One of the really likeable things about Canada, along with public health care and politeness, is our penchant for reasoned debate as a way to settle our political differences.
asserted
One → settle → differences
So it’s been jarring to see the level of vitriol recently directed toward Avi Lewis, federal leader of the New Democratic Party, who has been an outspoken critic of Israel’s assault on Gaza and Palestinians.
asserted
who → see → Gaza
Lewis, who is Jewish, has come under harsh attack from several prominent critics, especially in response to a recent social media post on the eve of Yom Kippur.
Globe and Mail columnist Robyn Urback accused Lewis of engaging in “antisemitism,” and public finance economist Jack Mintz denounced Lewis at an award ceremony, saying that anti-Israel critics “soon turn to antisemitism.”
Most unsettling however was an article in the National Post, written by Yoni Goldstein, former editor of the Canadian Jewish News, which accused Lewis of “endanger(ing) Jews everywhere in Canada,” and insisting that “(w)hen the community is endangered from the inside, reasoned debate and private conversations are no longer options.
asserted
debate → come → inside
Instead of reasoned debate, Goldstein suggests Biblical law provides guidance for handling the threat allegedly posed by Lewis.
uncertain
law → suggest → Lewis
Under the headline “Jewish law tells us how to deal with Avi Lewis,” Goldstein’s article recounts the story of God punishing the Biblical dissenter Korach, burning him and his followers alive, after Korach endangered the Jewish community.
asserted
Korach → tell → community
While the article doesn’t directly call for violence against Lewis, it certainly hints at it.
asserted
it → call → it
Surely, any suggestion that religious law justifies bloodshed against political dissenters — or anyone else — is completely out of sync with Canadian values, no matter what the religion.
asserted
religion → justify → values
Lewis enraged some in the Jewish community by writing on the eve of a Jewish holy day: “For Jewish people, the personal has always been political and the political always personal.
asserted
political → enrage → people
This year I’m reflecting on the fact that we failed to do our part to stop an ongoing genocide committed in our name.”
asserted
we → reflect → name
When accused of suggesting some sort of collective responsibility, Lewis clarified: “I spoke as a Jewish Canadian from a place of profound sadness. …
asserted
I → accuse → sadness
Many Jews have said that we have not done enough as Jewish people, among a family of faiths and communities around the world.”
asserted
we → say → world
In The Breach, Judy Rebick pointed out that Lewis’ comment was reminiscent of the conscientious men who created the White Ribbon campaign (which opposed violence against women) because they felt a special responsibility as men to address such violence.
asserted
they → point → violence
Lewis says that, as a Jew, he feels particularly strongly about Israel’s actions against Palestinians, since Israel sometimes claims to act on behalf of the Jewish people.
uncertain
Israel → say → people
As a political leader with a megaphone, Lewis really does represent a danger — namely, to the fiercely pro-Israel voices that have long managed to suppress criticism of Israel both inside and outside the community.
asserted
that → represent → community
The response in some quarters has been extreme, not only smearing Lewis, but even hinting at violence against him.
Lewis comes from an honourable tradition of dissent within the Jewish community.
asserted
Lewis → smear → community
He’s proud that his great-grandfather, Moishe Losz, was a leader of the Jewish Labour Bund, a trade union and political movement that battled antisemitism in Poland, while strongly resisting Zionist calls to solve the problem of Jewish dispossession by taking land from Palestinians.
asserted
that → ’ → Palestinians
The struggle between the Bund and the Zionists was bitter, with Zionists ultimately triumphing and managing to establish the state of Israel on land formerly occupied by Palestinians.
asserted
Zionists → triumph → Palestinians
However, the plight of the Palestinians has remained a central focus for a segment of the Jewish community.
asserted
plight → remain → community
Lewis’s track record of defending Palestinian rights reverberates with this segment of Jewish opinion, and with many other Canadians.
asserted
record → defend → Canadians
His stand for Palestinian justice is a principled one — and all the more laudable given the ferocity — and occasional menace — of his critics.
asserted
stand → give → critics
The Aporia
