Vice President JD Vance faced tough questions from voters about the Trump administration’s policies on data centers, high costs, immigration and his own rhetoric in a town hall on CBS News that aired Saturday night.
asserted
that → face → News
The string of sharp queries, some from voters who said they had supported him and President Donald Trump, previewed the rocky path he may face trying to answer for the administration’s record if he runs for president himself in 2028.
uncertain
he → say → 2028
Vance, who said during the town hall there’s “of course” a chance he doesn’t run for president, faced an especially pointed question about “a failure of leadership” posted by the widow of one of six U.S. soldiers killed by an Iranian drone strike in Kuwait, which occurred the day after Trump started the war with Iran.
asserted
Trump → say → Iran
“This literally is the first time I’ve heard of this,” Vance said in response.
asserted
Vance → hear → response
As he went on, he said, “This job is an amazing honor, but you live in a bit of a bubble and sometimes information doesn’t filter up.”
asserted
information → go → bubble
Questions about Iran war strategy and costs
After telling the vice president about his late wife, Master Sgt. Nicole Amor, who was killed on March 1, Joey Amor asked about mistakes and fundamental failures that led up to the deaths of those soldiers and how leaders would be held accountable.
asserted
leaders → tell → soldiers
Vance seemed taken aback by Amor’s questions, saying, “This literally is the first time I’ve heard of this,” and said he wanted to talk with Amor to learn more after.
asserted
he → take → more
But as Vance went on, he acknowledged mistakes were made and said, “there were issues with where troops were located that we realized was a huge mistake that we could do better on, and we have changed that.”
uncertain
we → go → that
A Michigan man who said he voted for Trump and Vance in 2024 but now plans to vote for Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed pressed Vance about the high gasoline prices resulting from the war.
asserted
he → say → war
In response, Vance said he recognized that gas prices were too high, and said, “I think it’s important to be honest about why they’re so elevated.”
asserted
they → say → response
He said it was because of “what’s happening in the Middle East” and said the administration was taking steps to try to lower prices.
“We’ve never had a situation like this where you have effectively, the largest state sponsor of terrorism that’s trying to choke off world energy supply,” Vance said, without acknowledging that situation occurred because of the war Trump launched.
asserted
Trump → say → war
He also blamed former President Joe Biden, saying that during his tenure, America’s refining capacity was diminished.
asserted
capacity → blame → tenure
But when Vance was pressed on the Trump administration owning the current situation, the vice president suggested that looking backward for blame was not the way.
uncertain
looking → press → blame
“Fundamentally, we are where we are, and you have to, in my view, I’d like to know what is Abdul El-Sayed’s solution for the problem that we have right now,” Vance said.
asserted
Vance → have → that
“It’s easy to criticize something that happened seven months ago.”
asserted
that → ’ → something
Immigration enforcement tactics and the rhetoric around immigrants
A nun who spoke to Vance about their shared Catholic faith questioned the administration’s hardline immigration enforcement tactics, including children who are separated from their parents when the adults are swept up in sweeps, and how that squared with their values.
asserted
that → speak → values
“We’re trying to strike the right balance,” Vance said.
asserted
Vance → try → balance
When moderator Tony Dokoupil asked Vance if the administration is not striking that balance, Vance replied, “I think that is constantly a work in progress.”
asserted
that → ask → progress
He admitted that, “Sometimes you have some people who made mistakes.
asserted
who → admit → mistakes
Sometimes you have some people who really screw up.”
asserted
who → have → people
When Dokoupil asked for specific examples, Vance said there are a number of cases the administration has investigated that resulted in further training or discipline for immigration enforcement officers, but said they don’t advertise it publicly in order to let investigations play out.
asserted
investigations → ask → it
Another voter, who said she became an immigrant five years ago and voted for Vance after becoming a U.S. citizen, asked him pointedly about his recent remarks referring to H1-B visa holders as, “foreign indentured servants,” and accused him of “scapegoating immigrants for the issues you’re supposed to be solving.”
“To the extent that my rhetoric has been imperfect here, that’s on me,” Vance said, before explaining that he was trying to criticize the companies that bring in the workers, not the immigrant workers themselves.
asserted
that → say → workers
Selling access to the White House is ‘disgusting and despicable’
asserted
Selling → sell → House
Dokoupil pressed Vance on whether Trump and others in his administration were profiting off the presidency, including the nearly $1.2 billion the president took in from his crypto businesses last year, according to a federal filing.
uncertain
president → press → filing
When asked if he’d seen anything in the White House that made him squeamish, Vance said, “I’ve never seen anything like that from the president.”
asserted
I → ask → president
He said, though, that there is evidence of corruption in Washington, but he doesn’t see evidence of it from the president or the administration.
asserted
he → say → president
Vance said he’s read articles about allegations, but said he goes to investigate claims himself and finds that they are not true.
uncertain
they → say → claims
Dokoupil asked Vance about the president’s crypto profits, along with the recent resignation of his ambassador to Greece, Kimberly Guilfoyle, over allegations she denies that she was leveraging her position for benefits.
asserted
she → ask → benefits
“If somebody’s selling access to the White House, that’s disgusting and despicable and they should suffer consequences,” Vance said.
asserted
Vance → sell → consequences
The Aporia
