Kim Herrick, an occasional substitute teacher and parent, is sounding the alarm about excessive screen time in schools, citing instances of students using non-educational apps during class. According to Herrick, many parents are pushing back against the use of technology in education, arguing that it's unnecessary for learning. The issue has sparked a "techlash" among parents, educators, and advocacy groups, with some countries like Sweden and Norway making efforts to reduce tech usage in schools by introducing physical textbooks and screen-free classrooms. Some experts, however, suggest that a thoughtful and intentional approach to technology use is the way forward, rather than a complete rollback to past practices.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-08,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Parents are pushing back on classroom screen time in a 'techlash' over too much technology in schools
'We do not need a Google account to learn,' says parent and educator
asserted
parent → push → account
As an occasional substitute teacher for middle- and high-schoolers in Nova Scotia, Kim Herrick often gets a front-row seat seeing how teens use tech at school.
asserted
teens → get → school
Whether students are tasked with assignments, work for another class or granted free time, Herrick regularly sees them checking Snapchat, TikTok or Instagram accounts, shopping online, gaming or even trading Bitcoin — easily bypassing school board security methods aimed at blocking such use.
asserted
them → task → use
The ubiquity of students engaging in non-educational online activities — and the futile attempts to clamp down on it — have contributed to her view that we need to reconsider the tech used by default in classes today.
But the alarm bells really started going off for Herrick when she discovered her elder daughter — who's starting Grade 2 this fall — has had a school Google account for three years, without Herrick knowing.
asserted
Herrick → engage → years
Herrick said she couldn't log into the account and school officials said she couldn't opt-out or have it deleted, saying it was necessary for access to educational apps and "a requirement" for learning.
asserted
it → say → learning
We have hundreds of years of going to school as humans, Herrick said.
asserted
Herrick → have → humans
"We do not need a Google account to learn."
asserted
We → need → account
Many parents, educators, advocacy groups and experts are pushing back against the amount of screen time in schools and the prevalence of tech tools woven into the current education system, with some making links to a range of woes, from behavioural issues to distracted students to data breaches that put youngsters' privacy at risk.
asserted
that → push → risk
Yet a rollback to classroom practices of the past isn't the answer to the current "techlash," say some education experts, who favour intentional and thoughtful use of technology as the way forward.
asserted
who → say → way
For years, a one-to-one student-to-device ratio, web access and learning through game-like applications have been seen as symbols of educational progress.
asserted
ratio → learn → progress
But amid a worldwide push to reduce teen smartphone and social media use, a vocal wave of parent groups — including Skills Before Screens in Canada, the U.K.-based Close Screen Open Minds, as well as Schools Beyond Screens and ScreenSense in the U.S. — is broadening this scrutiny to encompass educational tech usage more generally.
asserted
wave → reduce → usage
After having prioritized digital schooling for the past decade, for instance, Sweden has recently shifted back toward physical textbooks, pen-and-paper homework, reinvesting in libraries and screen-free classrooms (particularly for younger students), citing falling scores on international assessments.
Poor reading scores have tech-friendly Norway making a similar return to physical books in its schools, as well as introducing a near-ban on Generative AI usage in elementary, with restrictions for high-schoolers.
asserted
Norway → prioritize → schoolers
In the U.S., parental demands have led to stricter tech policies at the country's two largest school boards.
asserted
demands → lead → boards
The Los Angeles Unified School District has already started the school year with limits on screen time in every grade, including a total device ban before Grade 2.
asserted
District → start → Grade
On the opposite coast, New York is restricting one-to-one device time for Grade 2 and below and suggesting caps for older elementary students.
asserted
York → restrict → students
It's also halting student-facing Generative AI use through Grade 8 and limiting use for high schoolers, for now.
asserted
It → halt → schoolers
Herrick says many parents, such as herself, are in the dark about the screens and apps their youngsters access in class, let alone what the responsible use or data privacy agreements are regarding those apps and school accounts.
asserted
agreements → say → apps
Beyond privacy, the mother of two and former wilderness leadership educator in the U.S. is also concerned about what unfettered school tech use means for the long term.
asserted
use → mean → term
She worries about susceptibility to distraction — she's had secondary students claim they're multitasking as they juggle a bevy of browser tabs, apps or screens — not to mention negative impacts on their mental and physical health down the road.
uncertain
they → worry → road
In the meantime, overreliance on tech also bogs down educators' precious time with policing student usage and dealing with tech support, rather than teaching, Herrick said.
asserted
Herrick → bog → support
Intention versus novelty
Classroom tech use varies across Canadian regions, schools and educators, but it's indeed integrated into teaching today, according to Johanathan Woodworth, an assistant professor at Mount Saint Vincent University in Halifax.
uncertain
it → vary → Halifax
Whether teachers are getting students to research a project online, study the solar system via a virtual reality simulator or test out an AI chatbot, Woodworth emphasizes that tech use must be intentional, thoughtful and directly connected to the skills students are expected to learn.
asserted
students → get → skills
"A lot of times teachers use technology in the classroom because of the novelty effect and engagement — but the novelty effect wears off," Woodworth said from Halifax, where he teaches educational technology to existing and prospective teachers.
"
asserted
he → use → teachers
The first step is to think about 'Do I even need to use it?
asserted
I → think → it
What is the purpose of me using it?
asserted
me → use → it
Does it actually help me in my classroom?'
asserted
it → help → classroom
"
It's important teachers are supported with guidelines and enough training on how to carefully and effectively use technology, he says, in order to understand it and, in turn, teach and model that knowledge to their students.
asserted
he → support → students
Striving for balance
Rolling back to no-tech classrooms isn't necessarily the answer either, Woodworth said, since a main reason schools employ tech today — text-to-speech and speech-to-text applications, for instance — is to accommodate students with disabilities.
asserted
schools → strive → disabilities
Schools must balance "purposeful" tech use with the need to prep students for a tech-filled world, while also ensuring it's "not used as a distraction," according to education consultant Tom D'Amico, former director of education of the Ottawa Catholic School Board.
uncertain
it → balance → Board
He says the concerns raised by parents — both the ones driving the current "techlash" and those pushing for their kids to build tech skills — are contributing to a "balanced and focused" approach by school boards.
asserted
kids → say → boards
In his current work advising school districts across Canada about artificial intelligence, D'Amico says he's noticing a shift: schools taking a more developmentally and age-informed approach to technology.
asserted
schools → advise → technology
For instance, "that means regardless of the province, you're looking at the earliest grades not having a lot of device time, but still getting AI literacy.
asserted
you → mean → literacy
They still need to learn about digital citizenship, what it means to use a computer," he said, noting gradual introduction of more technology in middle and high school.
asserted
he → need → school
As more teens turn to AI for emotional support, experts say it's no substitute for human connection
What's the secret to perfect marks?
asserted
secret → turn → marks
Family, community, discipline and time management, top scholars say
"Critical thinking can be [taught] without the technology as well in the early ages," D'Amico added, emphasizing that this learning must be "embedded in the curriculum, so it happens every single year, in an age-appropriate manner.
asserted
it → say → manner
"
Ultimately, he says, the top focus of schools should be student learning and strengthening students' connections with teachers and their classmates.
asserted
student → say → teachers
It's the student and their brain," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
