Alfred Nobel intended the peace prize for those who had done the most to advance peace among nations.
asserted
who → intend → nations
Instead, it is increasingly handed out to the international activist class: people who say the right things, back the right causes and appeal to the political instincts of a handful of parliamentarians in a rarefied progressive bubble.
asserted
who → hand → bubble
Pillay is best known for chairing the U.N. commission of inquiry that accused Israel of genocide in Gaza.
asserted
that → know → Gaza
Her selection will inevitably be read as an endorsement of a U.N. culture in which hostility to Israel is not a liability but a badge of moral seriousness.
asserted
hostility → read → seriousness
When Denmark’s embassy in Pakistan was bombed after Danish newspapers republished the Muhammad cartoons, former Foreign Minister Per Stig Møller reportedly said Pillay’s response was not to defend free speech, but to suggest censorship and restrictions on it.
uncertain
response → bomb → it
Pillay reportedly called the magazine "doubly irresponsible" for publishing Muhammad cartoons.
uncertain
Pillay → call → cartoons
She is said to have described them as "malicious and deliberately provocative" and said she "fully understands why people wish to protest strongly."
asserted
people → say → them
When Islamists answer speech with threats, violence and murder, Pillay’s first instinct seems to be to scold those who exercised their right to speak.
asserted
who → answer → right
In 2022, she defended fellow U.N. commissioner Miloon Kothari after he referred to a "Jewish lobby" controlling social media and questioned whether Israel should even be a member of the United Nations.
asserted
Israel → defend → Nations
Kothari later apologized.
asserted
Kothari → apologize → ?
An event in Pillay’s honor at Berlin City Hall was canceled after the mayor withdrew her support.
asserted
mayor → cancel → support
Pillay is said to have declined to attend the 2010 Nobel ceremony for the imprisoned Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo, citing a scheduling conflict in Geneva as Beijing pressured foreign governments to stay away.
asserted
Beijing → say → governments
At Durban II the previous year, she remained seated while Mahmoud Ahmadinejad delivered an antisemitic tirade against Israel and Western delegations walked out.
asserted
delegations → remain → Israel
She condemned his speech later, but admitted that she had been "naive" about the Iranian president.
asserted
she → condemn → president
A review of Pillay’s first two years as U.N. human-rights chief found no public statements from her on abuses in dictatorships as Cuba, North Korea, Eritrea, Saudi Arabia, Sudan or Belarus.
asserted
review → find → Cuba
This is the person the Nobel Committee now presents as a model of human rights, freedom and peace.
asserted
Committee → present → rights
The prize has a long history of such decisions.
asserted
prize → have → decisions
In 1994, Yasser Arafat was awarded the Peace Prize despite a political career built around hijackings, murder and the glorification of violence against civilians.
asserted
Arafat → award → civilians
In 1973, Henry Kissinger and North Vietnam’s Le Duc Tho received it for negotiating a Vietnam ceasefire that quickly fell apart.
asserted
that → receive → ceasefire
Tho refused the award because peace had plainly not been achieved.
asserted
peace → refuse → award
In 2007, the prize went to Al Gore and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
asserted
prize → go → Change
Climate change may be an important issue; it is not, however, what Nobel had in mind when he wrote of peace among nations.
uncertain
he → have → nations
Barack Obama received the award in 2009, less than nine months into his presidency and before any significant diplomatic achievement.
asserted
Obama → receive → achievement
Even Obama seemed embarrassed by how premature it was.
asserted
it → seem → ?
The European Union won in 2012, not for a particular peace agreement or diplomatic breakthrough, but for a lofty view of Europe that appealed to the Oslo establishment.
asserted
that → win → establishment
It is an argument against pretending that every fashionable cause belongs under the heading of furthering world peace.
asserted
cause → pretend → peace
The latter involves deterrence, diplomacy, compromise, alliances and often, dealing with people one does not like.
asserted
one → involve → people
It is not always glamorous and rarely produces applause in international conference halls.
asserted
It → produce → halls
They normalized relations between Israel and several Arab states, creating embassies, direct flights, trade, investment and security cooperation.
asserted
They → normalize → embassies
They replaced formal hostility with working relations between governments that had long treated one another as enemies.
asserted
that → replace → enemies
Some may dislike Jared Kushner or the Trump administration.
uncertain
Some → dislike → Kushner
Kushner did more to advance peace between states than many of the campaigners and organizations celebrated by the Nobel Committee in recent years.
asserted
Kushner → do → years
Yet it is almost impossible to imagine the committee rewarding such an achievement.
asserted
committee → imagine → achievement
Association with Trump alone would make Kushner unacceptable to the small political circle that controls the prize.
asserted
that → make → prize
The Nobel Peace Prize is decided by five people appointed by Norway’s parliament.
asserted
Prize → decide → parliament
They have the power to pronounce who represents the world’s highest moral ideals.
asserted
who → have → ideals
Too often, they use it to reward people who share their own progressive assumptions.
asserted
who → use → assumptions
The Stockholm-based Nobel Foundation cannot simply reclaim the prize.
asserted
Foundation → base → prize
Nobel’s will assigns responsibility to a committee appointed by Norway’s Parliament.
asserted
will → assign → Parliament
But the committee can be criticized, and it should no longer be treated with the automatic reverence it enjoys.
asserted
it → criticize → reverence
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
