Reason
· collected 2026-09-08 · by C.J. Ciaramella
analysis
- Book One: Proto-Prisons and the Jacksonian Era (1790–1870)
- Book Two: The Progressive Era and Decline (1870–1955)
- Book Three: The South (1870–1970)
- Book Four: Resistance and Mass Incarceration (1971–2009)
- Book Five: Criminal Justice Reform (2009–The Present)
Last December, on a bitterly cold afternoon, I stood inside the walled yard of Philadelphia's Eastern State Penitentiary while I waited for a museum docent to start a tour.
asserted
docent → stand → tour
I stamped my feet and blew on my hands to keep warm, much like I imagined tourists and incarcerated men did there two centuries ago.
asserted
tourists → stamp → hands
Eastern State Penitentiary is one of the places where the American prison experiment began, and where one of its most bizarre iterations was tested on human beings.
asserted
one → begin → beings
After it opened in 1829, Eastern State was, as it is now, a tourist attraction.
asserted
it → open → 1829
In 1858, more than 10,000 visitors paid entry fees to gawk at the building and the men confined inside it.
asserted
visitors → pay → it
The walls are what everyone sees first when they come to Eastern State.
asserted
they → see → State
The prison, located on a rise in what is now Philadelphia's Fairmount neighborhood, is skirted by imposing 30-foot-high granite walls, crenelated turrets, and a medieval gatehouse.
asserted
what → locate → walls
It was designed to intimidate, and it has always done its job.
asserted
it → design → job
When the Marquis de Lafayette, a hero of the American and French revolutions, passed through Philadelphia on an 1824 tour of all 24 U.S. states, city leaders showed him the facade of Eastern State, then still under construction.
asserted
leaders → pass → construction
According to all accounts, Lafayette recoiled at the sight.
uncertain
Lafayette → accord → sight
Thomas B. McElwee wrote in an 1835 history of the prison that the "form of the edifice was disapproved by LaFayette, in the memorable expression which he uttered as he crossed its threshold for the first time, 'What! Have you Bastilles in this country?'"
asserted
he → write → country
Eastern State cost $780,000 to construct, making it one of the most expensive buildings in the country when it opened and one of the most expensive in the world.
asserted
it → cost → world
The paradox of the place was that this fearsome fortress represented the liberal ideals of the young American republic and an investment in building a more humane justice system.
asserted
fortress → represent → system
"Prisons were really supposed to be these republican machines," says Ashley T. Rubin, an associate professor at the University of Hawaii at Mānoa and author of The Deviant Prison, a history of Eastern State Penitentiary.
asserted
Rubin → suppose → Penitentiary
"Crime was one of the main ways that you could basically corrupt the nation, because virtue was essential to what it meant to be a good republican, and criminals are by definition not virtuous, so we had to make them into virtuous citizens.
uncertain
we → corrupt → citizens
"
What drew visiting dignitaries, Enlightenment intellectuals, and everyday lookie-loos to Eastern State after it opened—and what still draws tourists today—was the unprecedented experiment to produce virtuous citizens behind its walls.
asserted
what → draw → walls
It's an experiment that continues, in fits and starts, today.
asserted
that → continue → fits
Last year President Donald Trump announced to the surprise of everyone that Alcatraz prison would be reopened.
asserted
prison → announce → everyone
"The reopening of ALCATRAZ will serve as a symbol of Law, Order, and JUSTICE," the president posted on social media.
asserted
president → serve → media
The news was unexpected, not just because the island prison is currently under National Park Service management and has been rusting to pieces in the salt air of San Francisco Bay for decades, but because the federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) has been in a yearslong decline and can barely staff its existing prisons.
asserted
Bureau → rust → prisons
The BOP has almost 6,000 fewer staff than its target number, and many of its facilities are, if not as decrepit as Alcatraz, in need of serious repairs.
asserted
many → have → repairs
Nevertheless, the White House requested $152 million from Congress this April to reopen Alcatraz.
asserted
House → request → Alcatraz
Whether or not it ever reopens, the efforts are notable because Trump is claiming a national ideology of punishment, symbolized by the notoriously harsh prison.
asserted
Trump → reopen → prison
"When we were a more serious Nation, in times past," Trump wrote, "we did not hesitate to lock up the most dangerous criminals, and keep them far away from anyone they could harm."
uncertain
they → write → anyone
Trump was espousing a particular theory of prisons, one that emphasized pain and punishment.
asserted
that → espouse → pain
It also happens to be wrong.
asserted
It → happen → ?
The modern prison is widely considered an American invention, one born out of a peculiar American mix of Christian theology and Enlightenment confidence.
asserted
prison → consider → theology
Much as the Founding Fathers sought to constrain the passions of majorities and lawmakers through checks and balances, prison advocates in the early republic wanted to use architecture and discipline to mold convicts into productive citizens while avoiding the sadism and spectacle that typified criminal justice in Europe.
asserted
that → seek → Europe
Despite those best intentions, our prisons have been the sites of unremitting horrors for 250 years and counting.
asserted
prisons → count → years
Administrative whippings and outright torture—such as electrocuting inmates with jerry-rigged crank telephones—persisted until the end of the 1960s.
asserted
whippings → electrocute → 1960s
After judges and state oversight boards got too nosy, the punishments moved off the books.
asserted
punishments → get → books
The Justice Department sued the state of Alabama in 2020 over its failure to protect incarcerated people from rampant violence and sexual assault.
asserted
Department → sue → violence
Despite that, shocking levels of corruption and death have persisted, verging into the macabre.
asserted
levels → persist → macabre
In 2024, multiple families of deceased inmates filed lawsuits alleging that the University of Alabama at Birmingham had, without consent, retained their loved ones' organs after autopsies for student research.
asserted
University → file → research
In 2022, a federal judge ruled that Arizona prison officials were deliberately indifferent to appalling and sometimes fatal medical neglect, including a case where a woman's multiple sclerosis was left untreated until she was nearly completely paralyzed by age 36.
asserted
she → rule → age
"No legitimate humane system would operate in this manner," Judge Roslyn O. Silver of the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona concluded.
asserted
Silver → operate → Arizona
Yet this is the system that prevails in much of the United States.
asserted
that → prevail → States
It has endured since the country's founding, despite reliable 40- to 50-year cycles of reform.
asserted
It → endure → reform
The prison is a problem our republic has never solved in any of its various modes: the Jacksonian Era, the Progressive Era, the wave of prison building in the 1980s that launched the age of mass incarceration, or the attempts over the last decade to roll back mass incarceration's excesses.
asserted
that → solve → excesses
After 250 years of the American prison experiment, we need to ask why we've never been able to maintain prison systems compatible with our Constitution or our national ideals.
asserted
we → need → Constitution
…and 545 more, not listed.
