Contending, rebuilding or stuck in limbo: What AFL trade period says about your team’s flag hopes

Read the original at The Sydney Morning Herald ↗
Cite

Wu, A., & McGowan, M. (2026, October 14). Contending, rebuilding or stuck in limbo: What AFL trade period says about your team’s flag hopes. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/sport/afl/contending-rebuilding-or-stuck-in-limbo-what-afl-trade-period-says-about-your-team-s-flag-hopes-20261015-p615fz.html?ref=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss_feed

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

The Sydney Morning Herald · collected 2026-10-14 · by Andrew Wu, Marc McGowan

Quick Summary

The AFL trade period saw several high-profile player movements without major cliffhangers or blockbuster deals. Clubs like Hawthorn, Western Bulldogs, and Geelong made significant moves to bolster their teams for flag hopes. Hawthorn acquired players such as Zach Merrett and Ben King while trading away players deemed surplus. The Western Bulldogs secured free agents Jordon Butts and Zak Butters along with Hudson O’Keeffe in a multi-club trade deal. Geelong strengthened its forward line by acquiring Toby Greene through free agency and Rowan Marshall via trade, enhancing their chances of winning a premiership while they still have key players like Patrick Dangerfield and Jeremy Cameron at peak performance levels.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-14, using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the same event (that is the story summary below).

AI analysis runs on qwen2.5:14b, locally

Story summary

As of October 14, 2026, the AFL's recent trade period saw several teams making significant moves to strengthen their chances for the upcoming season. The Western Bulldogs and Collingwood were particularly active, with the Bulldogs acquiring players such as Jordan Butts and Zak Butters through free agency and draft picks, earning a trade rating of 9.5/10. Meanwhile, Collingwood signed Lachie Neale and Jesse Hogan in free agency while trading for Flynn Riley, despite losing Scott Pendlebury.

Notably, Hawthorn also made strategic acquisitions including Zach Merrett from Essendon via trade and Ben King through free agency, significantly bolstering their squad. These moves earned Hawthorn the highest trade rating of 10/10. Despite giving up some draft picks and players like Aidan Schubert and Sam Butler to other teams such as Geelong and Melbourne, the Hawks are considered much closer to competing for a flag this season.

Written for “AFL Trade Period Impact” on 2026-10-14, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.

