History does not really repeat itself, but, as the saying frequently attributed to Mark Twain goes, it often rhymes.
asserted
it → repeat → Twain
It took six years before the British government established an independent committee of Privy Counsellors to examine the United Kingdom’s involvement in the 2003 Iraq war, and an additional seven years before Sir John Chilcot and other members of the inquiry committee published their damning findings that former Prime Minister Tony Blair had misled the public and his own government.
asserted
Blair → take → public
The Inquiry found that the UK chose to join the invasion before peaceful options had been exhausted, that Saddam Hussein did not, in fact, pose an imminent threat and that Blair had deliberately exaggerated the danger and then promised former United States President George Bush: “I will be with you, whatever.”
asserted
I → find → you
It also found that Britain’s intelligence agencies had produced “flawed information”, that Blair had ignored warnings about what would happen in Iraq after the invasion, and that the government had not tried hard enough to keep a tally of Iraqi civilian casualties, which, according to Iraq Body Count, amounts to between 187,499 and 211,046 deaths.
Prime Minister Gordon Brown would not have established the inquiry committee without unrelenting pressure from within Parliament and civil society, and it was only due to these persistent demands that the truth finally saw the light of day (even though Tony Blair has still not been held to account).
uncertain
Blair → find → account
Starmer government blocks independent inquiry into Britain’s role in the genocide
Fast forward to the Gaza genocide.
asserted
government → block → genocide
In June 2025, former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn proposed a bill for a full, independent, public inquiry into Britain’s role in the genocide in Gaza.
asserted
Corbyn → propose → Gaza
This inquiry committee would consider any UK military, economic or political cooperation with Israel since October 2023, including the sale, supply or use of weapons, surveillance aircraft and Royal Air Force bases, while also having the power to question ministers and officials about decisions taken in relation to UK involvement.
asserted
committee → consider → involvement
The bill secured the support of more than 50 MPs.
asserted
bill → secure → MPs
However, when it reached a second reading, Keir Starmer’s government blocked its passage.
asserted
government → reach → passage
The government said “there is no need for an inquiry” and that “such an inquiry would be unnecessary as there is no confusion about UK military operations in Gaza.”
asserted
inquiry → say → Gaza
In response, Jeremy Corbyn decided to hold a public tribunal in the tradition of the Russell Tribunal organised by the great British philosopher Bertrand Russell in 1966 to investigate US war crimes in Vietnam.
asserted
Corbyn → decide → Vietnam
Corbyn invited Shahd Hammouri, an international law lecturer at the University of Kent, and me to join the Tribunal panel, and the hearings were held on September 4-5, 2025, in Church House, Westminster.
asserted
hearings → invite → House
We heard 29 testimonies from witnesses, journalists and survivors of the Gaza genocide, as well as a range of international law experts, lawyers, medical doctors and whistleblowers.
asserted
We → hear → experts
At the time, the official death toll in Gaza was nearing 65,000, of whom almost 20,000 were children.
asserted
20,000 → near → whom
With more than 150,000 injured, Gaza had become the home of the largest cohort of child amputees in the world.
asserted
Gaza → injure → world
Almost 80 percent of the buildings in Gaza had either been damaged or destroyed, including more than 90 percent of housing, 97 percent of schools, 33 of 36 hospitals, and every single university in the Strip.
asserted
percent → damage → Strip
The two days of hearings were among the most difficult in my life, given the emotional toll of listening to so many horrific testimonies.
asserted
days → give → testimonies
In addition to testimony after testimony describing the extent of the British government’s complicity in the mass murder and destruction, we also heard from a whistleblower about the culture of deception – to cover up the government’s wrongdoings – that had taken over the corridors of power.
asserted
that → describe → power
In the subsequent months, we analysed the findings and concluded that Britain had played a vital role in Israeli military operations in Gaza, including but not limited to:
The sale, supply and transfer of weapons that have been used to extinguish human life and destroy vital infrastructure in Gaza, the West Bank and beyond.
asserted
that → analyse → Gaza
This included individual export licences issued directly to Israel, as well as the indirect supply of components for F-35 fighter jets.
asserted
This → include → jets
The provision of political and diplomatic support, which has empowered Israel, enabling it to commit atrocities with impunity.
asserted
which → empower → impunity
This support has included the dehumanisation of Palestinians in political rhetoric, the justification of Israel’s actions, the hosting of Israeli officials, the failure to uphold the authority and decisions of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Court (ICC), and the demonisation of international solidarity, including the proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist group.
asserted
support → include → group
In March 2026, Corbyn submitted the Tribunal’s findings to the ICC, encouraging the court to interview government ministers regarding British complicity in war crimes.
asserted
Corbyn → submit → crimes
Since then, he has continued to demand a full, official, independent public inquiry into any cooperation between the UK and Israel since October 2023.
asserted
he → continue → October
The bill returns to Parliament
Corbyn knows that the Tribunal he organised is no substitute for a full, public, independent inquiry, and given that there is a new prime minister in Number 10 who said Labour “got it wrong” over Gaza, Corbyn wanted to know whether the current Labour government would finally commit to investigating Britain’s role in the genocide.
asserted
government → return → genocide
Expressions of regret are certainly important, but if justice is the goal, then the UK public requires both truth and accountability.
asserted
public → require → truth
Last week, the bill that Keir Starmer’s government blocked back in June 2025 was once again brought before Parliament, and once again the government blocked MPs from voting on it.
asserted
government → block → it
The Burnham government’s decision to postpone the vote on Corbyn’s Bill is reminiscent of the way previous governments postponed the establishment of an inquiry to investigate the Iraq war.
asserted
governments → postpone → war
It appears that, like previous UK governments, the current government’s strategy is to demur and delay, with the goal of sending the Gaza inquiry bill to purgatory.
asserted
strategy → appear → purgatory
The ruling elite have lost the ‘common sense’
asserted
elite → rule → sense
The problem for Burnham is that, today, he and other members of the ruling elite no longer have the power to define the “common sense” through which Gaza is understood.
asserted
Gaza → rule → which
Public opinion on Israel has shifted, as the huge pro-Palestinian marches and opinion polls demonstrate.
asserted
marches → shift → Israel
The majority of the UK population knows that Israel is committing a genocide and that it has been able to do so, in part, because of the support of Western governments.
asserted
it → know → governments
While the US and Germany were undoubtedly the most enthusiastic supporters – providing Israel with the lethal mechanisms and the diplomatic shield to carry out mass killings – the public also understands that Britain has played a vital role.
asserted
Britain → provide → role
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband’s recent – and I would say courageous – announcement that the UK government would ban imports from illegal Israeli settlements and sanction companies and individuals supporting settlement activity is a very important first step.
asserted
government → say → activity
Yet, it does not absolve the UK government of its alleged complicity in atrocity crimes.
asserted
it → absolve → crimes
The disturbing testimonies we heard during the Tribunal underscore the importance of formal scrutiny.
asserted
we → hear → scrutiny
The vote on Corbyn’s bill was postponed last week, but the need to reveal the role the British government played in Israel’s genocidal onslaught is not going away.
asserted
government → postpone → onslaught
Burnham and Miliband have a historic opportunity to prove that this new government is committed to the principles of international law and currently face a straightforward choice: Continue to block efforts to expose the truth and seek accountability, or break with the past and stand on the right side of history.
asserted
government → have → history
History often rhymes, but it does not have to.
asserted
it → rhyme → ?
…and 1 more, not listed.
