As President Donald Trump seeks to intensify his crackdown on what he characterizes as widespread illegal voting by noncitizens, several individuals charged with that crime are attempting a novel legal strategy to get their federal cases dropped entirely.
asserted
cases → seek → strategy
According to a Reuters review of court filings, five people being prosecuted in separate federal cases in Miami and Madison, Wisconsin, have argued for the very first time in court that the 1996 law used to charge them is unconstitutional.
uncertain
law → accord → them
A favorable ruling for the defense, which could arrive before the November 3 midterm elections, would raise serious questions about the federal government's authority to prosecute noncitizen voting cases.
uncertain
which → arrive → cases
The Trump administration has aggressively pushed to deport noncitizens accused of voting, raising the stakes for defendants who previously faced penalties as small as a $150 fine if convicted.
asserted
who → push → fine
The defendants stand accused of violating the federal "Voting by Aliens" statute enacted nearly three decades ago.
asserted
defendants → stand → statute
The law makes it illegal for noncitizens to vote in federal elections, and violators can be fined up to $100,000 or imprisoned for up to a year.
asserted
violators → make → year
In the five cases Reuters identified, defendants have asserted that the constitutional right to determine voter qualifications belongs exclusively to U.S. states.
asserted
right → identify → states
While every state requires voters to be citizens, defendants argue that it is up to state governments to prosecute any violations, not the federal government.
asserted
it → require → violations
Trump's Justice Department has argued that the Supreme Court has repeatedly recognized Congress's clear authority to protect election integrity and has passed laws such as one criminalizing repeat voting in the same election.
asserted
Court → argue → election
In addition, the DOJ has argued the statute does not regulate state elections but focuses directly on immigration, an area where Congress holds explicit constitutional authority to legislate.
asserted
Congress → argue → authority
The statute was part of the sweeping Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, which prosecutors compared to congressional limits on foreign campaign contributions that courts have upheld.
asserted
courts → compare → that
Defendants across the five cases hope presiding judges rule to dismiss the charges on constitutional grounds before their trials begin.
asserted
trials → hope → grounds
The first trial is set for October 5, with the final trial scheduled to start on December 14.
asserted
trial → set → December
Trump, who has repeatedly made unsubstantiated claims regarding widespread voter fraud while questioning the legitimacy of U.S. election outcomes, has asserted that noncitizen voting is a widespread problem that undermines the overall integrity of American polls.
uncertain
that → make → polls
However, a Reuters analysis published on July 19 showed noncitizen voting is exceptionally rare.
asserted
voting → publish → July
Only 129 people have been charged in the law's 30-year history.
asserted
people → charge → history
The typical defendant was a lawful permanent resident with deep community ties who voted in the mistaken belief they were permitted to do so.
asserted
they → vote → belief
In the midterm elections, when presidents' parties typically suffer losses, Trump's Republicans are fighting to retain control of Congress.
asserted
Republicans → suffer → Congress
Experts have noted that the president's repeated assertions about widespread noncitizen voting could be intended to sow doubts about the election's legitimacy if Democrats gain control of Congress.
uncertain
Democrats → note → Congress
Until Trump's second term, most defendants charged with noncitizen voting negotiated deals to plead guilty and were often sentenced to fines of around $150, similar to a standard traffic ticket.
asserted
defendants → charge → ticket
However, the Trump administration began pushing to deport noncitizen voters last year, raising the stakes for defendants.
asserted
administration → begin → defendants
The initial constitutional challenge in a noncitizen voting case was raised in March by Christian Erazo Valdez, an Ecuadorian citizen, according to federal court records in Madison, Wisconsin.
uncertain
challenge → raise → Madison
He was charged in October with voting in the 2024 presidential election, and a decision on his dismissal motion is expected soon.
asserted
decision → charge → motion
Another judge is scheduled to hear oral arguments on the constitutional argument Tuesday.
asserted
judge → schedule → argument
U.S. District Court Judge David Leibowitz in Miami is overseeing a case against Chelsea Cox, a Jamaican woman charged with voting in the 2020 federal election.
asserted
Leibowitz → oversee → election
In June, he said he wanted outside legal advice on the statute's constitutionality.
asserted
he → say → constitutionality
The judge enlisted Paul Clement, former solicitor general in the administration of Republican President George W. Bush, who submitted a 43-page report to the court in July stating Congress likely lacked authority to enact the law, though he noted the legal issue was "not entirely clear-cut."
asserted
issue → enlist → law
In a sixth case, a judge denied a defendant's motion to dismiss, siding with the Justice Department.
asserted
judge → deny → Department
Judge Jacqueline Becerra in Miami issued that ruling on September 9 against Wilner Renaud, a Haitian citizen who entered the United States in 1993, according to court records.
uncertain
who → issue → records
Renaud had a pending application for U.S. citizenship when he voted in the 2022 federal election and told government investigators he believed he was already a U.S. citizen, according to court records.
uncertain
he → have → records
Renaud's case went to trial on Monday.
asserted
case → go → Monday
The Aporia