Story

📰 AFL Trade Period Impact
Sports · 1 article(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 6% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Sydney Morning Herald
⚖️ leaning not scored 🔴 16% hedged 5 of 32 📰 publisher trust 61
“While both articles discuss the AFL trade period, they cover different aspects and do not focus on a single specific incident or outcome.”
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
97
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
6%
6 of 97 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Sports
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-14 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Sydney Morning Herald · 3613 article(s) · 10 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 10 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Andrew Wu
15 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
🔮 Bringing in readymade talent is worth far more than picks to the Hawks, given where they are – and even then, they didn’t give much up – so this was a ragingly successful fortnight. Western Bulldogs In: Jordon Butts (Ade/free agency), Zak Butters (PA/free agency), Finn Maginness (Haw/trade), Hudson O’Keeffe (Carl/trade), picks 42, 53, 83, 89, R2 2027 (PA), R3 2027 (Mel), R4 2027 (PA), R2 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (GC), R4 2028 (Melb) Out: Picks 14 and 33, R3 2027 (GC), R1 2028 (WB) Draft picks: 42, 53, 55, 83, 89, 91, 109 Trade rating: 9.5/10 The Bulldogs could hardly be happier.
🔮 When Will Hayward and Ollie Florent were forced out last year as part of the trade to land Charlie Curnow from Carlton, both were thanked by Cameron in the club’s public statement.
🔮 Piper said CV had attracted 35 more fans than they would have otherwise, “but I hope they’re self-employed and not being paid by Victorian employers to be there”.
🔮 South African cricket’s broadcast partner is using footage from the infamous ball-tampering scandal to promote coverage for the upcoming Test series, in an indication of the hot reception Australia will receive over the next month.
🔮 Marshall, 30, informed the Saints last week that he would not be attending the Trevor Barker Award function at Crown’s Palladium, saying he didn’t feel valued by the club and didn’t feel it was appropriate to attend while his trade request was in limbo. Marshall has played 177 games for the Saints over a 10-year stretch.
🔮 When Cameron Bancroft made the seismic decision on March 24, 2018, to take a small sheet of sandpaper out of his pocket and attempt to scuff up the ball, he should have known he would never get away with it.
🔮 When the bells tolled for Wharfie Time with just over four minutes left in this epic grand final, few, if any, of the 100,023 crammed into the MCG could have imagined what they would see next.
🔮 When the first siren sounds at the MCG on Saturday, Gerard Neesham will be in either the sandy savannah of the Kalahari Desert or a lodge in Maun, a village in Botswana that is the gateway for tourists on safari to the Okavango Delta.
🔮 The Swans have opted against scrubbing any of their five suspended players from claiming the club’s highest individual honour, the Bob Skilton Medal, which will be awarded at a function on Thursday night.
🔮 Most importantly, football lovers were given a contest, a nerve-jangler with savage momentum swings that left them guessing until the final seconds as to which team would come back to this venue next Saturday to take on minor premiers Fremantle to lift the cup.
Also by Andrew Wu
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 15 articles by Andrew Wu →
Marc McGowan
19 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
🔮 Bringing in readymade talent is worth far more than picks to the Hawks, given where they are – and even then, they didn’t give much up – so this was a ragingly successful fortnight. Western Bulldogs In: Jordon Butts (Ade/free agency), Zak Butters (PA/free agency), Finn Maginness (Haw/trade), Hudson O’Keeffe (Carl/trade), picks 42, 53, 83, 89, R2 2027 (PA), R3 2027 (Mel), R4 2027 (PA), R2 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (GC), R4 2028 (Melb) Out: Picks 14 and 33, R3 2027 (GC), R1 2028 (WB) Draft picks: 42, 53, 55, 83, 89, 91, 109 Trade rating: 9.5/10 The Bulldogs could hardly be happier.
🔮 North also swung and missed on the likes of Isaac Heeney (in 2016), Josh Kelly (2017 and 2021), Jordan De Goey (2018) and Andrew Gaff (2018) despite their willingness to give them all at least, and in some cases more than, $1 million annually on long-term deals.
🔮 Hawk forwards Aidan Schubert and Sam Butler will become Gold Coast players as early as Monday as the Suns bolster their forward line following the loss of Ben King to Hawthorn.
🔮 North Melbourne’s bold play for aggrieved Swans defender Nick Blakey could cost them in other ways as the Kangaroos close in on finally luring a big-name star.
🔮 Andrew Abdo would have known what he did as soon as the word “Jacob” left his lips – everyone else at the Rod Laver Arena function did – but he ploughed on without hesitation.
🔮 Free agency is under-used in the AFL and has not affected the equality of the competition, according to the players’ union – and could face a major overhaul as part of the league’s next pay deal.
🔮 The high-flying nephew of a premiership Magpie has smashed a long-standing AFL combine record to bolster his top-10 draft chances – and he might be wearing black and white next year.
🔮 The AFL trade period officially opens on Monday when the list managers from all the clubs gather at Marvel Stadium to get serious about the deals that will shape their teams for 2027.
🔮 Port Adelaide list boss Jason Cripps revealed this week that Essendon will bid on the Power’s next-generation academy prospect Dougie Cochrane at No.1, but there is plenty of other intrigue in how the top 10 might shake out.
🔮 Carlton’s path to secure gun father-son Cody Walker has become clearer, with bitter rivals Essendon set to bid on Dougie Cochrane with the first pick in this year’s national draft.
Also by Marc McGowan
Ruthless Roos leap towards relevance with Blakey blockbuster
2026-10-13 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 19 articles by Marc McGowan →

Topics

AFL Ess Haw Hawthorn Mel

Subjects

Mel ORG · 7× Cats ORG · 4× Ess ORG · 4× Haw ORG · 4× Butters PERSON · 3× AFL ORG · 2× Bodie Ryan PERSON · 2× Finn Maginness PERSON · 2× Hawks ORG · 2× Hawthorn ORG · 2×

