- Published
The Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea has been allowed to start production after years of debates and legal wrangling - but a decision is yet to be taken on the Rosebank oil field off Shetland.
asserted
decision → publish → Shetland
Industry bodies argue that the sites could provide jobs and improve the UK's energy security as overseas conflicts threaten supply.
uncertain
conflicts → argue → supply
Environmentalists insist that more drilling would be unconscionable, hampering efforts to cut planet-warming carbon emissions as deadly heatwaves and extreme weather affect billions across the globe.
asserted
heatwaves → insist → globe
They also say starting production would not protect energy security and that transitioning sooner to greener technologies would be better for supporting jobs.
asserted
transitioning → say → jobs
Jackdaw is a gas field located about 150 miles (241km) east of Aberdeen.
asserted
Jackdaw → locate → Aberdeen
The UK government, which has now given permission for production to begin, says it will be able to start to supplying gas from the end of this month.
asserted
it → give → month
Rosebank, about 80 miles (128km) north-west of Shetland, is Britain's largest untapped oil field, which would also produce some gas.
asserted
which → produce → gas
It would take longer than Jackdaw to become operational, but is scheduled to be up and running by 2027 if approved.
asserted
It → take → 2027
Licences for the fields were granted by the then Conservative UK government in 2022 and 2023 - sparking legal challenges from environmental groups.
asserted
Licences → grant → groups
The Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled last year that Rosebank and Jackdaw had been unlawfully approved because the government had failed to take into account the climate impact of burning extracted oil and gas from the sites.
asserted
government → rule → sites
A judge ruled that more detailed climate assessments had to be published.
asserted
assessments → rule → ?
These updated estimates were put out for consultation.
asserted
estimates → update → consultation
The UK government then had to decide whether to re-approve the fields, with input from industry regulators.
asserted
government → have → regulators
Prime Minister Andy Burnham had previously said he would stick to Labour's promise not to issue new oil and gas licences while honouring existing ones.
asserted
he → say → ones
Would Rosebank and Jackdaw cut energy bills?
asserted
Rosebank → cut → bills
If approved, Rosebank is expected to fill up to 500 million barrels of oil over its 25-year lifetime.
asserted
Rosebank → approve → lifetime
But that increased supply does not necessarily guarantee cheaper energy bills for people in the UK.
asserted
supply → increase → UK
Prices are determined by international markets which are vulnerable to shocks such as the conflicts in Ukraine and Iran.
asserted
which → determine → Ukraine
Most of the oil produced from Rosebank would be sent to the Netherlands because the UK's remaining refineries are not equipped to process the heavier type of crude oil extracted from the North Sea.
asserted
refineries → produce → Sea
If any of the refined products - such as diesel or jet fuel - were to be used in the UK, they would then to be reimported.
asserted
they → refine → UK
When plans for Jackdaw were unveiled in 2022, developers said it would produce enough gas to power 1.4 million homes.
asserted
it → unveil → homes
It would be a relatively simple process to connect Jackdaw to the UK energy system, meaning gas could be quickly pumped to the mainland.
uncertain
gas → connect → mainland
Announcing that the project would go ahead, the UK government said it was expected to increase domestic gas production by around 6% at its peak.
asserted
it → announce → peak
It said that over its 11-year lifespan, Jackdaw would protect hundreds of jobs and add an estimated £2.9bn to the UK economy.
asserted
Jackdaw → say → economy
Backers say opening the fields would improve the UK's energy security.
asserted
opening → say → security
Yet Fatih Birol, a leading energy economist at the International Energy Agency, told The Guardian, external earlier this year that new drilling in the North Sea "would not change much for the UK's energy security" or bring down energy bills.
asserted
drilling → lead → bills
He said that the UK would still be reliant on oil and gas imports, with prices set internationally.
asserted
prices → say → imports
How much CO2 will Rosebank and Jackdaw produce?
asserted
Rosebank → produce → CO2
Both Jackdaw and Rosebank are operated by Adura, a joint venture between Norwegian company Equinor and Shell.
asserted
Jackdaw → operate → Equinor
Aberdeen-based firm Ithaca also owns 20% of Rosebank.
asserted
Ithaca → base → Rosebank
It has estimated that Jackdaw could produce 35.8 million tonnes of carbon over its lifetime, the equivalent of 90% of Scotland's emissions for 2023.
uncertain
Jackdaw → estimate → 2023
Adura said a more likely estimate was about 23.6 million tonnes - equivalent to 60% of the 2023 figure.
asserted
estimate → say → figure
Those figures are dwarfed by the projections for Rosebank - almost 250 million tonnes of planet-warming emissions.
asserted
figures → dwarf → emissions
Yet Adura's updated environmental impact assessment, ordered by the Court of Session, says that emissions from Jackdaw would "not materially influence" global warming.
asserted
emissions → update → warming
The firm says that displacing imported liquified nature gas from the United States with gas from the Jackdaw field would save the equivalent of four million tonnes of CO2.
asserted
displacing → say → CO2
Campaign groups say that would not lower worldwide emissions as the US gas would still be sold and burned elsewhere.
asserted
gas → say → emissions
Adura also said the climate effects would be "minor" because the UK has a "well-regulated industry" aligned with the Paris Agreement, a legally binding commitment to limit global warming to between 1.5 and 2C.
However, Greenpeace UK chief scientist Doug Parr said opening a new field was "wholly incompatible" with the Paris Agreement.
asserted
opening → say → Agreement
How many jobs would Rosebank and Jackdaw support?
asserted
Rosebank → support → jobs
Industry body Offshore Energies UK (OEUK) has said Rosebank and Jackdaw would support a peak of more than 3,500 jobs during the construction phase.
asserted
Rosebank → say → phase
It says the fields would support 880 jobs, external throughout during their lifespans, with an average salary of £85,850.
asserted
fields → say → 85,850
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
