An anti-terrorism court (ATC) on Saturday summoned the Islamabad police chief and issued show-cause notices to two police officials over the continued failure to produce the case record in the security breach case against lawyer Imaan Zainab Mazari-Hazir and her spouse, Hadi Ali Chattha.
asserted
court → summon → Hazir
The case pertains to the alleged disruption of a security route of an international cricket team and incitement to public unrest.
asserted
case → pertain → unrest
Imaan and her husband were accused of removing barriers from the route.
asserted
Imaan → accuse → route
The couple was indicted in the case on Oct 7.
asserted
couple → indict → Oct
During Saturday’s hearing, ATC Judge Abul Hasnat Muhammad Zulqarnain directed the two police officials to whom notices were issued to explain their failure to ensure the production of the record.
asserted
notices → direct → record
He warned that they could face imprisonment if it was not presented before the court.
uncertain
it → warn → court
During the proceedings, the court expressed displeasure over the continued absence of the investigating officer and raised questions about the whereabouts of the case record.
asserted
court → express → record
A court official informed the judge that the investigating officer had travelled to Gilgit-Baltistan and had not returned.
asserted
officer → inform → Baltistan
The judge immediately summoned the superintendent (investigation) to explain the situation.
asserted
judge → summon → situation
Advocate Riasat Ali Azad, representing the accused, told the court that the bail application had been filed on October 29 last year and notices had already been issued, but the proceedings could not move forward because the investigating officer failed to appear with the record.
uncertain
officer → represent → record
He argued that in similar cases, another police official usually appeared with the case record when the investigating officer was unavailable.
asserted
officer → argue → record
Questioning how long the court was expected to wait, Azad urged the judge to make a decision in accordance with the law.
asserted
Azad → question → law
Advocate Asif Irfan, vice chairman of the Islamabad Bar Council, observed that the court was not powerless, but had so far been unable to ensure the production of the record.
asserted
court → observe → record
Advocate Aleem Abbasi, meanwhile, urged the judge to exercise his authority and decide the matter on merit.
asserted
Abbasi → urge → merit
He added that the legal fraternity stood with the judiciary in defending its independence, but questioned how lawyers could secure justice for their own children if the judicial system failed to deliver it.
uncertain
system → add → it
Advocate Zafar Khokhar also questioned under which law an investigating officer could take the case record away and leave court proceedings stalled.
uncertain
officer → question → proceedings
Judge Zulqarnain, however, expressed displeasure over the tone adopted by some lawyers, deeming such conduct inappropriate and remarking that he was not influenced by vlogs or commentary and always conducted proceedings impartially.
asserted
he → express → proceedings
After a short break in the proceedings, SP Khurram Ashraf and Deputy Superintendent (DSP) Naeem Yousuf appeared before the court.
asserted
Ashraf → appear → court
The SP informed the judge that the investigating officer had travelled to Khaplu and would appear after he returned.
asserted
he → inform → Khaplu
The judge questioned the arrangement and asked when the officer would return, observing that everyone was waiting while the court had a case to decide.
asserted
court → question → case
When pressed for a definite timeline, DSP Yousuf said the investigating officer could take another 10 to 15 days to return.
uncertain
officer → press → days
The judge criticised the police for causing prolonged hardship to PTI workers through delays in their cases.
asserted
judge → criticise → cases
Expressing frustration over the situation and the alleged harassment of workers, the judge ordered the discharge of several individuals arrested in connection with the PTI’s long march.
asserted
judge → express → march
The court subsequently issued show-cause notices to the SP and DSP, warning that failure to produce the case record could lead to proceedings for their imprisonment.
Islamabad Inspector General of Police Muhammad Sohail Chaudhry was also summoned for the next hearing on November 3.
uncertain
Chaudhry → issue → November
The lawyer couple has been in jail since their arrest on Jan 23 in a case registered against them for protesting outside the Islamabad High Court (IHC) and allegedly manhandling the IHC Bar Association president.
uncertain
couple → register → president
The arrest prompted criticism by rights bodies, politicians and journalists, who stressed the couple’s right to a fair trial.
asserted
who → prompt → trial
Just a day later, a sessions court sentenced them to 17 years on multiple charges under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (Peca) in a case pertaining to controversial social media posts.
asserted
court → sentence → posts
The convictions were widely condemned by lawyers and United Nations (UN) experts.
asserted
convictions → condemn → lawyers
On Sept 17, following months of litigation before the courts, the Supreme Court suspended their sentences in the case.
asserted
Court → follow → case
The SC ordered their release pending the IHC’s final verdict on their appeals against the trial court’s decision.
asserted
SC → order → decision
However, the reprieve was short-lived as hours later, Islamabad police arrested the couple again in connection with another case and produced them before an ATC, which sent them to jail on judicial remand.
asserted
which → live → remand
The fresh case in which the two were arrested was registered at the federal capital’s Kohsar police station on March 22 last year on the complaint of City Magistrate Ghulam Murtaza Chandio.
asserted
two → arrest → Chandio
Imaan and Hadi were accused of chanting anti-government slogans and blocking roads and were nominated by name in the FIR.
asserted
Imaan → accuse → FIR
However, at the time of registration of the case, no section of the Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA) had been added.
asserted
section → add → Act
The FIR included sections 188 (disobedience of an order lawfully promulgated by a public servant), 341 (wrongful restraint), 506 (punishment for criminal intimidation), 353 (assault or use of criminal force to deter a public servant from discharging their official duty) and 186 (obstructing a public servant in the performance of official duties).
asserted
FIR → include → duties
They were indicted in the case on Oct 7 and the ATC on Oct 10 disposed of the couple’s petition seeking to drop the terrorism charges.
asserted
ATC → indict → charges
On Oct 15, the court directed lawyers and witnesses in the case to appear at Adiala jail for the next hearing after police cited difficulties in transporting the couple to court.
asserted
police → direct → court
At yesterday’s hearing, Imaan and Hadi had objected to the manner in which they were presented during the hearing of the case, with the couple and their lawyers eventually walking out of the proceedings at Adiala jail.
asserted
couple → object → jail
The Aporia
