The Standard's journalism is supported by our readers.
asserted
journalism → support → readers
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
uncertain
we → purchase → commission
I didn’t always hate AI.
asserted
I → hate → AI
As a boy in the 1980s, every toy I wanted was a robot, or robot-related; I spent nights on end programming my Commodore Plus 4 to recite the alphabet.
asserted
I → want → alphabet
But recently, in my day job as a creative writing professor, I’ve found myself so angry about it that I’d happily join an army against the grifters forcing it on us.
asserted
I → find → us
We cannot allow AI to replace art and the creative process when AI companies have stolen all of our books to “train” the machines.
asserted
companies → allow → machines
It feels odd even to have to write a sentence like that when, for the majority of people, it goes without saying, but pro-AI propaganda has more money invested in it than anything else on the planet.
asserted
propaganda → feel → planet
The tech industry has made a major PR blunder, though.
asserted
industry → make → blunder
Instead of presenting AI-generated art as an amusing parlour trick (a robot who can wear a hat and juggle and compose a passable sonnet — how charming!) they chose to overplay their hand and threatened human creatives and researchers with obsolescence.
asserted
they → present → obsolescence
Why, they suggested, would we ever again bother staying up late into the night working on a tricky scene in our screenplay?
uncertain
we → suggest → screenplay
Or practising our scales so we can one day play in an ensemble? Or having one more go at that acrylic of our beloved cat?
asserted
one → practise → cat
The computers can do it!
asserted
computers → do → it
Think of the time we’ll save to do absolutely nothing in because life no longer has any meaning.
asserted
life → think → meaning
This, along with the horrendous cost to the environment and surrounding communities of their data centres, as well as their inexplicably awful personalities, feudal-era greed and fascist politics, and pirating the entire history of literature and art because copyright law somehow doesn’t apply here, has contributed to the radicalisation of an entire generation against them.
asserted
law → surround → them
Its capabilities may be exaggerated, but it can’t be denied that AI has already done a lot of damage to the arts industries and individual careers.
uncertain
AI → exaggerate → industries
Many creative professionals, from translators to graphic designers to scriptwriters for video games, have lost their livelihoods.
asserted
professionals → lose → livelihoods
Corporations are using it more and more, however hideous the CG results, because it’s seen as cheap, instant and convenient.
asserted
it → use → it
If a few hundred thousand artists starve, who cares?
asserted
who → starve → ?
The story might appear to be the same in universities; according to research by the Higher Education Policy Institute, overall AI adoption is more or less ubiquitous (92 to 95 per cent between staff and students).
uncertain
adoption → appear → staff
But in fact these statistics are misleading when you remember that you can’t even use a search engine or open a PDF without AI sticking its oar in.
asserted
AI → remember → oar
In the arts and humanities this is very rare — as rare as plagiarism (I’ve dealt with precisely two cases of this in my 20-year career and taught roughly 3,000 students).
asserted
I → deal → students
Cheating like this tends to indicate a deeper problem the student is struggling with, and with some attention and advice they can usually be brought around to trusting their own voice and ideas.
asserted
they → tend → voice
We’re human and we’re all tempted to cut corners, but in my experience the vast majority of students who choose to study literature or writing do so out of a deep commitment to the work, a belief in the importance of human culture and history and an ambition to contribute to that with their own perspectives.
asserted
who → ’re → perspectives
Rage against the machine
All is not lost: I’d like to tell the tech bosses what I see my students doing instead of using their overpriced, overrated and intellectually deadening tools: they spend hours on end working on 70,000-word novels; they perform at well-attended poetry nights; they write and produce stage plays; they start bands and compose music …
asserted
they → lose → music
They attend to the forms of culture that existed before we had electricity; the same ones that will survive even if the mismanagement and resource-wasting of AI sends us back to the pre-industrial age.
asserted
mismanagement → attend → age
In that eventuality, a lot of the art we make will probably be quite furious reflections on those responsible.
asserted
we → make → those
I’d recommend Tim Winton’s recent novel Juice as a template.
asserted
I → recommend → template
We see this rejection too in the public statements of successful young artists.
asserted
We → see → artists
The electronica composer and musician Fred Again recently reflected that the process of writing and making music is what makes it meaningful.
asserted
it → reflect → music
“Giving the process bit to a machine would be intrinsically contrary to what I love about the whole thing.”
asserted
I → give → thing
Art without humans is empty, meaningless, and ultimately damaging to the soul
A couple of years ago my own children were messing around with a song-generating app, writing obscene lyrics and setting them to AI-generated music.
asserted
children → mess → music
They got bored of it within an hour and have never used it since.
asserted
They → get → it
Meanwhile, they practise their musical instruments every day, courtesy of the local education authority’s commitment to affordable music lessons.
asserted
they → practise → lessons
Because a child of 10, like the Pope, grasps naturally what the clueless pushers of AI technology don’t (or they’ve forgotten, or they’re deliberately playing dumb): “art” — or indeed craft or design — without humans is empty, meaningless, and ultimately damaging to the soul and our collective humanity.
asserted
art → grasp → soul
There has never been a more important time to assert this, passionately and repeatedly, and when I look at the example of my own students, facing an unstable future with imagination and integrity, I feel nothing but gratitude and hope.
asserted
I → assert → gratitude
The Aporia
