Toronto Star
· collected 2026-10-12 · by Jakob Mcwhinney/voice Of San Diego The Associated Press
Earlier this year, the San Diego Police Department made headlines for a policy that prohibited officers from using artificial intelligence to produce police reports.
asserted
that → make → reports
Now, the department is opening the door to do just that.
asserted
department → open → that
A request for information issued by the department on July 31 describes the department looking for a program “that utilizes AI technology to assist officers and investigators in writing police reports.”
“The goal of this initiative is to enhance efficiency in report writing, thereby allowing officers to respond more quickly to calls for service,” the request for information reads.
asserted
request → issue → information
The request for information notes that the program must allow users to maintain control over the “content and structure of their reports.”
asserted
users → note → reports
It also notes that it is not a request for proposals and is being issued “solely for information gathering and planning purposes.”
asserted
it → note → purposes
The document estimates the contract value to be somewhere between $500,000 and $3 million.
asserted
value → estimate → ?
In an email, SDPD spokesperson Ashley Nicholes emphasized that the department is just in an “exploration phase” during which they are working to learn what’s out there and what best practices for such technology is.
asserted
practices → emphasize → technology
Should they choose to pursue AI-assisted police report programs, they would conduct outreach to elected officials and community members, she said.
asserted
she → choose → officials
“SDPD is constantly looking at ways to maximize efficiency throughout the department, particularly given current staffing shortages of front line officers.
asserted
SDPD → look → officers
With the emergence of AI technology, this may be an option to reduce time spent on certain tasks to put officers back in the field responding to additional calls for service faster,” Nicholes wrote.
uncertain
Nicholes → reduce → service
The request comes less than a year after the department instituted a policy that, at first, seemed wholly contradictory.
asserted
that → come → policy
In December, the department forbade officers from using AI platforms to generate reports.
asserted
department → forbid → reports
“The Department does not authorize the use of any generative Artificial Intelligence programs to author a police report,” read the memo, first reported by CBS 8.
asserted
memo → authorize → CBS
The policy change came shortly before Senate Bill 524 went into effect.
asserted
Bill → come → effect
The law required police departments statewide to begin to develop policies regulating AI use.
asserted
law → require → use
It also required that departments disclose if AI was used to write reports and hold on to any body-cam footage and audio to allow for future audits.
asserted
AI → require → audits
But the San Diego Police Department’s policy came with a huge asterisk: it only prohibited officers’ use of non-department-approved AI platforms.
asserted
it → come → platforms
So, what may have seemed like a blanket ban was really just a time-out, assuming the department officially approved an AI platform.
uncertain
department → seem → platform
Khalid Alexander is a professor at San Diego City College and the founder and president of Pillars of the Community, an organization dedicated to supporting San Diegans impacted by law enforcement.
asserted
Alexander → dedicate → enforcement
To him, the prospect seems all bad.
asserted
prospect → seem → him
“It’s just one more example of them trying to take any kind of humanity away from policing,” Alexander said.
But it goes deeper than that for him.
asserted
it → ’ → him
He not only worries about whether systems stuffed full of information about people on the worst days of their lives are actually secure, he also worries about over-reliance on the technology.
asserted
he → worry → technology
As an instructor, he constantly sees students relying on AI to complete coursework.
asserted
students → see → coursework
What it produces is work rife with errors, hallucinations and nonsense.
asserted
produces → produce → errors
He said he imagines a typically flawed system used in a law enforcement context will have even worse repercussions.
asserted
system → say → repercussions
“The problem isn’t just that they’ll use it, it’s the assumption that the technology is less biased and more correct than human beings,” Alexander said.
asserted
Alexander → use → beings
A handful of local law enforcement agencies have already leaned into AI.
asserted
handful → lean → AI
Both the Chula Vista Police Department and the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office utilize AI programs that transcribe residents’ non-emergency calls and route them to the appropriate place in a bid to free up dispatchers to take more emergency calls.
asserted
that → utilize → calls
Chula Vista, which has wholly embraced such technologies, also utilizes AI to write police reports.
asserted
which → embrace → reports
“We’re estimating usually three to five hours per shift spent on report writing,” Chula Vista Police Department Chief Roxana Kennedy told CBS8 in November.
asserted
Kennedy → estimate → November
“If that means that officer is going to get back out on the street quicker, it’s super important.
asserted
it → mean → street
Still, law enforcement’s usage of AI has long sparked controversy.
asserted
usage → spark → controversy
Many of those concerns have centered on the often-troubling biases programmed into AI platforms.
asserted
Many → center → platforms
But as AI platforms have become more integrated into everyday life, other worries have emerged, like whether the tendency of AI platforms to flatter and confirm the priors of their users can negatively impact police investigations.
asserted
tendency → become → investigations
Already, there are scores of examples of AI platforms bungling police-related tasks, leading to real-life consequences for innocent individuals, particularly when it comes to reliance on facial recognition software.
asserted
it → be → software
All of these concerns have been sent into overdrive by increasing pushback against AI-enabled surveillance cameras like Flock, of which San Diego has a robust network.
asserted
Diego → send → network
Last year, one local man spent nearly a month behind bars after being arrested for a crime he didn’t commit thanks to a misidentification from a Flock camera.
asserted
he → spend → camera
The use of AI to create police reports has been panned by some opponents and experts.
asserted
use → create → opponents
Studies have found that AI can produce writing that is better, at least technically, but may not actually save officers time.
uncertain
that → find → time
One recent study found that AI-generated police reports were “rated substantively and significantly worse on accuracy,” according to Ian Adams, a former police officer and criminology professor who ran the study.
“For a document whose downstream readers are prosecutors deciding to charge, defense attorneys probing for inconsistencies, and judges and juries reconstructing events months later, accuracy is the threshold condition,” meaning it is a minimum requirement, Adams wrote in a post on LinkedIn.
uncertain
Adams → find → LinkedIn
…and 16 more, not listed.
The Aporia
