Europe weighs giving utilities, infrastructure companies more powers to bring down drones
Oct 21 -
asserted
Europe → weigh → drones
At a former flight-test base south of Paris, drones swoop over fields and woodland as teams on the ground test systems designed to stop them — a response to a growing wave of drone incursions and "hybrid attacks" since Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022.
asserted
Russia → swoop → 2022
The potential clients for technology such as electronic jammers and interceptor drones tested at the Brétigny-sur-Orge site are no longer just governments, police and armies.
asserted
clients → test → site
Private firms and state entities across Europe that operate critical infrastructure want to strengthen their defences, with some utilities asking for authorisation to shoot drones down themselves.
asserted
utilities → operate → drones
From Paris to Berlin, governments are taking note.
asserted
governments → take → note
They are worried that hybrid warfare or a drone attack could knock out power to millions of people — as has happened frequently in Ukraine after Russian strikes.
uncertain
warfare → worry → strikes
"It is a theoretical, and increasingly a practical, possibility that there could be heating outages this winter due to hybrid attacks," Kristian Ruby, secretary general of European energy body Eurelectric, told Reuters.
uncertain
Ruby → tell → Reuters
Some European governments are responding by starting to give firms powers traditionally confined to the military.
asserted
governments → respond → military
Interviews by Reuters with over 30 company executives, officials and drone experts meanwhile show the technology to detect and bring down drones is maturing faster than the rules on who may use it.
uncertain
who → show → it
Approaches vary widely across Europe and legal uncertainties remain, including over who has the right to order a response to a drone threat.
asserted
who → vary → threat
Bringing down a drone could cause injury or death to people on the ground or damage property, raising questions for companies about liability and accountability.
uncertain
Bringing → bring → liability
France is among countries that have led the way.
asserted
that → lead → way
Its parliament passed a law in August allowing approved operators of critical infrastructure and contractors to detect, jam and shoot down drones near designated facilities.
asserted
operators → pass → facilities
The law passed by the French parliament in August responded to a wave of drone incursions over critical and military sites, including flights over the Ile Longue nuclear submarine base near Brest in northwestern France in December 2025.
asserted
law → pass → December
France wants a newly expanded list of sensitive sites deemed of vital importance equipped by 2027, a senior French official involved in the plans told Reuters, asking not to be named because details of the plan are not yet public.
asserted
details → want → plan
"We were defenceless in the face of the (drone) threat," the official said, adding that concerns had been growing over the last decade as unmanned aerial vehicles became more accessible and more common.
asserted
vehicles → say → decade
The French government wants to give operators of critical infrastructure such as state-owned utility company EDF and state-owned railway company SNCF a catalogue of approved systems ranging from electronic jammers to interceptor drones, depending on different environments and situations.
asserted
government → want → environments
Confirming important elements of the plan outlined by the French official, Systematic Paris-Region, which runs the government testing programme at Brétigny-sur-Orge, said evaluations launched this summer had so far catalogued three systems integrators — which combine different computer systems into a unified whole — and 17 counter-drone systems.
asserted
which → confirm → whole
It said assessments were continuing and work was under way to accelerate procurement from among those solutions.
France's defence ministry said the law passed in August would help strengthen capabilities to counter the threat, though it said it could speak only for the critical infrastructure under its authority.
uncertain
it → say → authority
EDF and SNCF declined comment.
asserted
EDF → decline → comment
WHO CAN BRING DOWN A DRONE?
asserted
WHO → bring → DRONE
The discovery of an explosives-laden drone near a Ukrainian cargo plane at Germany's Leipzig/Halle airport in August underlined how far the risks have spread.
asserted
risks → lade → August
Germany blamed Russia for the incident.
asserted
Germany → blame → incident
Moscow denied it was behind it, and has repeatedly denied carrying out hybrid attacks in Europe, many of which have been in countries that support Kyiv in Russia's war in Ukraine.
But concerns are growing that national authorities cannot respond fast enough to protect widely dispersed infrastructure against such attacks, and that the damage caused by relatively cheap drones could bring hefty repair costs.
uncertain
damage → deny → costs
In Germany, where counter-drone operations remain a policing function, the interior ministry told Reuters it was reviewing how critical infrastructure operators and third parties could be legally involved in active counter-drone measures.
uncertain
operators → remain → measures
In September, Austria announced plans to give similar powers to critical infrastructure operators, including large energy firms.
asserted
Austria → announce → firms
Defence Minister Klaudia Tanner told a press conference that the state could not protect every site on its own.
uncertain
state → tell → own
Poland has gone further.
asserted
Poland → go → ?
Operators told Reuters they have deployed counter-drone systems and trained with military and police units.
asserted
they → tell → units
Drone-restricted zones have been established around critical energy infrastructure, and designated security units working for operators have been authorised to destroy, disable or take control of drones entering them.
asserted
units → restrict → them
But two sources at energy transmission companies on NATO's eastern flank told Reuters that effective intervention still requires more assurances, and perhaps a judicial precedent, on who bears responsibility for collateral damage.
asserted
who → tell → damage
Without that certainty, they said, operators of critical infrastructure could remain reluctant to neutralise drones because bringing one down could itself cause injury or costly damage.
uncertain
bringing → say → injury
BUILT FOR RECOVERY
Having powers to bring down drones would be a change of approach for companies across Europe.
asserted
Having → have → Europe
Executives, officials and energy analysts told Reuters that utilities have spent years hardening networks and preparing to restore disrupted services, rather than preventing attacks.
asserted
utilities → tell → attacks
Leonhard Birnbaum, chief executive of German energy firm E.ON, said in September that operators must assume some attacks will succeed, rather than plan on stopping all of them.
asserted
attacks → say → them
The company operates about 2,720 substations across Germany, he said.
asserted
he → operate → Germany
Lithuania is building a fortified substation near its border with Russia as part of plans by the Baltic states and Poland to improve their defences that include constructing bunkers, installing anti-drone nets and building up stocks of hard-to-replace equipment for critical parts of the energy grid.
asserted
that → build → grid
Poland's state-owned transmission operator PSE patrols parts of its about 16,500-km (10,250-mile) high-voltage network by helicopter and is preparing more powerful aircraft to help protect an undersea power link to Sweden.
Yet relatively inexpensive drones are challenging such defences.
asserted
drones → own → defences
Essential equipment such as large transformers can take years to replace, while even a successful repair can leave infrastructure out of service for months.
asserted
repair → take → months
Not all utility operators are seeking a bigger role in defending themselves.
asserted
operators → seek → themselves
…and 11 more, not listed.
The Aporia
