A decade ago, nonprofit leaders in Arizona’s most populous county boasted that they had created the Amazon of homeless service systems.
asserted
they → boast → systems
Families in crisis would no longer have to contact a dozen agencies in search of shelter or housing.
asserted
Families → have → shelter
A single system could point them to help.
uncertain
system → point → help
But for all the hype, this system has become a dead end for many families.
asserted
system → become → families
A 2023 evaluation found 94% of people who were assessed for housing help by the system didn’t receive it.
asserted
who → find → it
And that didn’t account for parents who were unable to connect with a worker to see if they qualified for assistance.
asserted
they → account → assistance
Families say it hasn’t improved.
asserted
it → say → ?
In interviews, 30 families that are homeless told ProPublica that calling the hotline, meeting with outreach workers or showing up at shelters rarely results in offers of help.
asserted
calling → tell → help
Some families said they called 211 multiple times without being connected to the homeless response system for families, known as the Family Housing Hub.
asserted
they → say → Hub
Others, who said they were sleeping in cars or outdoors, said they couldn’t get a spot on the waitlist for shelter.
asserted
they → say → shelter
The system has returned to what it was a decade ago, with families calling as many shelters as they can, repeating the very situation the hub was intended to fix.
asserted
hub → return → situation
Those who did make it onto the hub’s waitlist said they were left guessing how long it would take to get help.
asserted
it → make → help
Some said operators told them to sleep in their cars.
asserted
operators → say → cars
Vanessa Lopez said she experienced this frustration after leaving a hostile relationship in the spring.
asserted
she → say → spring
While she and her two children stayed with a friend, Lopez said she repeatedly contacted 211, which functions as a referral service for the hub, hoping it would lead to shelter for her family.
asserted
it → stay → family
Her friend eventually asked them to leave.
asserted
friend → ask → them
Overwhelmed by the stress of not knowing where to take her family, Lopez took a leave from her job.
asserted
Lopez → overwhelm → job
By then, she said, she’d called 211 at least five times.
asserted
she → say → 211
Yet no matter how dire her situation became, it still took months to get on the waitlist for shelter.
asserted
it → become → shelter
During one call she said she broke down in tears, frustrated that others seemed to get help but she could not.
uncertain
she → say → help
She wondered if she needed to be addicted to drugs to receive assistance.
asserted
she → wonder → assistance
“It’s not me telling you no,” she said the operator told her.
asserted
operator → tell → her
“It’s the system.”
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Monique Lopez, the CEO of United Methodist Outreach Ministries, known as UMOM, which runs the Family Housing Hub and the shelter waitlist, acknowledged the frustrations of people like Vanessa Lopez (no relation).
asserted
which → know → Lopez
But before UMOM offers callers shelter or a spot on the waitlist, the organization first tries to help them find other options.
asserted
them → offer → options
“We don’t start the conversation with, ‘Hey, do you want to get on the shelter waitlist?’” Monique Lopez said.
asserted
Lopez → start → waitlist
“It really is ‘Let’s try to figure your situation out first.’”
asserted
’s → let → situation
Lopez attributed some frustrations to the number of organizations offering assistance through the hub.
asserted
Lopez → attribute → hub
Each shelter has its own rules, and some families may not meet the requirements of every program.
uncertain
families → have → program
To address the confusion, UMOM updated its website to provide more information about the homeless response system for families, she said.
asserted
she → address → families
The federally funded system, known as Coordinated Entry, mandates that providers use an assessment to prioritize scarce housing.
asserted
providers → fund → housing
But families told ProPublica that the process in Maricopa County often leaves them confused and hopeless.
asserted
process → tell → them
Family homelessness in the county has risen to its highest level in more than a decade, while every shelter is full and housing vouchers are scarce.
asserted
vouchers → rise → decade
Monique Lopez acknowledged that family shelters are full, leaving few good options.
asserted
shelters → acknowledge → options
“People are living in unsafe and unstable situations while waiting just to get into emergency shelter,” she said.
asserted
she → live → shelter
The process, experts said, shouldn’t leave people wondering if there is help and what it takes to get it.
asserted
it → say → it
“You have to have some kind of method for setting priorities when there aren’t enough resources to go around,” said Marybeth Shinn, an expert on family homelessness at Vanderbilt University.
asserted
Shinn → have → University
People should know if they’re on a waitlist.”
asserted
they → know → waitlist
UMOM and other Maricopa County nonprofits launched the Family Housing Hub in 2014, after years of planning and strategizing over how to end family homelessness in the county that is home to Phoenix.
asserted
that → launch → Phoenix
As they envisioned it, families would meet with a worker at UMOM who could match them with the best solution for their situation.
uncertain
who → envision → situation
…and 82 more, not listed.
The Aporia
