Mark Zuckerberg was just three minutes into his keynote speech at the company's annual Meta Connect product event last month when his tone turned almost wistful.
asserted
tone → turn → event
"Building is an act of love," he said, glancing down at the ground with his hands in his pockets.
asserted
he → say → pockets
"It's how we impart what we believe, and we pour our hearts and our souls into what we make."
asserted
we → impart → what
Speaking to hundreds of analysts and developers, Zuckerberg proceeded to share news about Meta's latest AI products: its new agentic chatbot Muse, a slew of smart glasses, as well as a Tamagotchi-like AI gadget users can attach to their wrists.
asserted
users → speak → wrists
It was a conference focused on new technologies - but still, it's perhaps notable that during a presentation lasting nearly an hour, Zuckerberg did not mention two of his most popular products, Instagram and Facebook, the social media platforms that have helped Meta become a $2tn company.
asserted
Meta → focus → products
For much of the past year, Meta has been embroiled in a series of legal actions, accused of deliberately designing products that are addictive to young users.
asserted
that → embroil → users
That has led to the release of internal emails, corporate documents and whistleblower testimony that personal injury lawyers and prosecutors across the country have wielded to make their case.
asserted
lawyers → lead → case
And Zuckerberg is unpopular: last year, a Pew Research Center poll found that two-thirds of Americans had an unfavourable opinion of him.
asserted
thirds → find → him
His reputation is unlikely to be helped by The Social Reckoning, a film by Aaron Sorkin released this week.
asserted
reputation → help → Sorkin
It's about whistleblower claims that Meta executives were aware of their products harming young people.
uncertain
products → harm → people
Succession actor Jeremy Strong plays Zuckerberg as a "full-on villain", according to a review in the Hollywood Reporter, "stoically arguing that even the slightest gesture of responsibility is anathema where money is concerned".
uncertain
money → play → responsibility
Some speculate that this is Meta's "Big Tobacco" moment, with a consensus forming against the company, and the social media industry as a whole.
asserted
consensus → speculate → whole
But the truth seems to be more complicated.
asserted
truth → seem → ?
Despite months of bad press, in the real world Meta's products are doing better than ever.
asserted
products → do → world
Use of its apps continues to rise, and users are already flocking to its new AI assistant.
asserted
users → continue → assistant
It raises the question: can anything really clip Meta's wings?
asserted
anything → raise → wings
Or is it now something of a 'Teflon' company, with scandals simply bouncing off it?
asserted
scandals → bounce → it
Last summer, Reuters revealed that Meta allowed its chatbots to "engage a child in conversations that are romantic or sensual", and provide false medical information to users.
asserted
that → reveal → users
Meta has revised those policies and said that such responses should never have been allowed.
And this year, bills have been mounting.
asserted
bills → revise → policies
In March, a jury gave $6m (£4.5m) to a 20-year-old California woman who claimed she suffered mental health harms related to her use of Meta's Instagram and Google's YouTube.
asserted
she → give → Instagram
Around the same time, New Mexico became the first state to succeed in a lawsuit against Meta over child safety issues.
asserted
Mexico → become → issues
A jury found the company had failed to warn the public about the dangers its platforms posed to kids.
asserted
platforms → find → kids
Meta was fined a total of $942m.
asserted
Meta → fin → 942
The judge called Meta a "public nuisance" akin to air pollution.
asserted
judge → call → pollution
Meta says it disagrees with the verdicts and is appealing both cases.
asserted
it → say → cases
In May, Meta was among the social companies that avoided a trial by settling a case brought by a Kentucky school district that claimed their product design had led to a youth mental health crisis.
uncertain
design → avoid → crisis
Meta reportedly agreed to pay $9m, the most of any defendant.
uncertain
Meta → agree → defendant
And this summer, Meta struck a high-profile $18bn settlement with 48 US states, plus the District of Columbia and three US territories.
asserted
Meta → strike → Columbia
Meta denied wrongdoing as part of the settlement, and during the five-day trial it maintained that it had worked extensively over the years to make its platforms safer for young users, pouring resources into testing and research.
asserted
platforms → deny → testing
As part of the deal, the firm promised to enact two-hour daily time limits for young users, along with night-time blocks on use, muted notifications during school hours, and other changes.
asserted
firm → promise → hours
The company faces other lawsuits too, including one starting later this month in Los Angeles, also related to alleged social media addiction among young users.
asserted
company → face → users
Meanwhile, several countries have moved to ban social media for children entirely, starting with Australia last December.
asserted
countries → move → Australia
Social media companies are broadly disliked, even while their products remain wildly popular.
asserted
products → dislike → ?
A Reuters/Ipsos survey suggests that 85% of Americans think social media can be addictive for children, and 61% support greater government oversight.
uncertain
% → suggest → oversight
To some, the trust issue feels existential
"Once the public has stopped trusting you, it's kind of a downward spiral," says associate professor Alison Taylor of New York University's Stern School of Business.
asserted
Taylor → feel → Business
"It feels like… the trust deficit is so big, I just don't know that they're going to be able to recover."
asserted
they → feel → ?
'Withstanding the blowback'
But despite those high-profile cases, the company reported that the number of people using some of its apps (like Instagram and WhatsApp) has risen 3% year on year and this year's second quarter revenue was up 28% compared with the same period in 2025.
While it has agreed to temper its pursuit of the teen market (which many brands eagerly cultivate to build their future user base), the company has said that teens accounted for less than 1% of its revenue anyway.
asserted
teens → withstand → revenue
And the company's settlement with the 48 states was widely considered a massive win for Meta, because it prevented some Meta bosses (including Zuckerberg) from having to give testimony, and stopped the release of further internal documents, while allowing the company to avoid admitting wrongdoing.
asserted
company → consider → wrongdoing
The company's stock price surged 4% immediately following the announcement, and is up more than 25% over the last month.
asserted
price → surge → month
One view popular among critics is that the company has tested consumer tolerance for bad behaviour and until now, its business has mostly managed to withstand the blowback.
asserted
business → test → blowback
…and 46 more, not listed.
The Aporia
