Pakistan’s laws aimed at protecting journalists from threats and attacks risk remaining largely “on paper” unless the federal and provincial safety commissions are given more powers, accessible complaint mechanisms and the resources needed to deliver timely protection, says a new report released by Freedom Network, a media watchdog, on Wednesday.
asserted
report → aim → Wednesday
The report, titled “From safety on paper to safety in practice”, is an assessment of the work carried out by two commissions — one appointed by the federal government and the other by the Sindh government.
asserted
report → title → government
The Islamabad-based Freedom Network produced the research with assistance from the International Media Support (IMS).
asserted
Network → base → Support
Authored by Minahil Shahab and Adnan Rehmat, the report examined the commissions’ capacity and operational constraints through consultations with stakeholders, interviews and a baseline online survey of around 40 working journalists in Sindh, including respondents from the province’s rural areas.
asserted
report → author → areas
According to report, 65pc of respondents say they have faced work-related threats or interference
According to the report, parliament enacted two special laws to combat impunity for crimes against journalists and the media in 2022.
uncertain
parliament → accord → 2022
Both the federal and Sindh governments instituted commissions to enforce the laws.
asserted
governments → institute → laws
The online survey found 70 per cent of the respondents knew a provincial protection law existed, but 65pc of them did not know where to find the commission’s office, obtain information, website or complaint route.
asserted
65pc → find → information
Sixty-five per cent of the respondents reported experiencing work-related threats or interference since 2021.
asserted
cent → report → 2021
These findings describe the surveyed group rather than establishing province-wide prevalence.
asserted
findings → describe → prevalence
Challenges pinpointed
asserted
Challenges → pinpoint → ?
The assessment identified distinct institutional challenges.
asserted
assessment → identify → challenges
Kamal Uddin Tipu, the federal commission’s chairperson, spoke of staffing, budget, and administrative constraints during the research.
asserted
Tipu → speak → research
With the federal commission now operational, the priority is to ensure that its personnel, resources and complaint systems support timely protection and sustained follow-up.
asserted
personnel → ensure → protection
In Sindh, the report documented an established institution with premises, meetings, complaints and engagement with police and media organisations.
asserted
report → document → police
However, union representatives and non-official members described delayed responses, limited outreach beyond Karachi and dependence on police replies.
asserted
representatives → describe → replies
The Sindh commission’s chairperson, Aijaz Ahmed Memon, disputed suggestions that journalists lacked trust in the institution and reported improvements in coordination, case activity and outreach plans.
The report also highlighted media employers’ responsibilities.
asserted
report → dispute → responsibilities
Fifty-one per cent of the respondents said employers had not informed them about safety procedures, emergency contacts, insurance, legal assistance or complaint mechanisms.
asserted
employers → say → procedures
The Sindh chairperson separately reported that 44 media outlets had not replied to the commission’s queries.
asserted
outlets → report → queries
Recommendations include confidential and accessible complaint routes, urgent risk assessment, designated caseworkers, police escalation procedures, stronger employer cooperation and publication of anonymised outcomes and spending.
asserted
Recommendations → include → outcomes
The report said amendments needed to be framed carefully in order to address documented legal barriers.
asserted
amendments → say → barriers
The Freedom Network called for coordinated action by governments, commissions, police, media employers and journalist organisations to deliver positive results and ensure that journalists can obtain effective assistance when threats arise.
asserted
threats → call → assistance
The Aporia
