In short:
The Coalition and the Greens are calling on the Attorney-General to set up an independent audit after several court data breaches.
asserted
Coalition → call → breaches
New emails reveal Federal Court CEO Sia Lagos was notified of a 2014 breach.
asserted
Lagos → reveal → breach
The Federal Court said it was reviewing a report into the latest data breach.
asserted
it → say → breach
The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner is also looking into the issue.
asserted
Office → look → issue
An integrity crisis in Australia's court system has deepened, prompting calls from the Coalition and the Greens for the Attorney-General to step in and set up an independent audit.
asserted
General → deepen → audit
Revelations that highly sensitive court data was accessed in India on at least two occasions has sparked national security fears.
asserted
data → access → fears
Now, internal court emails have revealed the Federal Court CEO was notified in 2016 of the first data breach — an incident for which no action was taken.
asserted
action → reveal → which
However, a spokesperson for the Federal Court said its CEO, Sia Lagos, had no recollection of having been notified of the data breach by the then-deputy principal registrar.
asserted
CEO → say → registrar
Security concerns were first raised in 2014 by former Auscript national manager, Paul Cutbush, who made Public Interest Disclosures (PID) to both the family court and the Federal Court as well as the Australian Federal Police (AFP) about the offshoring of sensitive data.
asserted
who → raise → data
In an email from then-Deputy Principal Registrar of the Federal Court John Mathieson to Mr Cutbush in 2016 he stated:
"I have notified Ms Sia Lagos, who is Acting Chief Executive Officer and Principal Registrar of the Federal Court, in Mr Soden's absence, as I am required to do so, of the decisions and determinations I have made under the [Public Interest Disclosure] Act."
asserted
I → state → Act
A spokesperson for the Federal Court of Australia said it was "not accepted that there has been a failure to act" in either the data breach earlier this year or the historical incident.
asserted
it → say → breach
"Ms Lagos did not have any recollection of a procedural notification she had received almost 10 years earlier concerning the Family Court of Australia and matters pre-dating the present administrative entity," the spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → have → entity
"Beyond that single notification, Ms Lagos had no involvement in the management of this matter."
asserted
Lagos → have → matter
Neither the Federal Court, nor the family court acted on the disclosures made to them by Mr Cutbush in 2014.
asserted
Court → act → 2014
The family court responded two years after the disclosures were made, classifying the breach as "minor and inconsequential" in emails seen by the ABC.
asserted
disclosures → respond → ABC
The family court has denied any current executives had knowledge of the first breach despite Mr Cutbush's disclosures.
asserted
executives → deny → disclosures
Last week, Mr Cutbush said the most recent data breach was a "slap in the face" after his concerns were ignored in 2014.
asserted
concerns → say → 2014
Auscript was responsible for court transcription services in 2014 before VIQ Solutions took over around 2020.
asserted
Solutions → take → 2020
A second data breach occurred earlier this year when VIQ was managing transcription services and the company was shutdown shortly after.
asserted
company → occur → services
Cases heard in the Federal Court include critical human rights matters, industrial relations cases, taxation law and matters involving multi-million-dollar corporations while the Federal Circuit and Family Court hears migration cases, and matters involving child sexual abuse, domestic violence and property settlements.
asserted
Circuit → hear → abuse
It is unclear how many files were accessed in India during either of the offshoring incidents.
uncertain
files → access → incidents
'Warning signs ignored by court leadership':
asserted
signs → ignore → leadership
Greens
A spokesperson for Attorney-General Michelle Rowland said the courts were "responsible for their own operation and management" — a position ridiculed by the Opposition.
asserted
courts → say → Opposition
Shadow Attorney-General Michaelia Cash said the latest developments strengthened the need for a full independent audit coordinated by the Attorney-General.
asserted
developments → say → General
"I again call on the Attorney-General to take control of this matter and organise a whole-of-government response," she said.
"
asserted
she → call → response
We need to know what has occurred and how widespread this issue is.
asserted
issue → need → ?
It is not good enough for the Attorney-General to keep her head in the sand."
asserted
General → keep → sand
Greens Leader Senator David Shoebridge took aim at the court's leadership.
asserted
Shoebridge → take → leadership
"It's almost impossible to believe that we are now facing another round of obfuscation from the Federal Court," he said.
asserted
he → believe → Court
"These data breach issues date back to 2014 and it appears that at least some senior staff members of the court have known this.
asserted
members → date → this
This requires a prompt and public explanation from the court.
"
asserted
This → require → court
Family court transcripts hold some of the most private and painful moments in people's lives, and twice now that material has gone offshore while the warning signs were ignored by the leadership of the court.
asserted
signs → hold → court
The Attorney-General keeps saying the responsibility is solely with the court, but the fact is the listed entity is under her administrative authority so she also has a clear role here.
asserted
she → keep → role
The Attorney-General should order a forensic audit across every agency in her portfolio that used Auscript and VIQ transcription services to provide people with real certainty about what on earth happened with their sensitive court data."
asserted
what → order → data
The Federal Court said it was currently reviewing a report by CyberCX into the latest data breach.
asserted
it → say → breach
A privacy complaint has also been passed on to the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) regarding the offshoring of Australian citizen's data.
asserted
complaint → pass → data
The Federal Court said it had provided information to the OAIC and the family court said it would "fully cooperate" with the OAIC or any other government inquiry.
asserted
it → say → OAIC
The Aporia