A report by advocacy group Safety on Swan claims that building a ferry terminal at Matilda Bay would put swimmers and water sports enthusiasts at serious risk due to potential collisions with ferries. The Western Australian state government, however, has commissioned its own analysis which found the same site to be safest for a ferry terminal with appropriate adjustments. While opponents suggest an alternative location further down the foreshore at JoJo's, Transport Minister Rita Saffioti maintains that Matilda Bay is the preferred and safer spot for the project.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-14,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
Safety concerns over a proposed ferry terminal at Matilda Bay in Perth have intensified, with an advocacy group called Safety on Swan claiming that water users would face "serious risk" if construction proceeds. The state government counters this by citing its commissioned analysis, which asserts that Matilda Bay is the safest location for the terminal, provided certain adjustments are made. Opponents of the project advocate moving the terminal to another site down the foreshore but have been rebuffed by the government's stance.
The Metronet project, part of Perth’s broader transport infrastructure plan, aims to connect ferry services from Matilda Bay and the southern suburb of Applecross to a floating pontoon at Elizabeth Quay. Despite approval by the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) in December last year, the ongoing dispute highlights the tension between development goals and community safety concerns.
Written for “Matilda Bay Ferry Plan Controversy” on 2026-09-15,
grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.
A report commissioned by advocacy group Safety on Swan has found that water users at the popular Matilda Bay area would be at "serious risk" if a government plan to build a ferry terminal in the area goes ahead.
asserted
plan → commission → area
The state government has cited an analysis it had commissioned which showed Matilda Bay was the safest location for the ferry terminal with "adjustments".
asserted
Bay → cite → adjustments
Opponents want the terminal to be moved to another location down the foreshore, but the government does not agree.
asserted
government → want → foreshore
The safety of swimmers and water sports enthusiasts at Perth's popular Matilda Bay has again been thrust into the spotlight as the state government sticks to its plans to build a controversial ferry terminal at the spot, despite ongoing opposition.
asserted
government → thrust → opposition
Construction has yet to start on the Metronet project, which would connect ferry services from Matilda Bay and the southern suburb of Applecross to a floating pontoon at Elizabeth Quay.
But the contrasting views of the state government and opponents of the project have been laid bare in two reports they commissioned separately on the terminal.
asserted
they → have → terminal
The Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) approved the Matilda Bay site in December last year.
asserted
Commission → approve → December
A government commissioned analysis found the area, across the road from the University of Western Australia, was the safest location for a ferry terminal.
asserted
area → commission → terminal
The report said all water activities there could continue with "adjustments" that were still being finalised.
uncertain
that → say → adjustments
However, another commissioned report by advocacy group Safety on Swan found the project would put children, novice sailors and other water users at "serious risk" of injury or death from being hit by a ferry.
asserted
project → commission → ferry
The group has long opposed the project, and hired Paul Chivers, a risk assessor and the founding director of Riskfacilitator, to conduct a review of Matilda Bay.
asserted
group → oppose → Bay
The review also looked into the site the group would prefer — an area further along the foreshore at the location of a now-closed restaurant known as JoJo's.
asserted
group → look → JoJo
A busy waterway
Mr Chivers's report found the government would not be able to mitigate what he said were serious risks for a high-frequency ferry service moving in and out of a busy recreational waterway.
asserted
he → find → waterway
He found people in the water would be too close to the ferries, putting their safety at an unacceptable risk.
"
asserted
people → find → risk
The issue is introducing a high-frequency vessel into an already complex recreational system when an alternative location provides greater opportunity to separate those activities by design," Mr Chivers's report stated.
asserted
report → introduce → design
"Good risk management should favour designing out foreseeable conflict rather than relying on people to continually manage that conflict in real time."
asserted
management → favour → time
Mr Chivers told the ABC there would be a much better and safer separation between ferries and people in the water at JoJo's.
asserted
Chivers → tell → JoJo
JoJo's a no-go for government
Transport Minister Rita Saffioti disagreed.
asserted
Saffioti → disagree → government
Speaking on 102.5 ABC Perth, Ms Saffioti pointed to the government's analysis of the different possible sites based on environmental, operating, waterway safety and public transport use criteria.
asserted
Saffioti → speak → criteria
She said Matilda Bay was clearly the safest and best option.
asserted
Bay → say → ?
The government's analysis found JoJo's had an "unacceptable safety risk" to windsurfers and kiteboarders due to the "informal" nature of the sports, and the ferry route would also cross over vessel traffic lanes in Melville Waters.
At Matilda Bay on the other hand, it found all water activities could continue with "adjustments", including a wide exclusion zone where the ferry could not go.
Other adjustments could include reducing ferry speeds in the bay, and building the jetty out to a length of 40 metres, so children and swimmers could still play and swim close to the shore.
"Any bit of infrastructure we deliver has risk attached to it.
uncertain
we → find → it
But the aim is to mitigate those risks," Ms Saffioti said.
asserted
Saffioti → mitigate → risks
In the government's analysis, JoJo's was also not suitable because it was further to walk to the UWA campus and because it was close to a marine park with significant seagrass, and next to a "bush forever" site.
asserted
it → walk → site
But Mr Chivers said JoJo's was the safer spot and did not need extensive mitigation measures.
asserted
JoJo → say → measures
"The question for government is whether it is reasonable to choose a location that requires more active management of conflict when another location provides greater opportunity to separate that conflict by design," he said.
asserted
he → choose → design
The Aporia