The lone holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy’s high profile murder trial said he had been harassed since the trial ended in September, and doubled down on his stance that he did not have reasonable-doubt when seeking to convict her.
asserted
he → say → her
The juror, Michael P. Desronvil, was the sole holdout who wanted to convict Clancy in the deaths of her three children — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 — in January 2023, other jurors have said since the judge declared a mistrial in the case last month.
asserted
judge → want → case
“It was like night and day,” Desronvil said of his life before and after becoming the holdout juror.
asserted
Desronvil → say → life
He spoke to Kayleigh McEnany on “Fox & Friends” on Thursday — his first media appearance since serving on the jury.
asserted
He → speak → jury
Other jurors have described a man who was unwilling to negotiate and hostile in the deliberations room.
asserted
who → describe → room
They said Desronvil was insistent on convicting Clancy of the murders, but that he was not following the reasonable-doubt standard and had been blocking a unanimous decision.
asserted
he → say → decision
Through his attorney, Edward Andrew Paltzik, Desronvil has previously denied such claims, saying, “I didn’t have any doubts.”
“As I tried to explain different possible theories during deliberation, I kept getting cut off as if I had doubts based on the evidence presented,” Desronvil said in a statement posted by Paltzik last month.
uncertain
Desronvil → deny → Paltzik
On Thursday, Desronvil said he “definitely listened” to the other jurors, but added that “some moments in that deliberation room felt like, that decisions would be swayed towards one way.”
asserted
decisions → say → way
McEnany asked Desronvil Thursday whether he had reasonable-doubt.
asserted
he → ask → doubt
He replied: “No.”
asserted
He → reply → ?
He said he had a lot of evidence to support his reasoning, but declined to share it Thursday.
asserted
he → say → it
He did, however, say he thought Clancy had thought out the murders, stating how “methodical” he believed she had been, “in the execution of the children.”
asserted
she → say → children
“That was really big for me,” he added.
asserted
he → add → me
“I thought it was logical.”
asserted
it → think → ?
Clancy, who allegedly strangled her children to death using exercise bands before throwing herself out of her home’s second-story window, could have been convicted of first-degree murder, or deemed not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility.
uncertain
who → strangle → responsibility
The jury could have also convicted Clancy of lesser charges — second-degree murder or manslaughter.
uncertain
jury → convict → charges
The other 11 jurors were poised to acquit Clancy by the insanity standard, they have said.
asserted
they → poise → standard
Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, argued that she was in the throes of postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings and was therefore unaware of her actions and unable to control herself.
asserted
she → argue → herself
The prosecution, however, argued that Clancy was not in psychosis when she killed her children, and that she planned the strangulations ahead of time.
asserted
she → argue → time
The case made global headlines and women showed up in droves to support Clancy at the courthouse and online.
asserted
women → make → courthouse
For those inside the courtroom, one piece of evidence in particular, from her husband, Patrick Clancy, made an impression, said Desronvil: A recording of the 911 call he placed when he found Clancy outside their home, injured after an attempted suicide.
asserted
he → make → suicide
“It was surreal,” Desronvil said of hearing that recording.
asserted
Desronvil → say → recording
“Hearing the pain in his voice, hearing the desperation from that clip, it was surreal.”
asserted
it → hear → clip
Desronvil said he realized his identity was going to be public the day after the mistrial, as the holdout juror was referred to as “he” and “him” multiple times.
asserted
juror → say → he
Since then, he said media have swarmed his home.
asserted
media → say → home
Despite this, he acknowledged that if he was called to be a juror again, he would do so.
asserted
he → acknowledge → this
Clancy’s lawyer Reddington, when speaking to NBC News last month about the holdout juror, defended Desronvil’s right to his own opinion.
asserted
Reddington → speak → opinion
How scrutiny of Clancy holdout juror could impact future cases
“He’s got every right to do that, and I would defend that right, but not to refuse to apply the law,” Reddington said at the time.
uncertain
Reddington → impact → time
Desronvil has since tried to shift attention away from himself and back to Clancy’s children, visiting a park dedicated to the kids with McEnany.
asserted
Desronvil → try → McEnany
He calls them “the three angels.”
asserted
He → call → them
“What I would like the world to know about me is that I do extremely care about people, especially children, because children are extremely innocent,” Desronvil said.
asserted
Desronvil → like → people
Despite his infamy now, Desronvil said he had “no idea” how big of a deal this case was in the Boston suburbs and around the country.
asserted
case → say → country
“Even during jury selection, I had no idea of this case,” he said.
asserted
he → have → case
She remains in Tewksbury Hospital while it is determined whether she will be retried.
asserted
she → remain → Hospital
She will be back in court in November for another status hearing to decide the future of the case.
asserted
She → decide → case
If you or someone you know is struggling or in emotional distress, call or text 988, or chat at 988lifeline.org 24/7, to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
asserted
you → know → Lifeline
The Aporia