Narrative

Collingwood In: Lachie Neale (BL/free agency), Jesse Hogan (GWS/free agency), Flynn Riley (Carl/trade), pick 65 Out: Scott Pendlebury (GC/trade), Pick 77, R3 2028 Draft picks: 11, 30, 67, 68, 70, 88, 106 Trade grade: 7.5/10 The Pies don’t believe in rebuilding – and showed it at the trade table, landing a 33-year-old (Neale), a 31-year-old (Hogan) and almost a third veteran over 30 in Richmond’s Jayden Short.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-14
🔮 Bringing in readymade talent is worth far more than picks to the Hawks, given where they are – and even then, they didn’t give much up – so this was a ragingly successful fortnight. Western Bulldogs In: Jordon Butts (Ade/free agency), Zak Butters (PA/free agency), Finn Maginness (Haw/trade), Hudson O’Keeffe (Carl/trade), picks 42, 53, 83, 89, R2 2027 (PA), R3 2027 (Mel), R4 2027 (PA), R2 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (GC), R4 2028 (Melb) Out: Picks 14 and 33, R3 2027 (GC), R1 2028 (WB) Draft picks: 42, 53, 55, 83, 89, 91, 109 Trade rating: 9.5/10 The Bulldogs could hardly be happier.

Claims (97 extracted, 6 hedged)

