Documentarian talks about going after the richest man in the world
Alex Gibney's nearly four-hour, fire-and-brimstone documentary Musk — about tech oligarch and the world's richest man Elon Musk —
asserted
Documentarian → talk → oligarch
Instead, it is one of the most depressing and terrifying pieces of public media since An Inconvenient Truth alerted a largely unaware public to its imminent annihilation by climate change.
asserted
Truth → alert → change
Unlike An Inconvenient Truth, Gibney's Musk does not appear to offer a hopeful final message about how we might get out of this mess.
uncertain
we → appear → mess
Instead, we get an outline of how, in Gibney's view, Musk rose from upstart entrepreneur to political arriviste who orchestrated the dismantling of USAID, then attempted to create a baby farm and commune to survive a supposed civil war.
asserted
who → get → war
That is all before, we are to believe, he supposedly upended all of Western democracy.
asserted
he → believe → democracy
Sitting for an interview this September ahead of the film's showing at the Toronto International Film Festival, Gibney was not too surprised by the dour perception: he had spent the previous few days fielding defamation lawsuit threats from a similarly unhappy Musk, after all.
asserted
he → sit → Musk
Gibney also acknowledged the foreboding length: it was only after they finished their original two-hour feature that Musk allied himself with U.S. President Donald Trump.
asserted
Musk → acknowledge → Trump
At that point, he said, HBO executives told Gibney they needed to expand the work, using it as a "building block for a much more epic drama …
asserted
they → say → drama
For this figure, who has so much influence on the future of the planet, it's deserving of that three hours and 45 minutes."
asserted
it → have → hours
That relationship proved fraught on its own.
asserted
relationship → prove → own
The film hits North American theatres Oct. 16, but — at the time of the interview — Gibney was nervous.
asserted
Gibney → hit → interview
The international rights-holder, Universal, hadn't confirmed whether it would even distribute the film outside North America, given the potential of political pressure.
asserted
it → confirm → pressure
At the same time, he said Paramount's acquisition of HBO parent company Warner — with Paramount controlled by the Trump-friendly David Ellison — had him "concerned in the back of [his] mind" that the documentary's streaming release could be scuppered entirely.
uncertain
release → say → mind
Since that interview, Gibney has said international theatrical release plans are now being discussed; the documentary is slated for an early 2027 streaming release, though no specific date has been given.
asserted
date → say → release
When, or if, audiences do see it, he hopes the reception isn't quite so bleak.
asserted
reception → see → it
We're going to be lowered into the earth if we're not careful," the director said, even while recognizing the sheer inescapability of dread his film tends to elicit.
asserted
film → go → dread
"You know, and
asserted
You → know → ?
the film ends with the planet Earth exploding and Musk escaping on his spaceship.
asserted
Musk → end → spaceship
So that's about as pessimistic as it gets."
asserted
it → get → ?
Though he started the project as an avowed Musk fan — a Tesla solar panel system-owner and all — by the time he began working on it in earnest, he says, any benefit of the doubt he had extended to his subject had evaporated.
asserted
he → start → subject
When he reached out to interview Musk himself, he said he was stonewalled.
asserted
he → reach → Musk
Director Alex Gibney poses for portrait photographs for the film Musk during the 83rd edition of the Venice Film Festival in Venice, Italy, in September 2026.
asserted
Gibney → pose → September
Outreach to those around Musk was similarly stymied: close business associates uniformly refused to speak without his permission.
asserted
associates → stymie → permission
The workaround was to instead give Musk a voice of his own.
asserted
workaround → give → own
An AI-avatar, using Musk's own statements, narrates much of the documentary.
asserted
avatar → use → documentary
Much of what it says, like the real Musk's statements about the "hit piece" Gibney came out with, is overtly critical of the documentary's framing.
asserted
Gibney → say → framing
The result is a somewhat bifurcated, but overwhelmingly negative picture of a man Gibney asserts is at the centre of modern politics' downfall.
asserted
Gibney → assert → downfall
There is the charting of Musk's early history as a self-described "founder" at Paypal and Tesla — including interviews ranging from journalists covering him at the time to his former wife, Justine Musk — that characterize his public persona as an engineer and genius as little more than a PR-crafted lie.
asserted
that → be → lie
"There is a kind of generalised notion in modern societies that if you're rich, you must be very smart — you must be a genius," Gibney says, sharing the central thesis of the documentary.
asserted
Gibney → be → documentary
TikTok, X reportedly barring ads for documentary about Elon Musk
Elon Musk calls documentary about him a 'hit piece' after buzzy debut
The film includes accusations from former MAGA influencer Ashley St. Clair, the mother to one of Musk's children, who speaks about cryptic text messages Musk sent her ahead of the 2024 U.S. presidential election that saw Trump re-elected — messages that include references to an "anomaly in the Matrix" created by "ten thousand lasers in space."
uncertain
that → bar → space
Gibney then asks her whether she thinks that was a reference to SpaceX satellites.
asserted
that → ask → satellites
She responds: "I don't know where else he has lasers."
asserted
he → respond → lasers
"I should point out that the remarks about the 'anomaly in the Matrix' and lasers from space didn't come from a critic of Musk.
asserted
remarks → point → Musk
It didn't come from me; they came from Elon Musk himself," Gibney said.
asserted
Gibney → come → Musk
That is despite a letter sent to Gibney's Jigsaw Productions, claiming the exchange reinforces a disproven conspiracy theory that Musk used his internet provider, Starlink, to interfere with voting machines in swing states.
asserted
Musk → send → states
"That seems a legitimate thing to put in a film," Gibney said.
asserted
Gibney → seem → film
"I don't say in the film that's what he did.
asserted
he → say → what
I say that's been said."
asserted
that → say → ?
Similarly when pressed, Gibney defended the decision of including an AI-generated avatar in a documentary critical of an AI proponent: "We used some AI tools, but they're being used by — they're guided by human hands," he said.
asserted
he → press → hands
He explained that the idea was for it to serve as a sort of "agent provocateur" that foments a negative reaction to AI proliferation by forcing audiences to witness it.
asserted
that → explain → it
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
