- Published
Google is facing a backlash from some staff members over the company's deployment of its AI technology for military use.
asserted
Google → publish → use
The BBC has spoken to several tech workers who have either recently resigned from Google's AI company, Google DeepMind, or are in the process of leaving, over concerns with the tech firm's military contracts.
asserted
who → speak → contracts
Sofia Liguori, a London-based research engineer, is one of them.
asserted
Liguori → base → them
She resigned from Google DeepMind this week and spoke about her concerns exclusively with the BBC, despite her contract restricting her from doing so.
asserted
She → resign → her
"Realising my company is pushing more and more for AI systems in military operations makes me feel ashamed to work at Google," Liguori said, speaking in a personal capacity.
asserted
Liguori → realise → capacity
In response, a Google spokesperson told the BBC: "We work with public sector organisations worldwide and follow a consistent process for reviewing and entering these contracts, including compliance with our acceptable use policies and AI principles."
"We also have dedicated channels for employees to safely raise any concerns - ranging from business ethics to misconduct - and have strict workplace policies in place to prevent retaliation of any kind."
asserted
employees → tell → kind
Google is one of several tech companies that signed contracts with the US military earlier this year to deploy AI across classified military environments.
asserted
that → sign → environments
The US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth has made integrating AI into the armed forces a key priority, saying the Trump administration will become an "AI-first warfighting force".
asserted
administration → make → forces
But AI technology is evolving rapidly, and critics question whether it is reliable enough to be used in warfare without more testing, stronger guardrails and human oversight.
asserted
it → evolve → testing
After working for the company for three years, Liguori said she decided to resign over Google's increasing work with the US and Israeli militaries.
asserted
she → work → militaries
"I don't agree with this direction and this has led me to lose faith in my company being true to its stated ethical values," she said.
asserted
she → agree → values
Those values, according to Google's AI Principles, external, include implementing AI with "human oversight" and aligning the technology with "international law and human rights".
uncertain
values → accord → law
But former and current staff at the company, and experts the BBC spoke to, said they were concerned about the level of human oversight at critical moments.
asserted
they → speak → moments
The tech workers said they are particularly worried about the AI military deals signed this year, because they greatly increase the scope of what the Pentagon can use the technology for.
asserted
Pentagon → say → technology
Andreas Kirsch, an AI researcher, also resigned from Google DeepMind earlier this month over his concerns.
asserted
Kirsch → resign → concerns
Kirsch told the BBC that he believes "Google's governance and oversight are not sufficient or meaningful enough to deploy AI safely and responsibly in military and classified settings" or "to develop artificial superintelligence safely in the future."
asserted
governance → tell → future
"Google seems to have no right to control or veto how the Pentagon uses its AI and also seems to have limited visibility into how it's being deployed," he added.
asserted
he → seem → visibility
In the past few years, the US military has deployed multiple AI-enabled technologies to help advance its warfighting abilities.
asserted
military → deploy → abilities
The most prominent example of this is Maven Smart Systems, the Pentagon's main software platform for organising intelligence and data.
asserted
example → organise → intelligence
Developed by US defence company Palantir, it uses AI to help personnel select and identify targets to strike.
asserted
personnel → develop → targets
Palantir has integrated the technology from several leading AI companies into Maven, and it has enabled some processes to be significantly speeded up.
asserted
it → integrate → processes
Retired Lieutenant General Jack Shanahan, who is the former director of Project Maven, said the "philosophy" seems to be: "Go as fast as possible to deploy [AI technology] as widely as possible, potentially at the expense of the rigour and discipline of test and evaluation.
asserted
philosophy → retire → test
However, the Pentagon has maintained that adopting AI technologies is essential for winning wars.
asserted
adopting → maintain → wars
"Speed defines victory in the AI era," said Emil Michael, an under secretary in the US Department of Defense, in a statement earlier this year.
asserted
Michael → define → statement
Google's contract with the Pentagon, which was signed earlier this year, allows its AI technology to be used for classified military work.
asserted
technology → sign → work
The agreement says Google's AI models can be used for "any lawful government purpose" and "should not be used for domestic mass surveillance or autonomous weapons (including target selection) without appropriate human oversight and control".
asserted
models → say → oversight
Similar contracts were signed by OpenAI, Amazon, Microsoft, SpaceX, Oracle, Nvidia, and the start-up Reflection, to allow AI technology to be deployed across a range of military settings such as transport, planning and battlefield operations.
asserted
technology → sign → transport
As the tech quickly evolves, concerns are growing about the use of AI in theatres of war.
asserted
concerns → evolve → war
"AI compresses the time an operator has to make a decision because it works much faster than a person, and that's especially risky in a high-stress environment," said Sarah Shoker, formerly head of OpenAI's Geopolitics team.
asserted
Shoker → compress → team
"When you have hundreds of targets that are selected by AI and a short amount of time, it is almost impossible for a human operator to meaningfully review the AI's outputs for errors.
asserted
operator → have → errors
"
Employees at Google have told the BBC that staff are scared to speak out about AI safety and its uses in warfare because their employment contracts prohibit them from publicly criticising the company.
asserted
contracts → tell → company
"In principle I'm not allowed to criticise Google for the duration of my life," Sofia Liguori told the BBC.
asserted
Liguori → allow → BBC
But she decided to do so "because I believe it's important for these things to be known and I also think that talking about facts is not criticising".
asserted
talking → decide → facts
Liguori added that at Google "people are scared of retaliation and putting their career at risk.
asserted
people → add → risk
You feel you are being watched, you can't speak."
asserted
you → feel → ?
A current employee at Google DeepMind, who declined to be named for fear of retaliation, told the BBC that "a lot of motivated employees who signed up for [the company's] original mission could leave – but there's also a pipeline of people at the start of the careers who could fill those positions.
uncertain
who → decline → positions
Another Google DeepMind staff member, who also wished to remain anonymous, told the BBC: "A lot of people have left the company that feel strongly about this [how Google DeepMind has changed its ethics position]."
"Some people are putting up a fight, others are thinking: 'it's a big company.
asserted
it → wish → fight
you expect to change?'
asserted
you → expect → ?
", the employee said.
asserted
employee → say → ?
Google's agreements with Israel have also caused controversy.
asserted
agreements → cause → controversy
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
