In the 1955 National Review mission statement, William F. Buckley makes a brief mention of “the irresponsible Right.”
asserted
Buckley → make → Right
The use of such a phrase suggests Buckley well understood that no movement can be effective in its broader vision if it does not have the means to hedge within the margins of philosophical and intellectual fellowship.
uncertain
it → suggest → fellowship
The success of the modern conservative movement in the 20th century and its culminating event of Ronald Reagan’s election owes itself considerably to the work Buckley and others did as gatekeepers of the movement.
asserted
Buckley → owe → movement
They broadened the tent to build a wider and stronger coalition while excising and banishing irresponsible and perfidious forms of right-wing ideology.
asserted
They → broaden → ideology
Populists often deride gatekeeping as “pearl clutching” because they want a right-wing popular front.
asserted
they → deride → front
They argue the circumstances are so dire, and the policy designs of the Left so destructive, that we must adopt a “no enemies to the right” posture.
asserted
we → argue → posture
But no political effort can maintain the discipline and cohesion necessary for civic victory without the ability to maintain philosophical coherence.
asserted
effort → maintain → coherence
Gadflies may ensure the coalitional river does not pool and stagnate, but gatekeepers are the ones who ensure the river flows to the actual desired destination.
uncertain
river → ensure → destination
Without gatekeepers, the whole point of a political effort gets corrupted toward completely different ends.
asserted
point → corrupt → ends
There was a time when gatekeeping was a straightforward task.
asserted
gatekeeping → be → ?
This was the pattern started by National Review and taken up by so many others.
asserted
This → start → others
This led to the success of the early conservative movement in the 20th century.
asserted
This → lead → century
But today holds different challenges.
asserted
today → hold → challenges
For better or worse, information has now been hyper-democratized.
asserted
information → hyper → ?
Individuals can hear, read, and believe as they choose on virtually every topic.
asserted
they → hear → topic
They can all find someone who will give them exactly what they want.
asserted
they → find → what
Fame, fortune, relevance … you can have it all if you just give people exactly what they want.
asserted
they → have → what
In such circumstances, how does an intellectually serious effort rise and gatekeep itself to maintain consistency, discipline, and legitimacy?
asserted
effort → rise → consistency
How does conservatism maintain itself as something similar to itself in Buckley’s time?
asserted
conservatism → maintain → time
First, we must recognize the failures of those we once took to be the next generation of gatekeepers.
asserted
we → recognize → gatekeepers
Then, we must reckon with the fact that the digital age has created a “year zero” moment in history, a point marking a new beginning in building a movement from the ground up and engaging with rank-and-file members of society in an entirely different manner.
asserted
age → reckon → manner
The political ground shifted in 2015 as a seemingly large and affluent conservative movement suddenly switched gears to embrace a host of ideas and behaviors I had thought were outside of conservatism, while jettisoning many clear and precious precepts I thought were beyond question.
asserted
I → shift → question
And, one by one, the gatekeepers succumbed to the zeitgeist.
asserted
gatekeepers → succumb → zeitgeist
Whatever gatekeeping was attempted either fell flat or was not even attempted.
asserted
attempted → attempt → ?
A surge of populism suddenly held sway over everything.
asserted
surge → hold → everything
, the reply from so many of those I had respected as gatekeepers became, “There go the people.
asserted
I → respect → people
I must follow them, for I am their leader.
asserted
I → follow → them
We cannot have a conservative movement in the digital age if we depend upon the old formulation of a few conscious conservatives leading the way for the natural conservatives to follow.
asserted
conservatives → have → way
If we are going to have a conservative movement in the digital age, we must have a movement where we are all, top to bottom, conscious conservatives.
asserted
we → go → bottom
The role of gatekeeper in this age cannot be one that merely hedges in the margins.
asserted
that → hedge → margins
These days, you cannot simply tell people what to think.
asserted
you → tell → what
They will rebel and seek out friendlier voices that don’t challenge their assumptions.
asserted
that → rebel → assumptions
Instead, we must endeavor to teach people how to think.
asserted
we → endeavor → people
We must give them the rhetorical tools to know when they are being patronized, lied to, manipulated, and misled.
asserted
they → give → tools
We must have a movement where intellectualism is not simply for the highbrow and high-minded but the purview of the grassroots and rank-and-file.
asserted
intellectualism → have → grassroots
If the political figures of the day cannot be trusted to gatekeep conservatism, then we must be concerned with engaging the American mind at the most basic and fundamental level.
asserted
we → trust → level
The gatekeepers of the movement must become the people themselves.
asserted
gatekeepers → become → movement
We must alter and adjust the incentive structures so that a principled conservative movement exists beneath, beyond, and separate from those who failed to be our gatekeepers.
asserted
who → alter → those
Today, a conservative gatekeeper cannot merely be a philosopher and an idealist but must become a teacher who imparts the missing ingredients at the core of the civic rot of our country: reason and rhetoric.
asserted
who → become → country
Justin Stapley is a graduate student at Utah Valley University, where he studies constitutional governance, civics, and law.
asserted
he → study → governance
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
