Consolidated Edison customers are about to get some shocking news about their electricity service: A huge part of their bill, 21% of the delivery charge for the average customer, is paying ConEd’s property taxes.
asserted
part → get → taxes
And Mayor Mamdani doesn’t want you to know that.
asserted
you → want → that
The city’s unique and highly dysfunctional property-tax system has for decades allowed mayors and the City Council to shift taxes onto its utility systems, Con Ed being the biggest.
asserted
Ed → allow → systems
Con Ed’s property tax bill for its electric system jumped from $1 billion in 2015 to more than $2.1 billion last year, all with Albany’s blessing.
asserted
bill → jump → blessing
No other major city comes close to Gotham in cramming such a big property-tax burden into consumers’ utility bills.
asserted
city → come → bills
The taxable value of Con Ed’s system has exploded for reasons ranging from rising component costs — the basis for much of the tax calculation — to the state’s 2019 climate law, which required Con Edison to upgrade its grid (driving up its tax liability).
asserted
which → explode → liability
What matters is that the city chose, year after year, to keep squeezing more money out of that system knowing full well that ratepayers would end up paying the bill.
asserted
ratepayers → matter → bill
$32 per house
It’s another tax hike on New Yorkers, hidden in your electricity bill.
asserted
It → ’ → bill
Today the property tax alone adds roughly 5.4 cents per kilowatt-hour to customer bills in the five boroughs, a Manhattan Institute analysis found.
asserted
analysis → add → boroughs
That’s about $15 per month tacked on to a typical apartment’s electric bill, and more than $32 for a single-family house.
asserted
That → ’ → house
It’s a big part of why residential electric rates are higher in New York City than in any other major city in the eastern United States.
asserted
rates → ’ → States
That tax is also far bigger than the other, smaller taxes disclosed on Con Edison bills.
asserted
tax → disclose → bills
Taken together with the other two taxes that New York City directly adds to electric bills, the sales tax and the gross-receipts tax, city tax alone adds 8 cents per kilowatt-hour — and that’s not including state taxes or the other normal business taxes Con Edison pays.
asserted
Edison → take → taxes
The Public Service Commission, the state board that regulates utility rates, for years has been critical of the high property-tax bills Con Edison was being forced to pass along to its customers.
asserted
Edison → regulate → customers
But the PSC is powerless to prevent it.
asserted
PSC → prevent → it
Earlier this year, though, the seven-member body did the next best thing: It gave Con Edison permission to show its New York City customers just how much of their bill covers city property taxes.
asserted
much → do → taxes
By the start of next year, customers will see greater detail on where their “delivery” charge, the biggest part of their bills, is going.
asserted
charge → see → bills
‘Misleading’
(Don’t go cheering the PSC as champions of transparency and free speech just yet: This is the same board that won’t allow utilities to itemize the cost of various renewable-energy subsidies and other climate mandates.)
asserted
utilities → go → subsidies
When the looming change was publicized earlier this month, a Mamdani spokesman accused Con Ed of “misleading” customers.
asserted
spokesman → loom → customers
It’s likely that the mayor’s office will push hard to prevent the transparency measure Con Ed is set to roll out.
asserted
Ed → ’ → measure
That’s because Mamdani (and virtually all of his colleagues, Democrats and Republicans alike) signed off on mundane-sounding bills that gave the City Council permission to keep shifting more of the city’s tax burden onto utilities.
asserted
that → ’ → utilities
And Mamdani as mayor is spending every penny that this arrangement brings in.
asserted
arrangement → spend → that
Con Edison’s electric system — meaning Con Edison electricity customers — paid the equivalent of 6% of the city’s property-tax receipts last year, up from 4.4% a decade ago.
asserted
system → mean → %
It should be closer to zero: The city could, if it chose, replace the property tax with a higher sales tax.
uncertain
it → choose → tax
But then it couldn’t hide that tax the way officials would like to.
asserted
officials → hide → tax
The Aporia
