Oscar-winning Israeli directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor have been at the centre of a raging controversy since their documentary NAZA debuted at the Venice Film Festival last month, receiving a 25-minute standing ovation, winning the special jury prize, being acclaimed by critics and selling to more than 50 territories around the world.
asserted
documentary → win → world
But their chilling film, which has Israeli military intelligence officers and soldiers outlining the AI-powered systems behind the mass killing of Palestinian civilians as they targeted Hamas members in Gaza, has sparked a furious reaction from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
asserted
they → have → Netanyahu
“It feels a little bit like we’re in the middle of a storm
asserted
we → ’re → storm
,” Abraham said on a Zoom call from London.
asserted
Abraham → say → London
“On the one hand, we hope the storm will pass because it’s overwhelming and it can be scary at times.
asserted
it → hope → times
“But on the other hand, because of this film’s subject matter and because the killing in Gaza which it describes is ongoing, there is also an importance for the storm to happen ...
asserted
storm → describe → which
It’s [part of what] could be an important process of reckoning and accountability for what the film is showing.”
uncertain
film → ’ → what
NAZA, a military acronym for collateral damage, has its subjects talking at night on Tel Aviv rooftops about Israel’s military response to the Hamas attacks in Israel on October 7, 2023, that killed 1200 people.
asserted
that → have → people
Szor said she and Abraham planned to return to Israel soon but they have been subject to death threats and there had been a demonstration next to her parents’ home.
asserted
they → say → home
“There’s also a risk from the government [taking action],” she said.
asserted
she → ’ → action
“But we feel like we’ve done the right thing.
asserted
we → feel → thing
We feel that this was our responsibility as Israelis.”
asserted
this → feel → Israelis
In a series of attacks, Netanyahu and his ministers have accused the directors of treason, threatened to have their citizenship revoked and called for the military whistleblowers to be found and prosecuted.
asserted
whistleblowers → accuse → treason
“The film presents a false, misleading, and biased narrative that defames the State of Israel and the [Israeli military] internationally,” Netanyu said.
asserted
Netanyu → present → Israel
Abraham said he understood why Netanyahu was so unhappy about a film that damned the actions of his government.
asserted
that → say → government
“There are elections in Israel so I think he’s trying to get a quick political profit by making very populist statements and inciting against us and against the film,” he said.
asserted
he → be → film
“We were surprised by the intensity.
asserted
We → surprise → intensity
“We expected a backlash but to have Netanyahu speak about the film I think it’s already maybe five or six times has been a little bit surprising ...
asserted
it → expect → film
It’s a film which is very damning to what Netanyahu has done, to what the Israeli army has done, and I trust in the intelligence of audiences to judge for themselves.”
asserted
I → ’ → themselves
Three Israelis who describe themselves as private citizens have posted online a quickly made counter documentary, NAZA The Real Story, which has Israeli military commanders and intelligence officers talking about “how the terrorist organisation Hamas fought from among civilians” in Gaza.
asserted
organisation → describe → Gaza
Abraham said he was not upset about the alternative documentary but called it “a bit shady” for mimicking NAZA with its title and interviewing its subjects on rooftops at night.
asserted
he → say → night
“I think it’s manipulative and you know people will search for our documentary and they will watch that other counter, giving the narrative of the military spokesperson,” he said.
asserted
he → think → spokesperson
“But in terms of Israeli soldiers feeling a need to speak and share their experiences, I think that’s all right.
asserted
that → feel → experiences
“I’ve certainly received messages from Israeli soldiers in recent weeks, writing to me that it’s important that we made this film ...
asserted
we → receive → film
It would be better if the Israeli government, instead of promoting these, in my view, propaganda movies that serve their own agenda, if they would allow the international media to enter Gaza …
asserted
media → promote → Gaza
“If you are so confident that everything is OK, why are you attacking our film so ferociously?
asserted
you → attack → film
Why are you preventing international journalists from entering Gaza?
asserted
you → prevent → Gaza
Why have you killed so many Palestinian journalists?
asserted
you → kill → journalists
It just doesn’t make sense.”
asserted
It → make → sense
The quietly spoken Abraham and Szor are members of a Palestinian-Israeli activist collective who won an Oscar for the documentary No Other Land last year.
asserted
who → speak → documentary
They teamed up with The Guardian newspaper to make NAZA, with English director Jonathan Glazer, who won an Oscar for The Zone of Interest, as executive producer.
asserted
who → team → producer
So how did they find 24 Israeli military intelligence officers and soldiers who were willing to risk being interviewed on camera?
asserted
who → find → camera
“It was a long process,” Abraham said.
asserted
Abraham → say → ?
“It entailed approaching a lot of people and hearing a lot of nos.”
asserted
It → entail → nos
What helped was that after Hamas’ October 7 attacks, many Israelis joined the military and reserve force.
asserted
Israelis → help → force
“The pool of potential sources was very big and I think that really helped,” Abraham said.
asserted
Abraham → think → sources
“It became our main centre of focus for many years: how do we find these people and how do we ask them these questions about the harm to civilians?
asserted
we → become → civilians
“These are questions that the mainstream Israeli media, much of it, not all of it ... ignored, so there was a vacuum that was created where sometimes all it took was just asking the questions and you get the answers.”
asserted
you → ignore → answers
Abraham said many of their interview subjects - it is not revealed if they are still serving in military intelligence or the army - felt a responsibility to speak out.
asserted
they → say → responsibility
“They felt that – many of them, not all of them – what they had [taken] part in was wrong.
asserted
taken → feel → part
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
