In March, two Mother Jones videographers and I stood outside the Space Center Houston and watched Kristan Hawkins, president of Students for Life, order abortion pills online.
asserted
Hawkins → stand → pills
We were shadowing Hawkins through Texas for a profile, documentary, and radio story about her role overseeing one of the anti-abortion movement’s most influential organizations, which now claims 1,700 chapters nationwide.
uncertain
which → shadow → chapters
On that spring day, we watched as Hawkins and Students for Life spokesperson, Lydia Taylor Davis, attempted to show just how easy it was to obtain abortion pills in Texas, despite its stringent laws, in the hopes that state and federal officials would do more to stop the pills.
asserted
officials → watch → pills
Now, Hawkins has been sued over the stunt, under a 2025 state law she and her team publicly lobbied for that was meant to target abortion providers and advocates.
asserted
that → sue → providers
On Tuesday, a 26-year-old Texas woman who says she was forced to carry two pregnancies to term because of the state’s abortion bans sued Hawkins, Davis, and two other Students for Life staffers in state court.
asserted
she → say → court
The woman, who uses the pseudonym Maria Puerto, claims that the stunt Hawkins staged in the Houston parking lot not only broke the law, but “mocks” Texans like her who have suffered life-altering harms from the state’s draconian laws, which ban abortion under virtually all circumstances.
uncertain
which → use → circumstances
The lawsuit cites Mother Jones’ reporting, along with Students for Life’s social media posts about the stunt.
asserted
lawsuit → cite → stunt
“Our client came to us because she has had a very difficult few years since Roe was overturned,” Molly Duane, litigation director of Amplify Legal, the litigation arm of Abortion in America, which represents Puerto, said in an interview Tuesday.
asserted
which → come → interview
“On the one hand, she loves being a mother, she has two beautiful children that she loves very much.
asserted
she → love → that
On the other hand, she was forced to become a parent long before she was ready.”
asserted
she → force → hand
The suit details how two unplanned pregnancies disrupted Puerto’s life.
asserted
pregnancies → detail → life
When she became pregnant the first time, in 2022, she was attending college on a scholarship, but she was forced to quit school when her financial aid was revoked because she missed class due to severe morning sickness.
asserted
she → become → sickness
She was also fired from her job at a convenience store.
asserted
She → fire → store
“I lost everything, my job, my career.
asserted
“I → lose → everything
Everything,” the lawsuit quotes Puerto as saying.
asserted
lawsuit → quote → Puerto
With her second pregnancy, in 2024, Puerto became depressed, especially when she discovered she was having a girl.
asserted
she → become → girl
“Since Roe v. Wade was overturned, women have not experienced a free Texas,” she says in the complaint.
asserted
she → overturn → complaint
“We have no ability to decide about our own bodies, our own families, our own lives.”
asserted
We → have → bodies
According to the lawsuit, Puerto and her two kids share a bed in a small room in her mother’s home, and she has been unable to find a job that would allow her to cover childcare costs.
uncertain
her → accord → costs
Where is paid family leave?
asserted
leave → pay → ?
Where is food and housing support for people that struggle to make ends meet?” Duane said in the interview.
asserted
Duane → struggle → interview
“Texas has helped her with none of that.”
asserted
Texas → help → that
With “nowhere else to turn for assistance,” the lawsuit says, Puerto’s lawyers decided to sue Hawkins and members of her Students for Life team who participated in the pill-ordering stunt, though the organization itself is not named as a defendant.
asserted
organization → turn → defendant
Puerto is seeking $459,782—the average cost of raising two children from birth to age 18 in the state of Texas, the lawsuit says.
asserted
lawsuit → seek → Texas
In a statement, Students for Life deemed the lawsuit “misplaced” but called the allegation that their legislative work is stopping abortions a “backhanded compliment.”
asserted
work → deem → abortions
“I feel so badly for this child who will forever have it in writing” that Puerto “wished them dead,” Hawkins wrote on X. “It’s child abuse.
asserted
It → feel → X.
Texas CPS should be called on this mother asap.”
asserted
CPS → call → mother
Duane said the attacks by Hawkins are “disappointing” though “not surprising,” and defended Puerto’s treatment of her children.
asserted
attacks → say → children
“I’ve never met a better mother, actually, who’s kinder to her kids,” Duane said.
asserted
Duane → meet → kids
The 2025 law at the heart of the case, HB 7, allows private citizens to sue anyone who mails, transports, delivers, prescribes or provides abortion pills to any person in Texas, or intends to do so.
asserted
who → allow → Texas
People who order the pills for themselves and use them to have an abortion cannot be sued, although Duane noted it’s unlikely Hawkins and her team would qualify for that exemption.
asserted
Hawkins → order → exemption
“The one thing that we can be sure of is that people who are categorically opposed to abortion didn’t take the pills themselves,” Duane said.
asserted
Duane → take → pills
HB 7 was strongly supported by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, now running for US Senate, and his anti-abortion allies around the country, who have been irate that telemedicine providers have been able to circumvent red-state abortion bans despite the end of Roe in 2022.
asserted
providers → support → 2022
Duane, formerly of the Center for Reproductive Rights, has been involved in several high-profile cases challenging Texas abortion laws, including a lawsuit aimed at forcing the state to clarify its “medical emergency” exception.
asserted
Duane → involve → exception
Last month Amplify and Duane sued Paxton, as well several doctors, on behalf of the family of Tierra Walker, a Black woman who died from preeclampsia in 2024 after being denied emergency abortion care.
asserted
who → sue → care
“Obviously, I have represented many clients with obstetrical complications during pregnancy,” Duane said.
asserted
Duane → represent → pregnancy
“Those are common, sure, but that is not the vast majority of people who are seeking abortion and can’t get it.”
asserted
who → seek → it
“The vast majority,” she said, “look like Maria Puerto.”
asserted
she → say → Puerto
The Aporia
