We’ve had “Once Upon a Time” in the West, in America, in Hollywood.
asserted
We → have → Hollywood
It’s a classic kind of movie title phrase, and a good way to start a fairytale or burnish a myth.
asserted
It → ’ → myth
But “Once Upon a Time in Harlem” is a staggering documentary event, and has a different relationship with the past.
asserted
Time → have → past
It takes place over one day about half a century ago, in 1972.
asserted
It → take → 1972
It’s about remembering the Harlem Renaissance of the 1920s, yet another half-century leap in time.
asserted
It → ’ → time
In that way, “Once Upon a Time in Harlem” stretches over more than a century of time.
asserted
Once → stretch → time
It doesn’t merely resurrect the Harlem Renaissance.
asserted
It → resurrect → Renaissance
It’s more about the act of resurrecting the Harlem Renaissance: the need to remember it, to argue over it and to cherish it.
asserted
It → ’ → it
The film is less an act of preservation than a lively and dynamic reminder that history is an ever-unfolding continuum.
asserted
history → unfold → reminder
It’s also just a cocktail party — a really, really amazing cocktail party.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
In August 1972, the filmmaker William Greaves invited luminaries of the Harlem Renaissance to gather at Duke Ellington’s townhouse and reflect on its legacy.
asserted
filmmaker → invite → legacy
Greaves, with a small camera crew including his son, David, planned to shoot the event on 16 mm for a film called “From These Roots.”
asserted
Greaves → include → Roots
But Greaves ultimately made that 1974 documentary largely with archival photographs.
asserted
Greaves → make → photographs
He spent years debating what to do with the footage from the townhouse in 1972, but never found a home for it.
asserted
He → spend → it
After Greaves’ death in 2014 at the age of 87, his widow, Louise Aarchambault Greaves, resolved to have the footage restored.
asserted
footage → resolve → 87
David Greaves stepped forward to direct the project to the finish line.
asserted
Greaves → step → line
“Once Upon a Time in Harlem,” a miracle of a movie, thus has an intoxicating time-capsule feel, like a ‘70s documentary classic that time somehow forgot.
asserted
time → have → that
We occasionally hear Greaves’ voice from behind the camera or catch him in a mirror.
asserted
We → hear → mirror
But the film is largely observational, floating between conversations as the attendees discuss the meaning and nature of the intellectual, artistic and cultural movement known as the Harlem Renaissance.
asserted
attendees → float → Renaissance
Remembering it requires arguing over where to place the most emphasis.
asserted
Remembering → remember → emphasis
Is it a matter of recalling certain individuals, and if so, who?
asserted
it → recall → individuals
Or was it a flourishing brought on by something more communal and harder to define?
asserted
it → bring → something
The writer George Schuyler terms it “an awakening of people who wrote and thought.”
asserted
who → term → people
The poet Arna Bontemps calls it “a prism reflecting all of the Black experience from the beginnings to the present.”
asserted
poet → call → present
Bontemps’ definition is shared by the spirit of “Once Upon a Time in Harlem.”
asserted
definition → share → Harlem
The movie could hardly be more specifically set, on a single day.
uncertain
movie → set → day
In dialogue and breadth, the documentary stretches across the years that lead up to the Harlem Renaissance and reverberates across both its contemporary ’70s time and today, when Black history is under considerable threat.
asserted
history → stretch → threat
The film’s final images are of children outside in the street, a parting glance that propels “Once Upon a Time in Harlem” into the future.
asserted
that → propel → future
Some of those in attendance include Ida Mae Cullen, widow of the poet Countee Cullen; the writer-artist Richard Bruce Nugent; the painter Aaron Douglas; the socialist and bookstore owner Richard B. Moore; Lee Whipper, actor and founder of the Negro Actors Guild; pianist Eubie Blake; and the scholar John Henrik Clarke.
asserted
Some → include → Guild
(Ellington was sick and absent, though his presence is felt all around.)
asserted
presence → feel → ?
“Once Upon a Time In Harlem” is most moving when the swirl of the party momentarily retreats and the excerpted words of the poets and the writers including Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston and Cullen speak with a depth of meaning that the free-flowing conversation of the gathering — for all its thoughtfulness — can’t match.
asserted
conversation → retreat → thoughtfulness
This is also dazzlingly true of Whipper, a grand and eloquent presence then in his mid-90s who eagerly recites, from memory, his speech from the 1943 film “Mission to Moscow.”
asserted
who → recite → Moscow
It’s in these moments when any definition between past and present slips away.
asserted
definition → ’ → past
In “Once Upon a Time in Harlem,” a documentary shared by father and son, the collective spirit and enduring sound of the Harlem Renaissance come thundering into now.
asserted
spirit → share → Renaissance
“Once Upon a Time in Harlem,” a Neon release in select theaters Friday, is rated PG-13 by the Motion Picture Association for some disturbing images, strong racial language, smoking and brief partial nudity.
asserted
Once → rat → images
The Aporia
_ONCE_UPON_A_TIME_IN_HARLEM_Courtesy_of_NEON.jpg?branch=production&width=2400&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=16:9)
