A judge blocks the government's tree-clearing spree at a municipal D.C. golf course
A federal judge has temporarily barred the Trump administration from cutting down additional trees at a D.C. municipal golf course, the latest example of a court intervening in the government's efforts to reshape pieces of the nation's capital.
asserted
court → block → capital
The long-simmering fight over East Potomac Golf Links — which President Trump wants to redevelop into a championship-level course — erupted over the weekend, after the administration cut down hundreds of trees with little notice.
asserted
administration → simmer → notice
U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes had ordered the administration in May to get court approval before cutting down more than 10 trees at the golf course.
uncertain
Reyes → order → course
Officials notified the court just before 5 p.m. on Friday of their plan to remove "up to 529 trees" in phases starting on Saturday — and had razed at least 430 by the end of the day, prompting Reyes to call an emergency hearing on Monday.
asserted
Officials → notify → Monday
"What has happened has cost the government all of its credibility with me in this case," Reyes said during the nearly four-hour hearing, held via videoconference.
asserted
Reyes → happen → videoconference
Reyes ordered a short-term stop to the tree-clearings, which she extended on Tuesday through Oct. 26.
asserted
she → order → Oct.
She warned Monday that "if that order is violated by two seconds, there are going to be contempt proceedings.
asserted
order → warn → seconds
"
Reyes also ordered top officials from the Department of Interior and the National Park Service to testify at a hearing next Monday, to shed more light on the government's motivations and the future of the historic course.
asserted
officials → order → course
"The questions go to whether or not I've been lied to," Reyes said.
asserted
Reyes → go → ?
"Whether I've been lied to in declarations about the plans, whether or not I've been lied to about the timing of things, and whether I've been lied to about what kind of notice the court was going to receive
asserted
court → lie → notice
East Potomac has emerged as another flashpoint in Trump's unilateral quest to remake D.C., and it's the subject of a lawsuit by critics who fear it could go the way of the now-lost White House East Wing unless a court intervenes.
uncertain
court → emerge → Wing
The D.C. Preservation League, along with two concerned residents, sued the government in February over what it calls an unlawful takeover.
asserted
it → sue → what
"This is a tactic we're seen before from the Trump-Vance administration – act quickly to irrevocably alter a cherished national landmark, just to advance another one of President Trump's pet vanity projects," Skye Perryman, president and CEO of Democracy Forward — one of the firms involved in the lawsuit — said in a statement this weekend.
asserted
Perryman → see → statement
Perryman told NPR on Tuesday that the golf course is the latest in a pattern of the Trump administration "undermining the entire checks and balances process in this country, which includes undermining court proceedings."
asserted
which → tell → proceedings
Trump has long floated the idea of redeveloping East Potomac into a championship-caliber course and announced plans to do so earlier this year, though his target Sept. 1 start date has come and gone without a formal proposal.
asserted
date → float → proposal
The prospect — and the lack of clarity since — has raised alarm among locals concerned about losing access to the historically affordable course and to the surrounding recreational area, which is popular with cyclists, runners, fishers and picnickers.
asserted
which → raise → cyclists
"This is a broader story than just about golf, especially when there's been this little transparency, … to say, 'Here's what the future of this little man-made peninsula is actually going to look like,'" Alex Rosen, a D.C.-based consultant who started the nonprofit Save East Po, told NPR in July.
asserted
who → be → July
A National Park Service official said in a Friday court filing that plans for renovations "remain in the conceptual stage."
asserted
plans → say → stage
And the Interior Department told NPR in a statement on Tuesday that it is "committed to continuing the relationships we have built with the local golf communities to ensure these courses are safe, beautiful, open, affordable, enjoyable, accessible, and world-class."
asserted
courses → tell → communities
But critics are growing increasingly concerned about the process itself.
asserted
critics → grow → process
They worry the Trump administration is using so-called routine maintenance as a pretext to begin redevelopment without the proper authorization.
asserted
administration → worry → authorization
"You can't continuously say, 'There's no plan' … while you're clearly taking steps to effect a plan," Rosen, who is not involved in the lawsuit, told NPR after watching the hearing.
asserted
who → say → hearing
"It's just frankly lying."
asserted
It → lie → ?
The court hopes for answers next week
asserted
court → hop → answers
At Monday's hearing, Reyes expressed regret that she hadn't issued a formal restraining order earlier, which she said was because "I have done everything humanly possible to give the government the benefit of the doubt in this case."
asserted
I → express → case
For example, after the administration quietly removed what it has since said were roughly 150 dying and invasive trees in late August, Reyes acknowledged that people were upset but declined to intervene: "I am not the Lorax," she said at an early September hearing.
asserted
she → remove → hearing
By Monday, that benefit of the doubt was gone.
asserted
benefit → go → doubt
When a government lawyer said they had done their best to notify the court, Reyes offered a sharp rebuke.
asserted
Reyes → say → rebuke
"You did not do your best," she said, voice raised.
asserted
voice → do → best
"You did your absolute worst."
asserted
You → do → worst
Perryman, of Democracy Forward, said, "What was really remarkable about the hearing yesterday is that the government did not appear to have a defense for its failure to notify the court."
asserted
government → say → court
In Friday's court filing, National Mall and Memorial Parks Superintendent Kevin Griess described the tree-clearing as part of an effort "to address deferred maintenance needs and implement treatment recommendations to restore the cultural landscape."
asserted
Griess → describe → landscape
Griess specifically cited a 2019 National Park Service report about D.C. municipal golf courses, which says several waves of tree planting at East Potomac over the last century have obscured views and changed the feel of the course from its original 1920s "links-style" design.
asserted
waves → cite → design
Griess said in his filing that NPS was able to act on the report because it had received a temporary surge of "approximately 20 to 50 trained personnel capable of performing labor-intensive grounds maintenance activities."
asserted
it → say → activities
Under questioning in court, he confirmed that surge was connected to the administration's 250th anniversary events, including the IndyCar race on the National Mall in August.
asserted
surge → confirm → August
But critics are skeptical, given the president's public statements.
asserted
critics → give → statements
Alex Dickson, one of the plaintiffs, said in a statement that "the administration is using a preservation report as cover to begin tearing out the course it was written to save."
asserted
it → say → course
Griess said he had gotten the green light last week from Frank Lands, the park service's deputy director of operations.
asserted
he → say → operations
At the judge's request, Lands then joined the hearing from his car in a parking lot.
asserted
Lands → join → lot
He said he had gotten the directive from Greg Wischer, deputy chief of staff to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum.
asserted
he → say → Burgum
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
