Pushing into her third decade as lord mayor, Clover Moore still has plenty of fans in Sydney – although I’m no longer really one of them.
asserted
I → push → them
Moore has been a trailblazer as the city’s first popularly elected female lord mayor, amassing nearly a quarter of a million first-preference votes over six elections.
asserted
Moore → elect → elections
She has helped make Sydney a much better place to live and work, and has been a role model for women in political leadership.
asserted
Sydney → help → leadership
But the 80-year-old has stayed too long, and failed to orchestrate anything resembling a succession plan.
asserted
old → stay → plan
Hubris and complacency have also crept in, gifting her haters something of substance to complain about.
asserted
Hubris → creep → substance
And her continued flirtation with the idea of running for a fresh term in 2028 only serves to highlight how her record-breaking reign has clouded her judgment.
asserted
reign → continue → judgment
However, none of that means Moore’s latest project, the $94 million Town Hall Square redevelopment, is the dud its opponents paint it to be.
asserted
it → mean → that
I have watched in amazement over recent months as well-organised groups plot to kill the City of Sydney’s four-decade-long plan to turn a block opposite Sydney Town Hall into much-needed open space.
asserted
groups → watch → space
The campaign has been led by the Business Sydney lobby outfit, retail giant Woolworths, the “Shoppies” union and Planning Minister Paul Scully, with The Daily Telegraph stepping up as their megaphone.
asserted
Telegraph → lead → megaphone
The vested-interest alliance has sprouted all sorts of arguments as selfish as they are short-sighted.
asserted
they → sprout → arguments
Sensing the risk of the project succumbing to pressure, the council has largely stayed quiet in the hope that the noise will just go away.
asserted
noise → sense → hope
Moore’s plan would see seven council-owned buildings demolished between George and Pitt streets, including one housing a Woolworths supermarket, and replaced by a plaza featuring 30 native trees, a water installation, seating and lighting.
asserted
buildings → see → trees
The views the square will open up of three sandstone gems – Town Hall, St Andrew’s Cathedral and the Queen Victoria Building – will be breathtaking.
asserted
square → open → gems
If you listen to the haters, you might think the fate of Sydney’s economy rests on this 5000-square-metre block – even though it represents just 0.17 per cent of the size of the Sydney CBD.
uncertain
it → listen → CBD
You might also think Moore dreamt up the whole thing yesterday as some kind of retirement vanity project, when the opposite is true.
uncertain
opposite → think → project
The City of Sydney has been planning the park since 1985, and the project enjoys largely bipartisan support on the council.
asserted
project → plan → council
But the council believes it can deliver the whole thing for $94 million – well down on its budget of $150 million.
asserted
it → believe → million
There was similar pearl-clutching about a decade ago when the City of Sydney council and then-Coalition state government pushed ahead with building light rail down a pedestrianised George Street.
asserted
council → be → Street
It has long been forgotten that NSW Labor – which is leading the charge against the Town Hall Square idea – opposed the light rail project, claiming it would be a “disaster” and function like the “Berlin Wall”, dividing east and west.
asserted
it → forget → east
The line Labor insisted would destroy Sydney is now a raging success, triggering billions of dollars of investment and renewal.
asserted
Labor → insist → investment
No one in their right mind would argue we should go back to a George Street clogged with cars and buses.
asserted
we → argue → cars
Labor also once opposed the conversion of the Sydenham-Bankstown line to metro rail, which will open by the end of the year and change the lives of hundreds of thousands of people who use the service.
asserted
who → oppose → service
The party also attempted to cruel the new Powerhouse project in Parramatta, but will quite happily cut the ribbon and claim political credit when the first visitors turn up next month.
See the pattern here?
uncertain
visitors → attempt → pattern
Time and time again, Labor underplays its role as custodian of central Sydney.
asserted
Labor → underplay → Sydney
The one thing it did get right was adopting former prime minister Paul Keating’s vision for a new headland park at Barangaroo, which restored the pre-European settlement shoreline of Sydney Harbour.
asserted
which → get → Harbour
More recently, Labor has failed to honour a 2023 election commitment to revamp the down-and-out Circular Quay, despite blowing nearly $108 million on planning with nothing to show for it.
asserted
Labor → fail → it
A new public square behind the neo-gothic Registrar General’s building off Macquarie Street is also languishing.
asserted
square → languish → Street
A plan devised by Keating and former Sydney lord mayor Lucy Turnbull to give the whole of Macquarie Street – home to the most architecturally and historically significant collection of public buildings in Australia – a much-needed glow-up remains sitting on the government’s desk.
asserted
plan → devise → desk
The scheme would restore vast tracts of land to the public and better link the city with the Domain.
asserted
scheme → restore → Domain
Short of a terrific $27 million revamp of the forecourt outside the State Library, nothing has happened.
asserted
nothing → happen → Library
Also gathering dust are concept plans to transform underutilised land to the west of Sydney’s glorious Central Station into a park and amphitheatre.
asserted
plans → gather → park
The site, tentatively dubbed Central Square, would be a cousin to Town Hall Square and link up with the new Atlassian office tower and a revamped Railway Square, which has seen better days.
asserted
which → dub → days
The idea has huge potential, but Labor has shown little interest.
asserted
Labor → have → interest
This is the record of the same mob which now claims it should be allowed to dictate the future of Town Hall Square.
uncertain
it → claim → Square
Rather than playing politics ahead of next year’s state election, Scully should be using his time as planning minister to get on with these major stalled projects, or deliver new housing targets which are running woefully behind.
asserted
which → play → targets
Instead, Scully has allowed himself to be roped into an anti-progress campaign.
asserted
himself → allow → campaign
The most shameless member of the alliance is Woolworths, which has known since 1985 that its landlord planned to raze the building for the plaza (a demolition clause has been in its contract for ages) yet has the hide to act shocked and surprised when those plans are finally enacted.
asserted
plans → know → hide
Corporate spinners have done a masterful job pretending that the demise of Woolworths’ premises would rob the CBD of a large supermarket.
asserted
demise → do → supermarket
That claim is rubbish; the idea that Woolworths would not want or be able to find a new location is fanciful.
uncertain
Woolworths → want → location
The council is also trying to work with the chain on finding alternative space nearby for the store and its staff.
asserted
council → try → store
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
