A few weeks back, in a former bank building that's now a music venue in Falmouth, Cornwall, I was DJ-ing at a night I run called Rave Machine.
asserted
I → e → night
All of the elements - the crowd, performers, staff, music, the journey home - connected to create something special, a one-off.
asserted
All → connect → something
Something, in theory, well out of reach of what technology could possibly offer.
uncertain
technology → offer → what
In the DJ world, though, technology has already changed the equation.
asserted
technology → change → equation
In the 1990s, a DJ had to not only pick the tracks, but also thread them together armed only with vinyl records, a pair of turntables and a mixer.
asserted
DJ → have → turntables
Now, much more assistance is on offer, including software that will sync beats on different tracks should you ask it to (I don't).
asserted
I → include → it
Apple Music and Spotify have an AI tune-mixing option too.
asserted
Music → have → option
If you were out dancing, would it matter to you if a DJ was, well, not really DJing?
asserted
DJ → dance → you
If you loved the music being played, would you care if technology was doing the work?
asserted
technology → love → work
It's a question that generative AI - the type of AI that creates content - is asking of us all.
asserted
that → create → us
One of the thrills of that night in Falmouth was seeing our special guest, Andy Cato from Groove Armada, artfully weaving an array of tracks.
asserted
guest → see → tracks
How would I feel if a DJ was just pressing play?
asserted
DJ → feel → play
(And that does happen).
asserted
that → happen → ?
I mention all of this because that experience in Falmouth connects to a far broader question: whether we actually care if a piece of art has been created by a human, be that a painting, song, book, poem, or any other type of art.
asserted
that → mention → art
The music platform Deezer says 44% of tracks uploaded to it are AI-generated.
asserted
% → say → it
Its research also found that 97% of listeners couldn't tell what was AI-generated and what wasn't.
asserted
what → find → listeners
But here's a third statistic: more than half of those surveyed said they did care if it was made by AI.
asserted
it → survey → AI
They want humans to be involved.
asserted
humans → want → ?
Daniel Susskind, an economics professor at King's College London, says many of us place huge value on the human role in making art.
asserted
many → say → art
It's what makes the creative process different from more functional, practical tasks, he thinks.
asserted
he → make → tasks
"I was once in a room of accountants, and one of them stood up and said, 'My clients come to me for the personal touch, the human process'," he remembers.
asserted
he → stand → touch
"And I said, 'That isn't why they come to you, they come because they want their taxes done properly'.
asserted
taxes → say → you
But it's different with art, he says.
asserted
he → say → art
"If I walk into the Sistine Chapel and look at the ceiling, I think not only is that extraordinarily beautiful, but isn't it amazing that a human hand, flesh and blood like my own, came up with that.
asserted
hand → walk → that
A mind like mine dreamt that up," he says.
asserted
he → dream → that
As Susskind describes it, what we value isn't just the destination, it's the knowledge that a human - one of us - got us there.
asserted
human → describe → us
We can wonder at that achievement.
asserted
We → wonder → achievement
Of course, it could be argued that computers and AI software were themselves created by humans.
uncertain
computers → argue → humans
If Susskind feels awe walking into the Sistine Chapel, others might experience awe of a different type using a chatbot like ChatGPT.
uncertain
others → feel → ChatGPT
Susskind points to another example, this time a chess match in 1997, when a world champion, Garry Kasparov, lost for the first time to a computer, Deep Blue.
asserted
champion → point → computer
At the time, there were fears the computer's success would mean our interest in chess would wane.
asserted
interest → be → chess
In fact, chess is more popular than ever, played by millions.
asserted
chess → play → millions
"It wasn't simply the moves on the board that people care about.
asserted
people → care → that
It's the fact that it's a human being sitting behind them, moving those pieces along that matters," Susskind argues.
asserted
Susskind → sit → pieces
And some think that the advent of AI has actually placed extra value on things created by people.
asserted
advent → think → people
You might call that a human premium.
uncertain
You → call → that
Human touch
Kyle Chayka, a journalist at The New Yorker focused on technology, says AI writing is now widely considered to be "generic, obsequious and banal".
asserted
writing → focus → technology
As a result, he says, "I think readers are coming to value very obviously personal writing, and maybe even writing that's messier, less structurally sound or composed or perfected, than they maybe once would've desired."
asserted
they → say → writing
Chayka goes on: "I think illustration and graphic design is going in the same direction, where the average is too easily accessible, and so designers are leaning into being weirder and more eye-catching and more unusual, trying to find things that AI can't generate so easily."
asserted
AI → go → that
In response to the surge in AI-created content, academics are racing to develop a universally recognised symbol to denote something that is "human made" (similar to the "Fairtrade" label that emerged in the 1980s).
asserted
that → create → 1980s
…and 54 more, not listed.
The Aporia
