On October 8, the UN secretary-general warned about potential abuses of neurotechnologies that could allow governments to access and manipulate citizens' minds, threatening fundamental human rights such as privacy and freedom of thought. The report suggests that without proper regulation, these technologies might be misused in criminal justice systems, leading to issues like arbitrary detentions and mental state alterations. To address these risks, the UN recommends strict regulations and requiring explicit consent for using neurotechnology in legal contexts.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-09,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it -0.50, but all 4 of its quote(s) are attributed speech - words the article quotes from someone, not the article's own narration, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 67373: attributed speech only · logged 2026-10-09
UN warns against technology used to read citizens’ minds
Jonathan Moens
AI generated
asserted
AI → warn → minds
The scenarios sound like science fiction: police officers accessing data contained in suspects’ brains to forcefully extract information, or to predict if offenders might plan to commit future crimes.
uncertain
offenders → sound → crimes
But the secretary-general of the United Nations warned on Oct 8 for the first time that neurotechnologies are advancing so rapidly that governments’ ability to access and manipulate people’s brains could one day pose a threat to fundamental human rights.
uncertain
ability → warn → rights
The abuse of future technologies, Secretary-General Antonio Guterres warned, could lead to arbitrary detentions, the alteration of people’s mental states and infringements on privacy.
uncertain
Guterres → warn → privacy
“Neurotechnology, including new and emerging forms, raises profound human rights challenges when applied to the administration of justice,” the secretary-general wrote.
asserted
general → include → justice
“Its expansion beyond clinical settings into investigative, judicial and correctional contexts introduces significant risks, alongside potential benefits.”
asserted
expansion → introduce → benefits
To address such threats, the report lists a number of recommendations, including establishing regulations consistent with international law, recognising thoughts as “highly sensitive personal data” and requiring explicit consent for the use of neurotechnology in criminal justice settings.
asserted
report → address → settings
Human rights officials said the document was an important step towards raising global awareness of the issue and that it could help countries develop laws to prevent the abuse of such technology.
uncertain
it → say → technology
“This gives states an opportunity to establish clear rules to regulate the use of neurotechnology, based on human rights, before they become routine in investigations, courts and prisons,” said Jeremy Laurence, a spokesperson for the UN Human Rights Office.
asserted
Laurence → give → Office
The report, some rights activists said, broadens the traditional understanding of freedom of thought, which has largely focused on freedom of expression, to include keeping one’s innermost ideas private.
asserted
which → say → ideas
“It’s no longer just about the classical ways through which freedom of thought is evoked,” said Marcello Ienca, a professor of ethics and neuroscience at the Technical University of Munich.
asserted
Ienca → ’ → Munich
The UN’s interest comes amid a growing global push to protect brain data.
asserted
interest → come → data
Chile in 2012 enshrined protections for brain activity in its constitution.
asserted
Chile → enshrine → constitution
And several states, including California, Colorado and Montana, have passed laws protecting neural data.
asserted
states → include → data
Similar measures have been proposed in Argentina, Brazil, Colombia and Mexico.
asserted
measures → propose → Argentina
But while some countries are working to protect citizens’ neural data, others are already attempting to access it.
asserted
others → work → it
In India, the police have for two decades used a technology called Brain Electrical Oscillation Signature – or BEOS – to determine whether a suspect may have been involved in a crime.
uncertain
suspect → use → crime
The scientific basis for this technology, which reads brain waves, is scant.
asserted
which → read → waves
Results from BEOS tests are inadmissible as evidence in Indian courts, but the technology has been applied in hundreds of high-stakes cases, including those of murder, rape and terrorism.
asserted
technology → apply → murder
BEOS has not been validated by the international scientific community.
asserted
BEOS → validate → community
And a committee established by the Indian government to review BEOS concluded in 2008 that it was “sub-optimal”.
asserted
it → establish → 2008
Not all neurotechnologies are being developed as tools of the state.
asserted
neurotechnologies → develop → state
Many have been brought to the consumer market as wearable health and wellness gadgets that can help users monitor their stress, sleep and focus.
asserted
users → bring → stress
But those too, experts warned, are subject to few regulations.
asserted
experts → warn → regulations
The Neurorights Foundation analyzed the privacy policies of 30 consumer neurotechnology companies in 2024 and found that most did not have limits on how they used customers’ brain data.
asserted
they → analyze → data
More than half of those companies, the foundation said, explicitly allowed user data to be shared with third parties.
asserted
data → say → parties
Neurotechnologies have also become powerful clinical tools for patients who have suffered severe brain or spinal cord injuries.
asserted
who → become → injuries
Brain-computer interfaces have helped paralysed patients to write sentences by imagining handwriting, as well as to move robotic limbs and to play chess online just by thinking.
asserted
interfaces → help → chess
The Aporia
