The Wyoming Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday in a case concerning counties’ authority to regulate gravel and sand pit operations on some 3.4 million acres of state trust lands scattered throughout the state.
asserted
Court → hear → state
“There are 84 active solid-mineral gravel leases currently before the (State Board of Land Commissioners), so this impact is far and wide,” Cheyenne-based attorney Deborah Roden told the justices.
asserted
Roden → be → justices
Roden represents Casper-based gravel operator Prism Logistics, which acquired state approval to pursue gravel mining on a cluster of state trust lands next to a rural neighborhood at the base of Casper Mountain, a popular recreation spot.
asserted
which → represent → Mountain
The appeals case centers on whether the Natrona County Board of Land Commissioners acted within its authority when it rezoned the area back to a previous designation that prohibits heavy industrial use after a county-wide public outcry against the proposed gravel operations.
asserted
that → center → operations
In response to the project, Coates Road area neighbors formed the Casper Mountain Preservation Alliance, which gathered more than 20,000 signatures from residents throughout the county in opposition.
asserted
which → form → opposition
“My gosh, I just don’t think we can ignore that,” William Schwartz, an attorney for Natrona County, told the justices.
asserted
Schwartz → think → justices
At stake is whether counties can impose zoning regulations to protect homeowners from industrial impacts, Schwartz added, as well as activities that would disrupt recreation areas and sensitive habitats.
asserted
that → impose → areas
“And this is the crown jewel of Casper, Wyoming,” he said.
asserted
he → say → Casper
Counties, in his legal opinion, have the authority to impose such restrictions and, if the high court agrees, it’s highly unlikely they would shut down gravel and sand operations en masse on state lands.
asserted
they → have → lands
“As we know, there are lots of counties in Wyoming that don’t even have zoning,” Schwartz told the justices, “and these (county-level) decisions about whether to regulate gravel pits, I think, are probably highly dependent upon their location.
asserted
I → know → location
Counties ought to have the ability, where they do have zoning, to regulate something as sensitive as this.”
asserted
they → have → this
In response to the county’s rezoning, Prism asked the Natrona County District Court to review whether the county had the authority to make the change.
asserted
county → ask → change
A judge sided with Prism, and Natrona County appealed to the Wyoming Supreme Court.
asserted
County → side → Court
Legal arguments Wednesday centered on whether Wyoming law views gravel pits narrowly as mining a mineral, or more broadly as commercial and industrial operations.
asserted
law → center → operations
Attorneys for both parties agree that counties have little authority over mineral production activities like coal, oil and natural gas operations.
asserted
counties → agree → operations
But they disagreed about whether state law views gravel and sand as a mineral in the classic sense of mining and processing.
asserted
law → disagree → mining
The State Land Board regards gravel and sand as a mineral — a misinterpretation of the Wyoming Legislature’s intent when it comes to county authority, Schwartz said, pointing to case law.
asserted
Schwartz → regard → law
Upon granting statehood in 1890, the federal government bestowed some 4.2 million acres of “ state trust lands ” to Wyoming, which now manages about 3.4 million acres of trust land.
asserted
which → grant → land
The Wyoming Constitution prescribes that the primary use of those lands, which are scattered throughout the state in a checkerboard pattern, is to support public schools, including activities that generate revenue for schools.
asserted
that → prescribe → schools
The Office of State Lands and Investments commonly leases those lands — often referred to as “school sections” — for grazing and industrial development such as mining and oil and gas drilling.
asserted
Office → lease → mining
“I think what the district court missed here is the really vital question of who decides whether it’s mineral or commercial or industrial,” he said.
asserted
he → think → what
“Who decides here is the Legislature.”
asserted
decides → decide → ?
Roden countered that although counties have authority to “weigh in,” or impose local zoning on industrial and commercial operations, they may not override the state’s authority regarding “mineral” extraction, which includes gravel and sand.
uncertain
which → counter → gravel
“Our position in this case is simple,” Roden said.
asserted
Roden → say → case
“The statutes and the case law and the regulations clearly demonstrate that Prism’s state land leases are not subject to local zoning, and we would ask this court to find as such.
asserted
we → demonstrate → court
Regardless of how the court rules, the legal wrangling has revealed a need to allow for more local input about what should happen on state-managed lands, said Carolyn Griffith, who lives near the proposed mine and chairs the Casper Mountain Preservation Alliance.
asserted
who → rule → Alliance
“It’s now evident that additional legislation may be needed to ensure that industrial activities on state lands align with responsible standards required of everyone else within that planning zone,” Griffith told WyoFile.
uncertain
Griffith → ’ → WyoFile
The court will issue a written decision, Chief Justice Lynne Boomgaarden said.
asserted
Boomgaarden → issue → decision
High court decisions often come months after oral arguments.
asserted
decisions → come → arguments
Meantime, stakeholders await the court’s decision in a closely related case.
asserted
stakeholders → await → case
Under public pressure, the State Board of Land Commissioners denied a request by Prism Logistics to grant an extension for the same gravel leases in question.
asserted
Board → deny → question
A subsequent Natrona County District Court ruling in January sided with the gravel miner.
asserted
ruling → side → miner
The state appealed to the Wyoming Supreme Court.
asserted
state → appeal → Court
The Aporia
