A Michigan appeals court has upheld a survivorship deed signed 14 years ago, ruling that a house in Troy belongs to a woman who was considered a grandmother by the owner, rather than the owner's only legal heir.
asserted
who → uphold → heir
A three-judge panel of the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld a lower court decision that granted partial summary disposition in favour of Jessica Rae Harless.
asserted
that → uphold → Harless
The legal challenge was brought by Anita Lanctot, who served as the personal representative of the estate of her late mother, Shirley Ann Page.
asserted
who → bring → mother
The dispute focused on a single-family home at 212 Hickory Drive in Troy, Michigan.
asserted
dispute → focus → Troy
On 30 November 2012, Page signed and recorded a quitclaim deed that transferred the property from her sole ownership into the names of herself and Harless.
asserted
that → sign → herself
Although Harless was not related to Page by blood or law, court records state that she considered Page her grandmother.
asserted
Page → relate → blood
After Page died on 12 September 2023, Lanctot filed a lawsuit in the Oakland Circuit Court to claim the property for her mother's estate.
uncertain
Lanctot → die → estate
Challenge over property language
Lanctot filed her civil lawsuit on 31 July 2024.
asserted
Lanctot → file → July
Her claims included quiet title, deed reformation, statutory conversion, rescission, and identity theft.
uncertain
claims → include → title
She argued that her mother's 2012 deed did not legally create a joint tenancy because it did not specifically use the word "joint" or "jointly".
asserted
it → argue → word
Under Michigan property law, when a property is transferred to two or more people, the law generally assumes they hold it as tenants in common rather than as joint tenants, unless the deed clearly states otherwise.
asserted
deed → transfer → tenants
Under a tenancy in common, a deceased owner's share passes to their heirs or estate.
asserted
share → pass → heirs
Under a joint tenancy with rights of survivorship, the property automatically passes to the surviving owner named in the deed.
asserted
property → pass → deed
Lanctot argued that because the deed did not include the word "joint", it created only a tenancy in common.
asserted
it → argue → common
This would mean that Page's half of the property should pass to Lanctot as her mother's only legal heir.
asserted
half → mean → heir
However, the main wording in Page's 2012 quitclaim deed stated that she transferred the house to herself and Harless "not as tenants in common, but with full rights of survivorship."
asserted
she → state → survivorship
On 6 June 2025, the Oakland Circuit Court granted partial summary disposition in favour of Harless on the quiet title and deed reformation claims.
uncertain
Court → grant → claims
The judge ruled that clearly stating the right of survivorship was enough to create a joint tenancy with rights of survivorship.
asserted
stating → rule → survivorship
On 1 July 2025, the trial court transferred the remaining claims that did not concern ownership of the property to the district court and closed the circuit court case file.
uncertain
that → transfer → file
Lanctot then appealed the decision.
asserted
Lanctot → appeal → decision
In an unpublished opinion, the Michigan Court of Appeals rejected Lanctot's arguments and upheld the trial court's decision.
asserted
Court → reject → decision
The three-judge panel included Chief Judge Michael F. Gadola, Judge Colleen A. O'Brien, and Judge Philip P. Mariani.
asserted
panel → include → Gadola
The court explained that Michigan law does not require specific words or phrases to create a joint tenancy.
asserted
law → explain → tenancy
Instead, the main question is whether the person transferring the property clearly expressed an intention to give the surviving owner the right to keep it after their death.
asserted
person → transfer → death
"The statute does not require any specific words to create a joint tenancy; however, the statute does require that the grantor's intent be clearly expressed in the instrument," the court stated in its ruling, citing section 554.44 of the Michigan Compiled Laws.
asserted
court → require → Laws
The judges also addressed Lanctot's reliance on earlier court decisions, including the 1945 Michigan Supreme Court case Taylor v Taylor.
asserted
judges → address → Taylor
They explained that earlier rulings focused on the property owner's intention, not simply on the exact words used.
asserted
rulings → explain → words
In Taylor, the Supreme Court ruled that using the word "jointly" in an opening paragraph did not automatically create a joint tenancy when the later paragraphs failed to make the owner's intention clear.
asserted
intention → rule → tenancy
The appeals court also referred to the 1925 Michigan Supreme Court case Kemp v Sutton.
asserted
court → refer → Sutton
In that case, the state Supreme Court found that a testator had created a valid joint tenancy even though the document did not include what the court called the "talismanic words 'this is a joint tenancy.'"
asserted
this → find → what
Plain meaning of the deed
The appeals court concluded that Page's choice of words made her intention for the home after her death clear.
asserted
intention → conclude → death
"Page used the terms 'not as tenants in common' and 'full rights of survivorship' in the deed, which, by their plain language, created a joint tenancy with rights of survivorship," the panel wrote.
asserted
panel → use → survivorship
"If there was any uncertainty of intent when analyzing the deed language, the phrase 'not as tenants in common' clearly rebuts the presumption that the grantor intended to create a tenancy in common."
asserted
grantor → be → common
The court found that the deed's wording was clear on its face.
asserted
wording → find → face
As a result, there was no genuine dispute over an important fact that would require a full trial or additional evidence.
asserted
that → be → trial
"The trial court did not need to go beyond the plain language of the deed to determine that Page's intent was to create a joint tenancy," the judges concluded.
asserted
judges → need → tenancy
The ruling leaves Harless as the sole legal owner of the Troy home.
asserted
ruling → leave → home
The Aporia
