A Newcastle tradie has been accused of billing clients for almost 500 hours a month, including for time he allegedly spent exercising, playing sport and even on his wedding day.
uncertain
he → accuse → day
James Shafren was accused of charging 'excessive and implausible' hours, including up to 19.5 hours a day, by the company that contracted him for a residential construction project.
asserted
that → accuse → project
At his busiest, Mr Shafren claimed up to 494 hours a month at a rate of $300 an hour, amounting to almost $150,000 in invoices for his family's construction company, Basebuild.
asserted
Shafren → claim → company
When the invoices raised suspicions, the company began investigating his apparent daily routine using information publicly available online.
asserted
company → raise → information
That included records uploaded to the fitness app Strava, which appeared to show Mr Shafren regularly squeezing in one to two hours of exercise despite the lengthy working days he claimed.
asserted
he → include → days
The dispute has since reached the NSW Supreme Court, where the company, Modern Caves, is pursuing civil action over the disputed charges.
asserted
company → reach → charges
Modern Caves alleges Mr Shafren systematically overcharged for his work, with progress claims showing he billed between 17 and 19.5 hours a day and submitted monthly claims for as many as 494 hours.
uncertain
he → allege → hours
The company also alleges some of the hours claimed overlapped with work Mr Shafren was carrying out on other construction projects.
asserted
Shafren → allege → projects
James Shafren has been accused of billing for 'excessive and implausible' hours by the company that contracted him, allegations he denies
Mr Shafren claimed almost 500 hours of work, potentially amounting to nearly $150,000 in invoices for his family's construction company, Basebuild.
asserted
Shafren → accuse → company
One of the company's projects is pictured
asserted
One → picture → projects
Evidence presented to Justice Hayley Bennett included Strava records, as well as information gathered from sports league websites and Facebook posts.
asserted
Evidence → present → websites
The court also heard Mr Shafren claimed two hours of work on his wedding day, when his ceremony took place in Toowoomba, Queensland.
asserted
ceremony → hear → Toowoomba
Under the terms of the contract with the clients, Shafren was allowed to bill for 'work, including administrative work', and Justice Bennett said she would not necessarily assume it was implausible for a groom to work for two hours on his wedding day.
asserted
groom → allow → day
Instead, the judge's concerns centred on the broader evidence, including the volume of hours claimed and allegations that Mr Shafren had billed for work on different projects during overlapping periods.
asserted
Shafren → centre → periods
Justice Bennett described the claimed working hours as 'highly implausible'.
asserted
Bennett → describe → hours
She said the evidence raised a strong possibility that deceit or fraud had occurred or, at the very least, that there had been breaches of contract or misleading and deceptive conduct.
asserted
deceit → say → contract
Justice Bennett granted a search order allowing independent parties to search for documents, computers, mobile phones and other devices that could help establish what work Mr Shafren had carried out.
uncertain
Shafren → grant → work
She accepted there was a risk evidence could be concealed or destroyed, given allegations that Modern Caves' access to its construction management system had been restricted after it questioned the disputed charges.
uncertain
it → accept → charges
Mr Shafren also claimed two hours of work on his wedding day, while Strava records appeared to show him exercising during hours he said he was working
Justice Bennett said the evidence presented to the Supreme Court raised a strong possibility that deceit or fraud had occurred
asserted
deceit → claim → possibility
In a statement, Mr Shafren's solicitor Patrick Kaluski said: 'My client denies the allegations against him and I am instructed to defend the proceedings.
asserted
I → say → proceedings
In the circumstances, it is not appropriate to comment any further at this stage.'
asserted
it → comment → stage
The Daily Mail has reached out to James Shafren and BaseBuild for comment.
The case continues.
asserted
case → reach → comment
The Aporia
