Eight states sued OpenAI on Wednesday, accusing it of deceiving parents about the safety of ChatGPT.
asserted
states → sue → ChatGPT
The coordinated lawsuits — filed individually in Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska, West Virginia, Arkansas, Arizona, Idaho and Montana — target the AI giant for the harms its generative AI chatbot is alleged to have caused to children in those states.
asserted
chatbot → file → states
“OpenAI, they wanted to be the first to market.
asserted
they → want → market
They advanced ChatGPT at a high speed, even though they knew that they were hurting children, lying to parents and breaking our laws,” Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird said at a news conference announcing the legal action.
asserted
Bird → advance → action
“Everyone must follow the law.”
asserted
Everyone → follow → law
The company’s flagship AI model, ChatGPT, launched the generative AI boom in November 2023, when it exploded into mainstream culture, and quickly became the biggest chatbot in the world.
asserted
it → launch → world
This summer, it surpassed 1 billion global monthly active app users.
asserted
it → surpass → users
In recent years, users have increasingly turned to it and other chatbots for everything from friendship to therapy, as well as a slew of agentic tasks in their personal and professional lives.
asserted
users → turn → lives
Bird was joined at Wednesday’s news conference by Kansas Attorney General Kris Kobach, Nebraska Attorney General Mike Hilgers and West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey.
asserted
Bird → join → Kobach
She said they aim to exhibit “a united front against companies that make money hurting our kids and breaking our laws.”
asserted
that → say → laws
She pointed to ChatGPT’s coaching users to commit suicide, aiding users in ways that enabled them to harm other people and offering dangerous medical advice (which, in one case, led a Texas teen to die from an overdose).
asserted
which → point → overdose
She also referred to OpenAI’s failing to stop its rogue AI agents from illegally hacking into other companies.
asserted
She → refer → companies
OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri wrote in a statement that OpenAI has “built industry-leading age-specific protections into our product that many other AI products lack.”
asserted
products → write → that
“While no system can be perfect, we’ll continue to work with experts to inform our work and build additional safeguards, such as the parental controls, break reminders and age-appropriate model protections that exist today,” Pusateri wrote.
asserted
Pusateri → continue → controls
“We’re committed to working with states on advancing pragmatic AI policies that apply to the entire AI industry, not just one company.
asserted
that → commit → industry
He added that OpenAI will continue sharing information about the “extensive steps we’ve taken in response to incidents of misalignment.
asserted
we → add → misalignment
We’ve strengthened safeguards across our research systems, continued a broader review of model activity, provided notifications to affected organizations, and published our findings.”
asserted
We → strengthen → findings
Last month, OpenAI launched a restricted ChatGPT mode for teenagers — users ages 13 to 18 — that offers stronger safety guardrails and parental controls.
asserted
that → launch → guardrails
Kobach said attorneys general across the country have occasionally brought multistate lawsuits over the decades, such as the litigation around opioids and tobacco or constitutional violations by a presidential administration.
asserted
attorneys → say → administration
“But usually, you don’t see us getting together to announce the lawsuit unless it’s really, really important,” Kobach said.
asserted
Kobach → see → lawsuit
“This is one of those lawsuits that’s really, really important, which is why I did the 3½-hour drive and Mike did a 2½-hour drive from Lincoln.”
asserted
Mike → ’ → Lincoln
Kobach noted that the suits are being brought under each state’s respective consumer protection laws.
asserted
suits → note → laws
Their lawsuits allege that ChatGPT’s overly agreeable design has led people to trust and depend on it, making it particularly “dangerous” for vulnerable users like children.
asserted
it → allege → children
They also cite a growing body of research suggesting that ChatGPT is “degrading critical thinking skills,” “encouraging paranoias and delusions” and “promoting unhealthy behaviors and relationships.”
asserted
ChatGPT → cite → behaviors
The state lawsuits follow another proposed class-action lawsuit filed Tuesday in federal court in San Francisco, which accuses OpenAI of unlawfully taking “vast amounts of highly sensitive and valuable data” from millions of children who used ChatGPT.
asserted
who → follow → ChatGPT
A slew of other tech companies — including Meta and Roblox — have been sued over similar allegations of deceptive practices that caused harm to children through addiction or exploitation by predators.
asserted
that → include → predators
Kobach said Wednesday that federal lawmakers have so far failed to keep AI companies in check, saying, “Many in Congress appear not particularly willing to oppose any significant restraint on the corporations engaged in AI.”
asserted
Many → say → AI
That means AI companies are effectively asked to police themselves, he added.
asserted
he → mean → themselves
“Regulating AI through legislation and just hoping that someday, somehow, we have a standard that can be imposed that will make everything good is a fool’s errand.
asserted
everything → regulate → standard
It’s slow, it’s weak, and it’s likely to be ineffective,” Kobach said.
asserted
Kobach → ’ → ?
“We certainly invite Congress and state legislators to keep investigating, keep looking for solutions.
asserted
We → invite → solutions
But in the meantime, we are not going to hold our breath.”
asserted
we → go → breath
The Aporia
