This story was originally published by The Guardian and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration.
asserted
story → publish → collaboration
When officials in Wyoming conducted a routine test on the water that was being discharged from a massive under-construction Meta data center, it was a shock to find it contained a rare and potentially hazardous bacterium.
asserted
it → conduct → bacterium
While the wastewater flushed into sewers in Cheyenne, Wyoming, was never destined for the public drinking supply, the presence of Cupriavidus gilardii bacterium in 801,000 gallons of water ejected by a contractor for the data center earlier this year was still unnerving.
asserted
presence → flush → center
Concerned that residents could be exposed to the bacteria if they inhaled evaporating droplets of the water used for irrigation, Cheyenne officials took until July before deciding to stop taking wastewater from Meta’s contractor, Goat Systems—a decision that is now being appealed.
uncertain
that → expose → contractor
“It was a big surprise,” said Frank Strong, water resources manager at the city’s board of public utilities, about the discovery.
asserted
Strong → say → discovery
“Out of a sense of caution we’ve shut it down until we can find out more information.”
asserted
we → shut → information
Meta, which is behind the $800 million, 960-acre artificial intelligence (AI) data center campus, said independent testing by its contractor found no evidence of the bacterium and questioned the validity of the city’s own tests.
asserted
testing → say → tests
“Meta is committed to being a good neighbor in Cheyenne, which includes helping protect local water resources,” said a company spokesman
asserted
spokesman → commit → resources
“We appreciate the board of public utilities’ detailed release of information, which confirms the board found no impact to the public or environment.
asserted
board → appreciate → public
However, the bacteria-laden water in Wyoming is just the latest in a series of alarms raised across the US about data centers and water—not just how much of it they are sucking up, but also what’s in the water when it is funneled back into rivers, streams, and public water systems.
asserted
it → lade → rivers
In Virginia, authorities have brought enforcement actions against several data centers for wastewater and wetland permit violations; in West Virginia stormwater runoff from an incomplete datacenter has twice flooded surrounding houses; all while locals and activists have campaigned against the discharge of heated water from an upcoming data center into Lake Seneca, in New York.
asserted
locals → bring → York
The Waterkeeper Alliance, a network of environmental organizations, said 55 of its affiliated groups across the US were working on data center-related issues, with 80 percent of these campaigns centered on concerns that pollutants may be leaching into the environment via discharged water.
uncertain
pollutants → say → water
Some of this backlash is now set to play out in the courts.
asserted
Some → set → courts
In Georgia, Flint Riverkeeper has said it will sue the QTS datacenter in Fayetteville for allegedly ejecting “massive amounts of dirt [and] massive concentrations of metals” into the Flint River over the past two years.
uncertain
it → say → years
“Data centers are a critical concern for Waterkeeper groups around the globe, in part due to their wastewater concerns,” said a Waterkeeper Alliance spokeswoman.
asserted
spokeswoman → say → concerns
“Data centers have been documented as sources of a wide range of toxic pollutants, including PFAS, heavy metals and antibiotic-resistant bacteria.”
asserted
centers → document → PFAS
Data centers require large amounts of water for their construction and operation, including for cooling the power-hungry computers at their heart, although the industry points out its water use is a fraction of that of other thirsty sectors, such as agriculture.
asserted
use → require → agriculture
A mid-sized data center can consume about 300,000 gallons of water a day.
asserted
center → consume → water
After water is used for cooling or, such as at the Meta facility in Cheyenne, for cleaning debris from pipes in “fill and flush” operations, liquid is ejected back for reuse under terms set by pretreatment permits issued by counties or local wastewater utilities.
asserted
liquid → use → counties
This water, released to prevent buildup of minerals and scaling in pipes, can contain heavy metals or PFAS, the “forever chemicals” that are linked to an array of health problems when ingested.
asserted
that → release → problems
These PFAS can be found in the “closed loop” cooling systems that the data center industry lauds for using less water.
asserted
industry → find → water
When used as a coolant, water can come back out hotter than when it was taken, which has alarmed critics of a controversial gas-fired facility that is pivoting from powering crypto mining to AI and draws water from Lake Seneca.
asserted
that → use → Seneca
The water, opponents point out, can be discharged at a temperature of 108 F into the lake.
asserted
opponents → point → lake
“It’s going into a trout stream, where trout are stressed at temperatures of 70 F or higher, and that hot water is also a contributing factor to harmful algal blooms, which is a toxin to both humans and animals,” said Yvonne Taylor, vice-president of Seneca Lake Guardian and president of the National Coalition Against Cryptomining.
asserted
Taylor → go → Cryptomining
“If there are algal blooms,” she said, “people can’t even run their water, because once this stuff gets into their systems it’s very difficult to remove.
asserted
it → be → systems
So you can’t even shower, or you don’t even want to flush your toilet.
asserted
you → shower → toilet
You definitely don’t want to give your pets water from this.”
asserted
You → want → this
Vulcan Infrastructure and Power, which is behind the revamped facility, has previously stressed it has complied with all relevant environmental laws.
asserted
it → revamp → laws
The company was approached for further comment.
asserted
company → approach → comment
New York has issued a temporary moratorium on huge, hyperscale data centers and Taylor claimed there was swelling support across the US for a national pause.
asserted
Taylor → issue → pause
“These facilities are spreading across the country like a cancer,” she said.
asserted
she → spread → cancer
“AI data centers are very, very good at greenwashing and trying to paint a picture that sounds like everything is going to be nothing but unicorns and rainbows, when in fact what we’re finding out is just the opposite.
asserted
finding → greenwashe → what
Finding out what is in wastewater from industrial facilities can be challenging, however.
asserted
what → find → facilities
An environmental group has sued the city of Racine, Wisconsin, to force more details on the water use of a $3.3 billion Microsoft data center while the city of The Dalles in Oregon sued its local newspaper, the Oregonian, in 2021 to block the public release of water data related to a Google data center before subsequently dropping the case.
asserted
city → sue → case
“We need to know what is in this wastewater but there is a void of information,” said Chris Manganiello, water policy director at Chattahoochee Riverkeeper in Georgia, where a rash of new datacenters are set to draw water from the Chattahoochee.
asserted
rash → need → Chattahoochee
“I would like there to not be more PFAS going into the river but there is this level of anxiety because we don’t know what’s there.”
asserted
what → like → anxiety
Alarm about wastewater is part of a broader backlash against data centers that has rattled some Republicans, even those previously enthusiastic about building AI infrastructure, who have scrambled to recast them as a political liability and vow some scrutiny of their development.
asserted
who → rattle → development
In Wyoming, Harriet Hageman, a Republican congresswoman and devoted ally of Donald Trump, wrote to Mark Zuckerberg, Meta’s chief executive, to demand answers to the bacterial contamination.
asserted
Hageman → write → contamination
“Water is a precious resource in our state, so it is of immense concern to learn the system marketed to reduce a data center’s water consumption caused this contamination,” Hageman said.
asserted
Hageman → learn → contamination
Trump himself, however, has been unmoved by the sharp public turn against AI data centers, calling them a “golden goose” that creates jobs and wealth.
asserted
that → call → jobs
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
