The WA government has revised plans for the new Women and Babies Hospital, which will be built next to Fiona Stanley Hospital in Murdoch, despite opposition from doctors and parents who want it located at the QEII site in Nedlands. The hospital's planned upgrade includes adding 19 beds to Perth Children's Hospital's neonatal intensive care unit at a cost of around $95 million. The government maintains that locating the new hospital at the original site would cause unacceptable disruption or delays, but doctors and the AMA have expressed ongoing concerns about the distance from Perth Children's Hospital. Health Minister Meredith Hammat says the revised plans will improve services, including a second Newborn Emergency Transport Service base at Murdoch.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-09,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
The Western Australian government has announced revised plans for the new Women and Babies Hospital, but doctors are criticizing the decision as a "wrong choice". The hospital will be built next to Fiona Stanley Hospital in Murdoch, about 20 kilometres from Perth Children's Hospital (PCH), where some infants may need to be transferred for specialist care. This distance has been deemed unacceptable by doctors and parents, who have been advocating for the hospital to be built on the QEII campus in Nedlands, which is closer to PCH. In response to criticism, the government claims that building the hospital at the preferred location would cause "unacceptable disruption" or "intolerable delays". To mitigate this issue, the government has allocated $95 million to upgrade pediatric services at Fiona Stanley Hospital and establish a new neonatal transfer service base there. However, doctors remain unconvinced by these revisions, saying that they do not address the fundamental problem of the hospital's location.
Written for “Hospital Expansion Controversy” on 2026-09-09,
grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.
Why this leaning score
The article's own words the score was based on. Each is quoted
verbatim and was checked against the article text before being
stored, so you can find it in the original.
-
The hospital is being built next to Fiona Stanley Hospital in Murdoch, about 20 kilometres from Perth Children's Hospital (PCH) where some infants will need to be transferred for specialist care.
right emphasizes the distance as a problem
-
Doctors and parents have long said the distance is unacceptable and called on the government to find a way of building the hospital on the QEII campus in Nedlands to make it easier for women and babies to be transferred to PCH and Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital.
left quotes doctors and parents as saying the distance is unacceptable
-
But the government maintains that is impossible without unacceptable disruption to other hospitals on the site, or intolerable delays.
right attributes a position to the government
Leaning score -0.35 for article 7245 (medium confidence, 3 verified quotes) · logged 2026-09-09
In short:
Paediatric services at Fiona Stanley Hospital will be upgraded and a new neonatal transfer service base established as part of revised plans for the new Women and Babies Hospital.
asserted
base → upgrade → Hospital
Around $95 million has been set aside to add an extra 19 beds to Perth Children's Hospital's neonatal intensive care unit.
asserted
million → set → unit
But doctors and the opposition are continuing to push for the new hospital to be built at the QEII site in Nedlands.
asserted
hospital → continue → Nedlands
Plans to manage high-risk births at WA's new Women and Babies Hospital represent the government doubling down on a "wrong decision", the doctors' lobby says.
asserted
lobby → manage → decision
The hospital is being built next to Fiona Stanley Hospital in Murdoch, about 20 kilometres from Perth Children's Hospital (PCH) where some infants will need to be transferred for specialist care.
asserted
infants → build → care
Doctors and parents have long said the distance is unacceptable and called on the government to find a way of building the hospital on the QEII campus in Nedlands to make it easier for women and babies to be transferred to PCH and Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital.
But the government maintains that is impossible without unacceptable disruption to other hospitals on the site, or intolerable delays.
asserted
that → say → site
Instead, the government has now outlined how it intends to allay the concerns of medical professionals and families by expanding existing services.
asserted
it → outline → services
Neonate transfer upgrade
Paediatric services at Fiona Stanley Hospital will be upgraded, including extra specialist staff and services, and a second Newborn Emergency Transport Service (NETS) base established for babies who need to be transferred from the new hospital.
asserted
who → upgrade → hospital
"We've heard from clinicians that the time for the baby to reach the NETS team is a key consideration," Health Minister Meredith Hammat said.
asserted
Hammat → hear → team
"These are specialised staff, these are like mobile intensive care units and so they do provide that critical opportunity to stabilise a baby and transport them, so that is why we're making the decision about having a base here.
asserted
we → provide → base
The government also believes locating a team at Murdoch will help with the timely transfer of babies from regional hospitals, because it is closer to Jandakot Airport where Royal Flying Doctor Service aircraft land.
asserted
aircraft → believe → Airport
Around $95 million has been set aside to add an extra 19 beds to PCH's neonatal intensive care unit.
asserted
million → set → unit
Two adult beds will be added to handle a "very small number of cases" where women needed to birth at the children's hospital.
asserted
women → add → hospital
A consultation report, dated November 2025 but only tabled in parliament today, revealed clinicians rejected the idea of creating a smaller "satellite" facility to allow for births at PCH "due to clinical safety risks, limited workforce sustainability and fragmentation of services".
asserted
clinicians → date → services
Ms Hammat said few women would give birth at PCH.
asserted
women → say → PCH
"It would only apply in those circumstances, a small number of circumstances, where a parent might also need to continue to receive treatment," Ms Hammat said.
uncertain
Hammat → apply → treatment
Ongoing concerns
Australian Medical Association WA president Kyle Hoath said while the government's announcements were welcome, the profession still wanted the new hospital to be built at the QEII site.
asserted
hospital → ongoe → site
"I appreciate that it's a full site that's difficult to make those allowances on, but this isn't good enough," he said.
asserted
he → appreciate → allowances
"We have a separation of services that need to be next to each other."
asserted
that → have → other
Opposition Health spokesperson Libby Mettam also wants a maternity hospital at the QEII site and said the government's plans were "flawed".
asserted
plans → want → site
"It will still require a 20-kilometre journey for neonates requiring high-risk surgery at Perth Children's Hospital," she said.
asserted
she → require → Hospital
Dr Hoath said his members believed between 100 and 200 babies a year would need to be moved to PCH.
asserted
babies → say → PCH
The government's response to the November 2025 consultation report notes there is "no consensus on the size of the cohort needing 'time-critical neonatal transfer'".
asserted
response → note → transfer
The upgrades at PCH will require admin staff to be moved out of the building and the relocation of a surgical ward.
asserted
staff → require → ward