This year’s AFL trade period did not have as many blockbuster moves or as many cliffhanger deals to complete in the final, but there was still plenty enough to maintain our interest. asserted
period → have → interest
Among the players to switch teams were the league’s games record-holder, a dual Brownlow medallist, a seven-time club champion, one of the competition’s best on-ballers, an All-Australian defender, a No.1 draft pick, and a Coleman medallist. asserted
holder → switch → ballers
We graded every club’s performance through the free agency and trade period to find the best- and worst-performed in this year’s player movement window. asserted
We → grade → window
Adding King and Merrett to a team already overflowing with talent was a home run for the brown and gold, and Goater was worth the punt in a cheap-as-chips trade. asserted
Goater → add → trade
Hawthorn rated Schubert highly, but he was a mile down the key forward pecking order, while Butler and Maginness were also surplus to demands and Ryan had been delisted. asserted
Ryan → rat → demands
Bringing in readymade talent is worth far more than picks to the Hawks, given where they are – and even then, they didn’t give much up – so this was a ragingly successful fortnight. Western Bulldogs In: Jordon Butts (Ade/free agency), Zak Butters (PA/free agency), Finn Maginness (Haw/trade), Hudson O’Keeffe (Carl/trade), picks 42, 53, 83, 89, R2 2027 (PA), R3 2027 (Mel), R4 2027 (PA), R2 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (PA), R3 2028 (GC), R4 2028 (Melb) Out: Picks 14 and 33, R3 2027 (GC), R1 2028 (WB) Draft picks: 42, 53, 55, 83, 89, 91, 109 Trade rating: 9.5/10 The Bulldogs could hardly be happier. uncertain
Bulldogs → bring → Butts
They beat Geelong and others to secure Butters’ prized signature in a major coup, as well as adding fellow free agent Butts to shore up their defence and added O’Keeffe for ruck depth. asserted
They → beat → depth
They played ball in a five-club mega deal that was largely designed to appease Port Adelaide for losing Butters and avoid them matching their restricted free agency offer. asserted
them → play → offer
Butters and Marcus Bontempelli instantly become arguably the best duo in the AFL, and they will spearhead the Dogs’ premiership assault. asserted
they → become → assault
They also took a cheap flyer on ex-Hawk Maginness. asserted
They → take → Maginness
Geelong In: Toby Greene (GWS/free agency), Jordan Ridley (Ess/trade), Rowan Marshall (StK/trade), Pick 62, R3 2028 (StK), R4 2028 (Ess) Out: Jack Bowes (Ess/trade), Pick 16, R1 2027, R2 2028 Draft picks: 36, 57, 62, 75, 93, 111 Trade grade: 8.5/10 The Cats have gone all-in to win a flag while they can still get decent footy from Patrick Dangerfield and Jeremy Cameron. asserted
they → go → Dangerfield
They have strengthened every third of the field. asserted
They → strengthen → field
Veteran match-winner Greene, who came for nothing, provides a star-studded forward line with even more firepower and can also add to their secondary midfield rotations. asserted
who → come → rotations
If they can get the best out of the injury-plagued Ridley, who turns 28 next week, they have a topline defender to bolster their intercept game. asserted
they → get → game
In Marshall, the Cats land a ruckman who can match the best rucks around the ground. asserted
who → land → ground
The latter pair, though, have come at the cost of two firsts and a second, leaving the Cats without a pick until 36 in this year’s draft. asserted
pair → come → draft
They also ran out of picks to seriously get into the race for Nick Blakey – but with three high-class players to come into their best 23, the Cats should start next season one of the flag favourites. asserted
Cats → run → favourites
Trade rating: 8.5/10 No club is better at accumulating draft picks and rising in the order than the Demons. asserted
club → accumulate → Demons
Duursma was a bust at North Melbourne as the No.4 selection three years ago, but Melbourne present him with a second chance without the same risk (effectively pick 33). asserted
Melbourne → present → risk
They also brought in Lions forward Will McLachlan for pick 45, which came in the deal that sent Viney and Rivers to West Coast. asserted
that → bring → Coast
Melbourne encouraged ex-skipper Viney to explore his options after he fell behind younger midfield options. asserted
he → encourage → options
The Demons pulled another surprise when they traded pick 107 for delisted Hawks defender Ryan. Richmond In: Kieren Briggs (GWS/free agency), Nathan O’Driscoll (Frem/trade), pick 5 Out: Pick 63, R1 2027 (Rich), R2 2027 (Rich), R4 2027 (Rich) Draft picks: 2, 5, 44, 99 Trade rating: 8.5/10 Take a bow, Blair Hartley. asserted
they → pull → bow
The Tigers’ shrewd list boss enjoyed an outstanding free agency and trade period. asserted
boss → enjoy → period
Ruckman Briggs filled a position of need and arrived for free, while wingman O’Driscoll cost them only pick 63. asserted
O’Driscoll → fill → pick
But they saved their best work for last in being the successful applicant for Port Adelaide’s No.5 pick, giving them two top-five choices. asserted
they → save → choices
Richmond secured that coveted selection for a second-rounder this year, as well as first-, second- and fourth-round picks in the Tasmania-compromised 2027 draft. asserted
Richmond → secure → draft
Factor in that Tassie have already pre-listed seven of the best players from that draft class, and this is terrific business from the Tigers. asserted
this → factor → Tigers
Draft picks: 33, 49, 66, 74, 84, 102 Trade rating: 8/10 The Kangaroos intended for contracted Crows key defender Nick Murray to be their No.1 target until Blakey suddenly became available. asserted
Blakey → intend → ?
The ex-Swan delivered the type of recruiting coup that has eluded them for decades, but they certainly paid for it. asserted
they → deliver → it
Blakey joins on an eight-year deal worth up to $12 million, and will be expected to perform an integral role in North climbing the ladder. asserted
North → join → ladder
However, the failure to secure Murray from Adelaide is an obvious disappointment because the Roos still lack a reliable lockdown option for rival tall forwards. asserted
Roos → secure → forwards
It was not for a lack of trying, but they ran out of assets and could not secure the top-20 pick the Crows demanded. uncertain
Crows → try → pick
Duursma and Goater left for worse returns than they were drafted. asserted
they → leave → returns
They filled two of their three main list needs, landing key forward Amartey from Sydney to provide support for Harry McKay and bringing in veteran Whitfield from the Giants to add to their speed and ball use off half-back. asserted
They → fill → back
Equally important, they achieved their gains with minimal loss of draft capital. asserted
they → achieve → capital
Amartey came as a free agent, while Whitfield cost pick 25 and minor pick slides in the draft. asserted
Whitfield → come → draft
Their ruck stocks need replenishing after the exits of O’Keeffe and Riley, though neither was in their best 30. asserted
neither → need → 30
The big question now surrounds how the Blues will acquire son of a gun Cody Walker, who would fulfil the third list aim of future-proofing their midfield. asserted
who → surround → midfield
Their current picks of 13 and 18 can match a bid no earlier than three. asserted
picks → match → three
Amartey, Whitfield and Walker will be strong additions to a team that bowed out in the elimination final. asserted
that → bow → final
…and 57 more, not listed.
💬Give feedback
🕘History 🎫Support