and communications technologies.
Last month, the Law Society of Ontario (LSO) did not agree to a formal request from 10 lawyers who wished to add to their Annual General Meeting (AGM) agenda a motion that could have revoked accreditation from Toronto Metropolitan University’s (TMU) Lincoln Alexander School of Law.
Buying through us may earn us a commission, which supports our work.
2026-10-28 · assertive framing · On the map: A new view of renting in Hamilton
It’s the story of one student, but it could be any student at any North American university.
Work, save, take a risk, start a company, buy a home, raise a family; the expectation held that effort might lead somewhere and that children could inherit better prospects than their parents.
Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon has vowed to defund the office of the lieutenant governor, said he will seek legal advice on keeping the Crown’s representative out of the opening of the legislature and has promised to cut Quebec’s ties to the monarchy.
St-Pierre Plamondon will lead a minority government, five seats short of a majority, and has promised to wait until Donald Trump leaves the White House in January 2029 before holding a sovereignty referendum.
As we wrap up a month of what has the potential to be one of the biggest missteps in British Columbia, or Canadian, political history, it bears examining whether David Eby’s attempt to position himself as a modern day Joseph McCarthy dedicated to rooting out thought criminals from his opposition will be ultimately effective.
Also by Special to National Post
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 104 articles by Special to National Post →

Topics

Alberta Canada Ontario Ottawa the United States

Subjects

Alberta GPE · 8× Canada GPE · 4× The Supreme Court ORG · 3× Carney PERSON · 2× Ottawa ORG · 2× Pierre Trudeau PERSON · 2× the United States GPE · 2× Doug Ford PERSON · 1× Mark Carney PERSON · 1× Ontario GPE · 1×

Narrative

Here Alberta’s argument would be stronger, but one would expect the federal government to push back by arguing the embargo is within its jurisdiction under peace, order and good government, either because it’s an emergency or a national concern.
framing: mixed · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-03
The Constitution Act of 1867 assigns all matters that governments may regulate exclusively to either the provinces or the feds, and provides a residual power to Parliament to “make laws for the peace, order, and good government of Canada, in relation to all matters not coming within the classes of subjects by this act assigned exclusively to the legislatures of the provinces.” It’s not always easy to assign a matter exclusively to one level of government.

Claims (26 extracted, 7 hedged)

Ontario Premier Doug Ford says the federal government should consider blocking oil exports to the United States to give Canada leverage in the trade war that’s now hitting that province hard. asserted
that → say → province
“Although I understand the need to respond strongly to these tariffs, I cannot think of a more disastrous policy decision than cutting off or taxing Alberta’s oil to the United States,” she said. asserted
she → understand → States
This means the metaphorical taps are now in Prime Minister Mark Carney’s hands. asserted
taps → mean → hands
But can Carney really cut off or put an export tax on Alberta oil without violating the constitutional division of powers? asserted
Carney → cut → powers
The answer is probably yes, but don’t expect Alberta to go down without a fight. asserted
Alberta → expect → fight
The Constitution Act of 1867 assigns all matters that governments may regulate exclusively to either the provinces or the feds, and provides a residual power to Parliament to “make laws for the peace, order, and good government of Canada, in relation to all matters not coming within the classes of subjects by this act assigned exclusively to the legislatures of the provinces.” It’s not always easy to assign a matter exclusively to one level of government. uncertain
It → assign → government
The court has developed certain rules to deal with this reality, but it’s not always clear how they will be applied. asserted
they → develop → reality
For example, if two laws are in conflict and it’s impossible to comply with both laws, the federal law may prevail under the doctrine of paramountcy. uncertain
law → ’ → paramountcy
That said, if a law intrudes on the “core” or the “basic, minimum and unassailable content” of the other order of government’s powers, it may be deemed inapplicable under the doctrine of interjurisdictional immunity. uncertain
it → say → immunity
One thing that’s clear under the Constitution is who owns the oil (and forests … and potash). asserted
who → ’ → oil
Canada transferred ownership of natural resources to the Prairie provinces through the Natural Resources Transfer Agreements and related acts, which became part of the Constitution in 1930. asserted
which → transfer → 1930
It’s also clear that Alberta has exclusive control over the “development, conservation and management of non-renewable natural resources and forestry resources in the province.” asserted
Alberta → ’ → province
That’s from the text of Section 92A, which was added to the Constitution Act of 1982 at Alberta’s insistence. asserted
which → ’ → insistence
If the provinces own their natural resources and have control over their development, how can Ottawa impose embargoes or taxes that would stifle their sale or development? asserted
that → own → sale
It turns out, Ottawa would have a number of strong arguments. asserted
Ottawa → turn → arguments
First, it could point to the 1982 Supreme Court decision in the Exported Natural Gas Tax Reference, where the court examined a federal tax proposed by the Pierre Trudeau government on natural gas, including on exported natural gas, which Alberta opposed. uncertain
Alberta → point → which
Alberta argued that Section 125 of the Constitution Act of 1867, which says, “No lands or property belonging to Canada or any province shall be liable to taxation,” blocked the proposed tax. asserted
lands → argue → tax
The Supreme Court ruled that the proposed tax was a valid exercise of the federal taxation power outlined under Section 91(3) of the act. asserted
tax → rule → act
The court also reasoned that this was not an export tax because it applied also to Canadian consumers, but had it been an export tax, the federal government may have been able to impose that anyway under its “trade and commerce” power, as it had long done with customs duties. So what about a total embargo? uncertain
it → reason → embargo
Here Alberta’s argument would be stronger, but one would expect the federal government to push back by arguing the embargo is within its jurisdiction under peace, order and good government, either because it’s an emergency or a national concern. asserted
it → expect → peace
In 1976, a majority of the Supreme Court held in the Anti-Inflation Act Reference that the Pierre Trudeau government’s price controls aimed at runaway inflation were a valid exercise of that power. asserted
controls → hold → power
More recently, in 2021, the Supreme Court upheld the federal carbon tax as a national concern in the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act References. asserted
Court → uphold → References
Of course, legal arguments aside, it seems obvious the Carney government would be playing with fire by blocking oil exports. asserted
government → seem → exports
While such a move might play well in Ontario and Quebec, Albertans are angry enough about the lost years of oil sands production that have already occurred. uncertain
that → play → production
Any move Carney makes now could antagonize Alberta right before it votes on whether to hold a separation referendum. uncertain
it → make → referendum
National Post Josh Dehaas is Interim Litigation Director with the Canadian Constitution Foundation, a charity that fights for Canadians’ rights and freedoms. asserted
that → fight → rights
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support