This article was originally published on September 20, 2025.
asserted
article → publish → September
Last week, the United Nations Independent Inquiry Commission on the Occupied Palestinian Territory announced its findings that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, making it the first UN-affiliated body to do so.
asserted
it → announce → Gaza
Leading the charges against Israel is Navi Pillay, the Commission’s chairwoman and an international jurist of repute with several roles under her belt.
asserted
Pillay → lead → belt
Navanethem ‘Navi’ Pillay was born in 1941 in apartheid-era South Africa to Indian parents of Tamil descent.
asserted
Pillay → bear → descent
She received her BA and LLB degrees from the University of Natal.
asserted
She → receive → Natal
In later years, she also earned a Master of Law and a doctorate from Harvard University.
asserted
she → earn → University
In 1967, Ms. Pillay became the first woman to start a law practice in Natal, her home province.
asserted
Pillay → become → Natal
Her early years saw her defending anti-apartheid activists and advocating for prisoners’ rights.
asserted
her → see → rights
She helped establish rights, including access to legal representation and basic amenities, for prisoners on Robben Island in 1973.
asserted
She → establish → 1973
The first democratic government in South Africa was set up under Nelson Mandela post the end of apartheid in 1994.
asserted
government → set → 1994
Ms. Pillay was appointed Acting Judge of the High Court of South Africa in 1995, becoming the first non-White woman in this role.
asserted
Pillay → appoint → role
The same year, she was also elected as a judge on the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, serving for eight years, with four of them as president (1999-2003).
asserted
she → elect → president
During her time on the Tribunal, Ms. Pillay contributed to jurisprudence on propaganda, free speech and crimes of sexual violence in conflict, including rape as part of genocide.
asserted
Pillay → contribute → genocide
“The judicial panel over which I presided convicted three Rwandans of genocide.
asserted
I → preside → genocide
So I understand the word “genocide,” and it is not one I use lightly,” Ms. Pillay wrote in an opinion piece for The New York Times on September 16, 2025.
asserted
Pillay → understand → September
In 2003, Ms. Pillay was appointed as a judge on the International Criminal Court in the Hague, where she served until August 2008.
asserted
she → appoint → August
Following this, she became the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and served a six-year term, till 2014.
asserted
she → follow → 2014
Along with extensive writing and practice in international criminal law and human rights law, Ms. Pillay has worked for the rights of women and children, detainees, and victims of torture and domestic violence.
asserted
Pillay → work → torture
As a member of the Women’s National Coalition, she contributed to the cause of gender equality in South Africa, pushing for the inclusion of the clause prohibiting discrimination on the grounds of race, religious, sex or sexual orientation in the country’s constitution.
asserted
she → contribute → constitution
She also co-founded Equality Now, which works to advance women’s legal rights.
asserted
which → co → rights
Earlier this year, Ms. Pillay received the 2025 Sydney Peace Prize for “a lifetime of advocating for accountability and responsibility in the face of crimes against humanity.”
asserted
Pillay → receive → humanity
She heads the three-member Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, which was established by the UN Human Rights Council in 2021, with panelists appointed by the 47 member states.
asserted
which → head → states
The other members are Miloon Kothari, an Indian expert in land rights and housing who served as the first UN Special Rapporteur on adequate housing and Chris Sidoti, an Australian international human rights lawyer who has held multiple roles in the UN, including as founder and expert member of the Special Advisory Council for Myanmar.
asserted
who → serve → Myanmar
All three members will end their term later this year, having submitted their resignations in July.
asserted
members → end → July
Ms. Pillay, 83, cited her “age, medical issues and the weight of several other commitments,” as her reasons for stepping down.
asserted
Pillay → cite → reasons
The Commission’s latest report, “the strongest and most authoritative UN finding to date,” finds reasonable grounds to conclude that four of five acts constituting genocide, as defined under the 1948 Genocide Convention, are being carried out against a national, ethnic, racial or religious group (here, by the state of Israel against Palestinians in Gaza) since the start of the war in 2023.
asserted
acts → find → 2023
The four acts are: killing members of a group, causing serious bodily and mental harm to them, deliberately inflicting conditions calculated to physically destroy the group, and imposing measures intended to prevent births.
asserted
acts → kill → births
The report concluded genocidal intent from statements by Israeli leaders such as President Isaac Herzog, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, and the actions of the Israeli Defence Forces.
asserted
report → conclude → Forces
More than 64,000 people have been killed and thousands injured in Gaza since the start of the war, which followed a Hamas-led attack in Israel on October 7, 2023 that killed around 1200 people, and saw 251 taken hostage.
asserted
251 → kill → hostage
“The international community cannot stay silent on the genocidal campaign launched by Israel against the Palestinian people in Gaza,” Ms. Pillay said at a press conference in Geneva announcing the launch of the report.
asserted
Pillay → stay → report
“When clear signs and evidence of genocide emerge, the absence of action to stop it amounts to complicity.”
asserted
absence → emerge → complicity
Israel has denounced the report as distorted and false, with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs alleging in a post on X that the report’s authors were serving as Hamas proxies.
asserted
authors → denounce → proxies
Israel has characterised its actions as prompted by self-defence, and maintains that they are consistent with international law.
asserted
they → characterise → law
Its foreign ministry has demanded that the Commission should be abolished after its members step down from their roles later this year.
asserted
members → demand → roles
Notably, the Commission does not speak for the UN, which maintains that a legal determination about whether a situation constitutes genocide under international law can only be made by a competent court.
asserted
situation → speak → court
The ICJ is currently hearing a genocide case against Israel brought by South Africa; any resolution, however, may take years.
uncertain
resolution → hear → years
The Aporia
