- Published
"Water! Water!" the crowd shouted as it stormed a compound with data centres, armed with empty plastic bottles and jerry cans.
asserted
it → shout → bottles
There were about 300 of them, all residents on the Indonesian island of Batam, and they were furious that the taps at home had run dry, while the data centres in the new Nongsa Digital Park seemed to have enough water to protect their machines from overheating.
asserted
centres → be → overheating
"Not a single drop has come through our taps for the last three months...
asserted
drop → come → months
Our water supply had been reliable until the data centres came," Dewi Susanti, one of the protesters, told the BBC.
asserted
Susanti → come → BBC
People in her village, Bakau Serip, were now depending on tanker trucks that dispensed "dirty, cloudy and smelly" water, she said.
asserted
she → depend → water
Batam's water utility told the BBC it was working to improve supply, but did not comment on whether the disruption was linked to demand from the data centres.
asserted
disruption → tell → centres
But BP Batam, the agency overseeing trade and industry, blamed it on a prolonged dry spell and denied allegations from locals that water meant for homes was being channelled to data centres.
asserted
water → oversee → centres
This is not the first such protest in Batam, whose shrinking reservoirs find themselves under more pressure as the island tries to transform itself into a digital hub.
asserted
island → shrink → hub
Following protests in August and September, authorities told the firms opening data centres in Batam that they must build their own desalination plants instead of relying on reservoirs for freshwater.
asserted
they → follow → freshwater
But locals say they are increasingly concerned that they must now compete with servers for water.
asserted
they → say → water
"Reliable data on data centre water use in Indonesia remains scarce, partly because companies treat it as proprietary information," says Agus Hasan, a professor at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology.
asserted
Hasan → remain → Science
"We should build [data centres] rationally, transparently, and responsibly, and insist on seeing the numbers...
asserted
We → build → numbers
[Otherwise] those kept in the dark while their taps run dry will push back, and rightly so," he adds.
asserted
he → keep → dark
A backlash has been building against data centres across the world, from the US to the UK to parts of Asia, as tech companies pour billions into AI infrastructure.
asserted
companies → build → infrastructure
People are worried about how the huge, windowless buildings might change their neighbourhoods, the constant hum of machines, the security lights that could stay on all night, and the pressure this puts on water and energy resources.
uncertain
this → worry → resources
While electricity powers the centres, the water keeps the servers from frying - engineers deploy elaborate cooling systems, which consume a lot of water.
asserted
which → power → water
Research in the US suggests a typical data centre consumes around 300,000 gallons of water a day, or about as much as 1,000 US households.
uncertain
centre → suggest → water
A larger, 50MW facility could take as much water as 2,200 households per day, and enough electricity to power 22,000 homes, according to Malaysia's central bank.
uncertain
facility → take → bank
It's unclear how much water or electricity the data centres in Batam are consuming.
uncertain
centres → consume → Batam
But the island routinely faces water shortages, and the levels are worse this year, possibly because of a historic "super" El Niño.
uncertain
levels → face → Niño
Devoid of natural freshwater sources, Batam's 1.3 million people rely on rainwater collected in six artificial reservoirs.
asserted
people → rely → reservoirs
Nongsa reservoir, which supplies water to Bakau Serip, where Dewi lives, would dry up over the next month with no rainfall, simulations by local environmental non-profit group Akar Bhumi Indonesia suggest.
asserted
simulations → supply → group
"The water shortage is affecting our livelihoods...
asserted
shortage → affect → livelihoods
Money that should be used to buy rice is now spent on water drums," Dewi says.
asserted
Dewi → use → drums
"My husband has to wait up overnight to get water, and then go straight to work the next morning."
asserted
husband → have → work
Batam's water utility had earlier said that it would consider measures like cloud seeding should the water shortage continue.
asserted
shortage → say → seeding
When asked about the recent protests, they pointed us to earlier statements.
asserted
they → ask → statements
Authorities in Batam have approved 10 data centres, six of which will be located in Nongsa Digital Park.
asserted
six → approve → Park
Two are up and running, while a third is under construction.
asserted
third → run → construction
At least six more are currently under review for approval, BP Batam told the BBC.
asserted
Batam → tell → BBC
Official figures put investment in data centres on the island at more than $6.7bn (£5.1bn) as of mid-2026, spurred in part by demand from Singapore, which is just an hour away by ferry.
asserted
which → put → ferry
Singapore paused construction of data centres in 2019, citing land and energy constraints.
asserted
Singapore → pause → constraints
It lifted the ban in 2022 after introducing new efficiency standards, which prompted investors to look elsewhere.
asserted
which → lift → investors
Singapore has long been promoting the Riau Islands, which includes Batam, and the Malaysian state of Johor as "complementary" regions.
asserted
which → promote → regions
Quick to absorb the spillover, Johor approved data centre projects worth tens of billions.
asserted
Johor → absorb → billions
But this soon drew the ire of residents frustrated with noise, dust and water shortages.
asserted
this → draw → shortages
The state has since tried to regulate how much water and electricity data centres consume.
asserted
centres → try → ?
Nongsa is home to a 13,000-sq-m data centre by Hong Kong-based private equity firm Gaw Capital and Indonesian developer Sinar Primera.
asserted
Nongsa → base → Capital
In April, Singapore's DayOne signed a deal with an Indonesian state utility to build one of the country's largest data centres - around 450MW capacity, enough to power 350,000 average households.
asserted
DayOne → sign → households
In June, DayOne, chip maker Nvidia and Australian AI start-up Firmus Technologies announced a 360MW "AI factory".
asserted
DayOne → announce → factory
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
