U.S.-based Cleveland-Cliffs said on Monday that it saw its strongest quarterly financial results since the year before acquiring Stelco in 2024.
asserted
it → say → 2024
This comes as Stelco continues to lay off hundreds of workers at its steel plant in Hamilton, Ont., while citing pressure from U.S. tariffs, a decision the federal government says breaches its binding agreement to maintain jobs.
asserted
government → come → jobs
Cleveland-Cliffs said it saw net earnings of US$612 million in the third quarter, up from $286 million in the previous quarter.
asserted
it → say → quarter
Cleveland-Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves in the report said, “Third quarter was our strongest quarter in three years,” and added that the figure was higher than the $575 million guidance they provided three months earlier.
asserted
they → say → guidance
On Tuesday, Industry Minister Mélanie Joly spoke outside the House of Commons.
asserted
Joly → speak → Commons
“We took good note of the earnings call that happened yesterday where the CEO of Stelco again mentioned that he was in favour of American tariffs against steelworkers in Canada and therefore we’ve hired the best lawyers to advise us on what to do next,” said Joly.
asserted
Joly → take → what
“I’ll have more to say in the coming days, but we’re following this very closely.
asserted
we → have → this
We’ve been working also with the union as they’re providing important proof for a legal case.”
asserted
they → work → case
Several legal experts say that, based on publicly available information, the federal government could have a strong case.
uncertain
government → say → case
“The federal government’s case, from everything we’ve heard, is rock solid and they should be seeking injunctive relief against the layoffs entirely and recalling the workers.”
asserted
they → hear → workers
Stelco announced last month that pressure from U.S. tariffs forced it to concentrate steel production at its Lake Erie Works plant in Haldimand, Ont., and halt production at its plant in Hamilton.
asserted
pressure → announce → Hamilton
Although the company said some of those workers would be offered positions at the Haldimand facility, hundreds are still expected to be out of work.
asserted
hundreds → say → work
U.S. President Donald Trump’s tariffs include a 50 per cent duty on various Canadian steel products, and Stelco claims that has severely impacted its sales.
uncertain
that → include → sales
Here’s how the two arguments stack up, according to legal experts.
uncertain
arguments → ’ → experts
Ottawa's potential case against Stelco
When Cleveland-Cliffs acquired Stelco in 2024, the federal government approved the deal under the Investment Canada Act.
asserted
government → acquire → Act
The full legally binding agreement has not been made public, although a summary of its terms was released in 2024.
asserted
summary → make → 2024
According to the summary, the agreement with Cleveland-Cliffs includes a commitment “To continue to employ at least the same number of unionized employees and the vast majority of non-unionized employees as were employed when the transaction was announced.”
uncertain
transaction → accord → employees
The federal government’s stance is that by using tariffs to justify laying off workers, Stelco and Cleveland-Cliffs breached the agreement.
asserted
Stelco → use → agreement
“But again, it’s based on what we’ve heard and I’m surprised the federal government has not released the actual documents.
asserted
government → base → documents
But I’m also surprised, if the owner of Stelco has a real good defence, that they haven’t released the actual documents.”
asserted
they → ’m → documents
Joly sent Stelco’s president a letter on Oct. 5 demanding the company outline how it plans to abide by its commitments, including preserving jobs.
asserted
it → send → jobs
In addition, Joly said last week that Goncalves has been a vocal supporter of U.S. tariffs on steel, and therefore the company cannot use tariffs as an excuse for layoffs.
asserted
company → say → layoffs
“He’s in favor of these U.S. tariffs against steel,” she said to reporters on Oct. 7.
asserted
she → ’ → Oct.
“They cannot say that this is now an act of God or force majeure.”
asserted
this → say → God
Employment lawyer Christopher Achkar, managing partner at Achkar Law, says that in this context, Stelco using tariffs as an excuse for layoffs amounts to trying to “have your cake and eat it too.”
asserted
using → say → it
“You can’t say that you are in favor of something, and then when it actually happens, say, ‘oh, it is out of my hands,’ — you are the one who was in favor of that,” he says.
asserted
he → say → that
“I think Stelco’s positions from a practical standpoint are quite weak.”
asserted
positions → think → standpoint
Further, Achkar says that Stelco would likely have a tough time arguing that tariffs forced it to lay off workers, when it also refused financial assistance from the federal government to mitigate those risks.
asserted
it → say → risks
Stelco's case
Stelco’s president, Paul Simon, responded to Joly’s letter on Oct. 9.
asserted
president → respond → Oct.
The seven-page response detailed the company’s stance, and said the federal government’s accusations are “false.”
asserted
accusations → detail → stance
“Stelco submitted its annual report confirming its compliance with the employment undertakings in November 2025.
asserted
Stelco → submit → November
That report highlighted that Stelco was facing significant challenges due to the unforeseen consequences stemming from unprecedented U.S. tariffs and Canada’s failure to advance an effective ‘Fortress North America’ trade regime,” the letter said.
asserted
letter → highlight → regime
“Your representation that Stelco’s planned layoffs cause it to breach its undertakings is false as the undertakings do not stipulate a commitment to avoid layoffs.”
asserted
undertakings → plan → layoffs
The company is describing the cuts as indefinite layoffs, while the union is treating them as temporary under its collective agreement, which Levitt says is a key detail.
asserted
Levitt → describe → agreement
“You can lay off some without paying them anything, as long as you maintain benefits for 35 weeks, if it’s a temporary layoff.
asserted
it → lay → weeks
But Stelco announced this is an ‘indefinite’ layoff — in my mind, that’s a termination, not a layoff.”
asserted
that → announce → mind
The letter also says its exports of cold-rolled and coated steel to the United States have plunged 58 per cent from pre-trade-war levels as foreign imports continue to undercut Canadian-made steel.
asserted
imports → say → steel
Achkar says the wording in the letter suggests Stelco may seek to argue its case based on a technicality.
uncertain
Stelco → say → technicality
“Their argument is going to be that they are still technically employees and the headcount is still technically the same,” he says.
asserted
he → go → ?
Achkar also explains that the Investment Canada Act stipulates to avoid terminating workers, while these tariff-related layoffs are considered by the company to be temporary measures until market conditions improve.
asserted
conditions → explain → company
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
