Claims extracted
19
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
21%
4 of 19 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
71/100
ABC News (AU)'s corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Health
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
In short:
A decision to ban a health care worker who abused "vulnerable" clients has been upheld by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT).
asserted
who → ban → Tribunal
Adrian Fabio Mangini had asked for a review after the Community Services Complaints Commissioner banned him from practising indefinitely.
What's next?
asserted
What → ask → him
Mr Mangini has filed an appeal against SACAT's decision in South Australia's Supreme Court.
asserted
Mangini → file → Court
A man who abused "vulnerable" clients by claiming he could cure cancer and make an non-ambulatory woman walk has failed in a bid to overturn his "indefinite" ban from practising as a health care worker.
uncertain
walk → abuse → worker
Adrian Fabio Mangini was providing health services in South Australia, including "hypnogym", hypnotherapy and yoga, before he was banned from practising indefinitely in 2024 by the Community Services Complaints Commissioner.
asserted
he → provide → Commissioner
A judgement published by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) earlier this year upheld the decision after Mr Mangini asked for a review.
asserted
Mangini → publish → review
It upheld the previous findings by the Community Services Complaints Commissioner which included Mr Mangini's claim, in a YouTube video, that he made a woman living with a non-ambulatory disability walk "after an 11-minute consultation where he hypnotised her and counselled her by providing encouraging words".
uncertain
he → uphold → words
Senior member of SACAT Jacqueline Rugless also reiterated in her judgment that there was "no evidence" the woman "was previously disabled or that she could not walk at all or could only walk with a frame".
"I am satisfied that the applicant claimed in advertising or promotional materials to have made … 'a disabled person' walk as a direct result of his provision of services, in circumstances where there was and is still no proof that [she] was disabled and could not walk prior to the consultation," she said.
uncertain
she → reiterate → consultation
Cancer cure claims
The tribunal also upheld a previous finding that Mr Mangini had claimed he cured cancer.
uncertain
he → uphold → cancer
"The applicant [Mr Mangini] privately messaged a client about assisting a different client of his to be 10 years' cancer free, such that he represented he was able to cure cancer," the judgement said.
asserted
judgement → message → cancer
The judgement also upheld a finding that the health care worker had "engaged in behaviour of a sexual or close personal nature with a client".
asserted
worker → uphold → client
"I am satisfied that the proven conduct of the applicant demonstrates a degree of overt abuse of the health and safety of vulnerable consumers together with open and deliberate dishonesty in his advertising about the alleged beneficial consequences of the services he sought to offer to consumers," Ms Rugless said.
"
asserted
Rugless → prove → consumers
The applicant has demonstrated no insight into his behaviour and has displayed no remorse for his conduct.
asserted
applicant → demonstrate → conduct
I am satisfied that he continues to pose a risk to the public.
asserted
he → continue → public
The proven conduct is completely incompatible with Mr Mangini continuing to be a health care worker or a health services provider."
Proceedings labelled a 'vendetta'
asserted
Mangini → prove → ?
The judgment also outlined that Mr Mangini had argued in the tribunal that the proceedings were brought against him because of a vendetta by the Community Services Complaints Commissioner.
asserted
proceedings → outline → Commissioner
"I am not satisfied that there is any evidence of a 'vendetta' against Mr Mangini by a person or persons either known to him or unknown, or of a racist motivation behind the allegations that were before the Commissioner," Ms Rugless said in the judgement.
"
asserted
Rugless → be → judgement
In any event I am satisfied that the allegations found proved in the Commissioner's report have been independently verified by the Commissioner's investigation.
asserted
allegations → find → investigation
"
Mr Mangini has filed an appeal against SACAT's decision in the state's Supreme Court.
asserted
Mangini → file → Court
The Aporia