- Do you have a story?
asserted
you → have → story
An Albanian burglar will be deported from Britain for a fifth time - as the Daily Mail won a fight to stop the serial criminal from keeping his name secret.
Dorian Puka, 32, has been jailed four times for burglaries and deported on each occasion only to sneak back in illegally.
asserted
Puka → deport → occasion
He has become notorious for taunting the authorities by flaunting his wealth on social media, with photos showing him posing in fast cars, drinking in nightclubs and feeding banknotes to his dogs.
asserted
him → become → dogs
He appealed against his latest deportation and applied for asylum on the basis his life could be at risk if he returns to Albania.
uncertain
he → appeal → Albania
During a hearing in London last month, Puka's lawyers persuaded a judge to grant anonymity on the basis that revealing his location could put him at risk.
But the judge axed the order after the Mail pointed out that Puka had filmed a video of himself inside Taylor House Immigration Tribunal Centre and shared it on social media.
uncertain
Puka → persuade → media
As well as revealing his location, the footage violated a ban on photography and filming inside court buildings.
asserted
footage → reveal → buildings
Anyone found to have broken the rules can be prosecuted for contempt of court and face a prison sentence of up to two years.
asserted
Anyone → find → years
'I accept that the image was taken in the waiting area at Taylor House, which is clearly identifiable,' Judge Ravinder Bagral wrote in response to the Mail's challenge.
asserted
Bagral → accept → challenge
'The appellant's response neither admits nor denies the journalist's account, and I have no reason to doubt it.
asserted
I → admit → it
I therefore accept that the appellant placed his attendance at the tribunal in the public domain.'
asserted
appellant → accept → domain
Dorian Puka, 32, has been jailed four times for burglaries and deported on each occasion only to sneak back in illegally.
asserted
Puka → jail → occasion
He has taunted the authorities by flaunting his wealth on social media
Puka had filmed a video of himself inside Taylor House Immigration Tribunal Centre and shared it on social media - prompting the Daily Mail's legal challenge
A social media showing Puka offering a wad of banknotes to his dogs, Mouse and Cobra
Puka first arrived in the UK illegally in 2012 or 2013 while he was still a teenager, according to court documents.
His first prison sentence was in January 2016, when he was handed a nine-month prison sentence for burglary.
uncertain
he → taunt → burglary
He was deported just a month into his sentence before returning illegally at an unknown date.
asserted
He → deport → date
On November 3, 2016 he was found guilty of burglary a second time and jailed for two months.
asserted
he → find → months
He was deported back to Albania after 20 days.
asserted
He → deport → days
He then returned illegally for a third time and was arrested on November 17, 2017 - only to be let out of custody to offend again.
asserted
He → return → custody
This time he was convicted of burglary, theft and driving offences and jailed for 42 months.
asserted
he → convict → months
On December 20, 2018, he was returned to Albania.
asserted
he → return → Albania
Yet again, he sneaked back into the UK before being arrested in August 2019 for dangerous driving, driving while disqualified and going equipped for theft.
asserted
he → sneak → theft
He went on to receive his fourth jail sentence - of 18-months imprisonment - and was deported to Albania on July 29, 2020.
asserted
He → go → July
Puka told the court he last entered the UK illegally on October 15, 2021.
asserted
he → tell → October
This time, he sought to stay by exploiting the asylum system - applying for leave to remain in December 2022 and then asylum in July 2023.
asserted
he → seek → July
His claim was rejected by the Home Office in September 2024 but he appealed.
uncertain
he → reject → September
This appeal is what was considered by Judge Bagral last month.
asserted
what → consider → Bagral
At the hearing, Khdeeja Khan - representing the Home Office - asked Puka if he admitted to being a serial offender who had been jailed and deported four times before returning each time illegally.
asserted
who → represent → Puka
She told the court: 'Do you accept you have continuously committed serious crimes in the UK involving burglaries?
asserted
you → tell → burglaries
Do you accept continually breaching UK border laws and breaching a deportation order four times?
asserted
you → accept → order
Puka accepted that his offences were 'very serious' but claimed he had been 'forced' to return to the UK illegally because of fears for his safety.
asserted
he → accept → safety
Puka has been posting extensively about his lavish lifestyle in a clear challenge to the UK authorities
Puka driving his £184k Lamborghini which he frequently shows off.
asserted
he → post → which
His Savannah cat, a hybrid breed of a domestic and wild cat, features in many of his social media videos
Puka enjoys an expensive night out in the VIP section of the plush Cirque le Soir - a favourite haunt for A-listers
He told the court he had first arrived in the UK aged 13 before falling into the clutches of a powerful Albanian crime gang that forced him to carry out burglaries.
asserted
that → feature → burglaries
He claimed that when he later tried to leave the gang, both he and his family became targets.
asserted
he → claim → gang
Each time he was deported to Albania, he said he learned gang members were looking for him and left again within two to three weeks.
asserted
members → deport → weeks
Ms Khan suggested there was no evidence to support his claims that he was at risk in Albania and noted that he had not reported any threats to police in either Albania or the UK.
Ms Khan also noted Puka's prolific social media use and questioned why he would continually draw attention to himself online if he was really in fear of a gang.
uncertain
he → suggest → gang
Throwing out his appeal, Judge Bagral said he did not accept that Puka had been forced to commit crimes by a gang or remained at risk from them.
asserted
Puka → throw → them
'I do not accept that the Appellant was associated with the gang in the manner alleged, that its members controlled or compelled him to offend, that he was kidnapped, or that he was repeatedly traced in Albania or elsewhere in Europe,' he wrote in his judgment.
asserted
he → accept → judgment
'Nor am I satisfied that the alleged gang retains an adverse interest in him, that publicity created or increased any such interest, or that he is at risk through a blood feud.'
asserted
he → allege → feud
He found there were 'no compelling circumstances capable of outweighing the substantial public interest in his deportation'.
asserted
He → find → deportation
The Aporia
