Mount Pleasant, Michigan
A NEW CAMPAIGN AD FROM MIKE ROGERS says a lot about the kind of senator he would be for Michigan.
asserted
he → say → Michigan
I don’t think it’s the message he wants to be sending.
asserted
he → think → ?
The ad is about the tariffs that Donald Trump has imposed on Canada since taking office, and the trade war that’s unfolding as a result.
asserted
that → impose → result
The tariffs are already damaging Michigan’s economy, especially the auto industry where—according to one estimate—the extra charges on parts crisscrossing the Michigan–Ontario border have saddled carmakers with more than $4 billion in extra costs.
uncertain
charges → damage → costs
I have heard it in my conversations with voters across the state.
asserted
I → hear → state
But it’s evident in the polls as well, which show voters here oppose the tariffs by a two-to-one margin—quite possibly because they have heard (correctly) that Canadian tariffs will raise the prices of everything from cosmetics to skating gear.
uncertain
tariffs → ’ → gear
Rogers’s new ad leans hard into the local anxiety.
asserted
ad → lean → anxiety
It places him at a pub, sitting at a barstool while a hockey game plays on the television, a Canadian beer right there on the bar.
asserted
game → place → bar
“Drinking a Labatt and watching the Red Wings—man, it just doesn’t get any more Michigan than that,” Rogers says, speaking in what I am guessing is some political consultant’s idea of how real Michiganders talk.
asserted
Michiganders → drink → that
Then Rogers waxes indignant about the tariffs: “We know that Canada is not our enemy.
asserted
Canada → wax → tariffs
We need to end this tariff war.
asserted
We → need → war
The indignation would have been perfectly natural coming from the version of Rogers that represented Michigan in Congress from 2001 to 2015.
asserted
that → come → 2015
Back then, he was a fairly typical, pro-business Republican—the type who would reliably stand alongside the Chamber of Commerce and the “Detroit Three” in condemning the tariffs threatening a supply chain that has largely benefited both Americans and Canadians.
asserted
that → stand → Americans
But that’s not the version of Rogers that has been running for Senate this year.
asserted
that → ’ → Senate
Rogers 2.0 stands by Trump, and until about five minutes ago he stood by Trump’s tariffs too—rationalizing them as “necessary” because “the Canadians have not been good partners.”
asserted
Canadians → stand → them
His flip-flop drew instant attention from the state’s local outlets, including the Detroit Free Press and the Detroit News, in part because it followed a similar reversal on the war in Iran—which, after praising it for months, Rogers is now saying must end.
asserted
Rogers → draw → months
Still, Rogers has been consistent about one thing: He won’t take on Trump directly.
asserted
He → take → Trump
Whether talking about the “war” with tariffs or the war with bombs, he won’t blame the president.
asserted
he → talk → president
And it’s no mystery why.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Breaking with Trump is not something you can do in modern Republican politics.
asserted
you → break → politics
That explains the precarious political position of Rogers and so many other Republicans, both here in Michigan and in the rest of the country as well.
asserted
That → explain → country
They can’t separate themselves from Trump without antagonizing him and his most rabid supporters.
asserted
They → separate → him
But if they don’t make a clean break from Trump, they are stuck leaving the impression that they support his policies or, maybe even worse, that they are afraid to confront him when they don’t.
asserted
they → make → him
Here in Michigan, Rogers’s solution has been to make the debate about El-Sayed—and then, to make El-Sayed seem as scary as possible—in hopes voters will forget about everything Trump has done to the state.
asserted
Trump → make → state
The strategy has been obvious from the get-go, when Rogers and his allies started airing attack ads painting El-Sayed as extreme literally hours after he won the bitterly contested Democratic nomination in early August.
asserted
he → start → August
But it may never have been more obvious than it was on Thursday night, when the two candidates met in a televised debate.
uncertain
candidates → meet → debate
Upgrade Today at 30% OFF & Join Our Member-Only Livestream with Pete Buttigieg
The midterms are coming.
asserted
midterms → upgrade → Buttigieg
Get the reporting, analysis, and conversations you won’t get anywhere else.
asserted
you → get → reporting
📺 Hear what others don’t: access member-only shows including our October 18 livestream featuring Pete Buttigieg with Sarah, Tim, and JVL—live from Charlotte
THURSDAY’S DEBATE WAS ACTUALLY supposed to be the second faceoff between Rogers and El-Sayed.
asserted
DEBATE → hear → Rogers
The first was scheduled to take place in September.
asserted
first → schedule → September
Rogers refused to participate, saying that the host—a well-respected local anchor for the Detroit Fox affiliate named Roop Raj—was biased.
asserted
host → refuse → affiliate
El-Sayed showed up anyway and answered questions, standing opposite an empty chair.
asserted
Sayed → show → chair
It was emblematic of how this campaign has gone.
asserted
campaign → go → ?
I’ve been attending El-Sayed events ever since he declared his candidacy early last year.
asserted
he → attend → candidacy
He holds several a week and generally takes reporters’ questions afterwards, including from outlets he knows will be hostile.
asserted
he → hold → outlets
During those sessions he holds forth confidently on an array of topics, from industrial policy to childcare.
asserted
he → hold → childcare
This week, while discussing artificial intelligence, he talked about China’s progress—and how its development is “drafting” on America’s—in a nuanced way that suggests he’s been reading up on the topic (or at least listening to some good podcasts).
uncertain
he → discuss → podcasts
El-Sayed can get ornery: When he thinks a question is dumb or redundant, he’ll turn it around on the reporter and interrogate them.
asserted
he → get → them
But mostly he mixes it up enthusiastically, as he did recently in two marquee appearances on Fox News—one of which left host Martha MacCallum fumbling for facts, and the other of which left Jesse Watters with what his Fox colleagues likened to a man crush.
asserted
colleagues → mix → crush
Even Trump noticed, according to Axios, and complained to Fox brass that they were not giving El-Sayed a hard enough time.
uncertain
they → notice → time
…and 74 more, not listed.
The Aporia
