If Canadians focused solely on recent commentary from union leaders and their lawyers, they’d be forgiven for thinking the current Liberal government has been engaged in a long battle against workers’ rights, culminating in a final charge against the right to strike.
asserted
government → focus → right
It’s time to set the record straight.
asserted
It → ’ → record
The recently released Building Canada Strong Act does nothing to diminish hard-fought rights.
asserted
Act → release → rights
It offers sensible solutions to a persistent problem of labour disputes in certain critical supply chain industries.
asserted
It → offer → industries
Recommended Videos
Not only does Bill C-39 stand on a solid constitutional footing, we believe it could in fact — under certain circumstances — go further to protect the national interest.
uncertain
it → stand → interest
The legislation responds to a concerning pattern in collective bargaining that has exploded in the past few years — exemplified by recent airline, port and rail stoppages.
asserted
that → respond → stoppages
These disruptions have played out in a manner our labour model never envisaged: where pressure doesn’t just target the parties involved, instead it puts the national economy, especially when it impacts critical sectors of our economy, in the crosshairs and leaves millions of Canadians to pay the price.
asserted
it → play → price
The right to strike was recognized by the Supreme Court of Canada in a landmark 2015 decision.
asserted
right → strike → decision
As courts have confirmed since that date, however, this right is far from absolute.
asserted
right → confirm → date
There are circumstances where governments may reasonably intervene in work stoppages, including to protect the national interest.
uncertain
governments → be → interest
It also bears remembering why strikes and lockouts exist in our labour relations system.
asserted
strikes → bear → system
They are tools to make a negotiated agreement more likely: the economic pressure they create pushes both sides toward compromise.
asserted
they → make → compromise
When it no longer brings the parties closer to a deal and simply inflicts harm on Canadians who have no seat at the table, it has stopped serving its purpose.
asserted
it → bring → purpose
In fact, the Canada Labour Code already recognizes that some sectors are so critical to the national interest that work stoppages there cannot be tolerated.
asserted
stoppages → recognize → interest
It includes a number of restrictions on strikes and lockouts — including a total prohibition related to longshoring services in Canadian ports that are critical to Canada’s grain trade.
asserted
that → include → trade
Bill C-39 also significantly strengthens the support available to the parties at the bargaining table.
asserted
C-39 → strengthen → table
It extends the conciliation period from 60 to 90 days and introduces a Special Mediator to the bargaining process, whose role will be to assist the parties to find a resolution and, if not possible, issue a report to the Minister of Labour recommending next steps.
asserted
parties → extend → steps
With this report in hand and, upon receipt of a comprehensive National Interest assessment, the minister will have the authority under Section 107 of the Canada Labour Code to end a current work stoppage by sending the parties to a process of independent third-party binding arbitration.
asserted
minister → have → arbitration
Let us be clear — there is nothing unconstitutional about any of this.
asserted
us → let → this
In fact, the minister could even go one step further and still remain compliant with the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
uncertain
minister → go → Rights
As many industry associations and employers have argued, the minister could act pre-emptively in the most severe cases, invoking a Section 107 referral before a consequential work stoppage begins.
uncertain
stoppage → argue → referral
If the parties have had extended conciliation, the help of a Special Mediator and every other tool the new law provides, and still cannot reach a deal, they likely never will.
asserted
they → extend → deal
A strike or lockout at that point would no longer serve its purpose; it would only impose costs on farmers, manufacturers, travellers and workers across the country.
asserted
it → serve → country
In those circumstances, and only in sectors where the national interest is truly at stake, the minister could exercise the discretion the law provides to prevent the stoppage before it starts and send the outstanding issues to fair and neutral binding arbitration.
uncertain
it → exercise → arbitration
Canadians would be wise to not believe the hype.
asserted
Canadians → believe → hype
It recognizes current law and affirms the vital importance of labour stability and its connection to reliable supply chains, increased exports, and greater economic diversification required to protect Canadian sovereignty in a rapidly changing world.
asserted
It → recognize → world
The Aporia
