Only two months ago, a group called Compassion in Politics Australia gained the first signatory to its "Civility Pledge".
asserted
group → call → Pledge
The organisation, based on a similar foundation in the United Kingdom, aims to turn the tide of toxic debate and build a better politics.
asserted
organisation → base → politics
As a start, it's asking elected officials to sign a simple pledge.
asserted
it → ask → pledge
"In my political life, I pledge to act with honesty, respect, and compassion," is all it states.
asserted
it → pledge → honesty
This week the independent MP was the victim of an attack widely described as shocking but unsurprising.
asserted
MP → describe → attack
Sadly predictable, was the common reaction amongst MPs who have been at the receiving end of increasing threats and harassment.
asserted
who → receive → threats
Yesterday, security agencies briefed MPs on the risks to their safety.
asserted
agencies → brief → safety
Security will no doubt be improved as much as is practicable, without sacrificing the critical ability of MPs to interact in their communities.
asserted
Security → improve → communities
The more difficult question is what, if anything, can be done about the increasingly hostile political environment.
asserted
what → do → environment
What can be done to restore the "civility" that Haines, at least, pledged to pursue?
asserted
Haines → do → that
Civility was the word emphasised by the Governor-General late yesterday, who stood alongside the husband of Helen Haines in an effort to calm a worried nation.
asserted
who → emphasise → nation
"We don't have to all agree, but we can wrestle with the issue not the person," Sam Mostyn said from Melbourne's Alfred Hospital.
asserted
Mostyn → have → Hospital
Her message echoed the call to turn the temperature down.
asserted
message → echo → temperature
"Words matter, whether spoken or in written form or increasingly in the virtual world.
asserted
Words → matter → world
This call for civility is something ASIO boss Mike Burgess has been going on about now for years.
"
asserted
Burgess → go → years
I genuinely believe the temperature of our security environment would be several degrees lower if we recommitted to conversing with civility, debating with respect and disagreeing with restraint," he said after the attack on Haines.
asserted
he → believe → Haines
Burgess draws a line between words and actions: "ASIO has seen direct correlations between inflamed language, inflamed tensions and acts of violence."
The intelligence chief must feel at times he's talking to a brick wall.
asserted
he → draw → wall
He warned against "inflamed language" and called for a return to civility after the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel in 2023, again after lifting the terrorism threat level to "probable" in 2024, and again after the Bondi terrorist attack in 2025.
asserted
He → warn → 2025
Will anyone listen this time?
asserted
anyone → listen → ?
Will an attack on one of their own force politicians to re-think their part in setting the tone of political discourse?
asserted
attack → force → discourse
"We should all, every single one of us, me included, find ways to minimise the temperature of these debates," said shadow minister Jono Duniam, who will soon depart the Senate.
asserted
who → include → Senate
"We could all do better.
uncertain
We → do → ?
I don't exclude myself or any political party," acknowledged the prime minister who, like Burgess, has repeatedly called for a more civil debate.
asserted
who → exclude → debate
Opposition Leader Angus Taylor, by contrast, is worried about limiting robust argument.
asserted
Taylor → worry → argument
While condemning anything that intimidates or incites violence, he defended the role of vigorous debate.
asserted
he → condemn → debate
"We have, like so few other countries in the world, avoided political violence.
asserted
We → avoid → violence
This is part of the great Australian achievement, and we've done that by having vigorous and rigorous debate and choice at the ballot box," he said.
asserted
he → do → box
"This is what's worked for us.
asserted
what → work → us
We need to make sure it stays there."
It's certainly true — Australia has long enjoyed robust political debate while largely avoiding political violence.
asserted
Australia → need → violence
But this misses the point being made by the ASIO boss.
asserted
this → miss → boss
Times have changed.
asserted
Times → change → ?
We're now in an environment, according to Burgess, where "politically motivated violence is more likely than previous years".
uncertain
violence → accord → years
Angus Taylor's own colleagues can recognise the deterioration, too.
asserted
colleagues → recognise → deterioration
"It's clear that the political environment has become more heated in recent years," said shadow minister James Paterson.
asserted
Paterson → become → years
"In the last few years things have gotten much worse," said independent MP Monique Ryan, adding that "the 2025 election was completely different to 2022", with more aggression and anger.
asserted
election → get → aggression
So, what does it take to turn the temperature down?
asserted
it → take → temperature
"Gosh, if only I could say what the answer to that is," One Nation's Barnaby Joyce admitted on Radio National yesterday.
uncertain
Joyce → say → National
"I don't know," he said.
asserted
he → know → ?
It's rare to hear Barnaby Joyce stumped for an answer on anything.
asserted
Joyce → hear → anything
He's certainly not accepting any blame on the part of One Nation for raising the temperature.
asserted
He → accept → temperature
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
