Amid the post-Covid 19 massive inflationary spiral, the fiscally suffocated government, with limited days of foreign exchange reserves, became dependent on the domestic debt market to finance its massive deficits amid rising inflation.
asserted
government → become → inflation
Therefore, it had to issue a massive amount of floating-rate, long-tenor debt instruments to manage extreme rollover risk.
asserted
it → have → risk
For reference, the total cumulative issuance of semi-annual floating Pakistan Investment Bonds increased from less than Rs1 trillion in 2020 to more than Rs14tr in 2024, and is currently more than Rs22tr.
asserted
issuance → float → Rs22tr
Floating rate instruments constitute approximately 70 per cent of all domestic sovereign debt.
asserted
instruments → float → debt
The debt portfolio’s Average Time to Maturity (ATM) is near 3.9 years, while Average Time to Refix (ATR) stands just above one year.
asserted
Time → stand → year
This leads to a vicious cycle of repricing: price increases immediately upset fiscal accounts.
asserted
increases → lead → accounts
The conventional economic theory believes price spirals are the result of excess aggregate demand that the State Bank of Pakistan can tame by raising interest rates.
asserted
Bank → believe → rates
However, Pakistan has high cost-push, structural, and import-driven inflation.
asserted
Pakistan → have → inflation
The recurring price spirals are mainly on the supply side and are the result of sudden currency devaluation, global commodity shocks, frequent revisions of administered energy tariffs to offset energy sector circular debt and domestic food supply bottlenecks.
asserted
spirals → recur → debt
In this structural context, the monetary policy measures taken by the State Bank of Pakistan are certainly needed.
asserted
measures → take → Pakistan
In the absence of a hawkish monetary policy amid an inflationary wave, inflationary expectations quickly get out of hand, second-round wage-price spirals set in, and exchange rate pressures build up, potentially leading to an uncontained macroeconomic spiral.
asserted
pressures → get → spiral
But the central bank’s tightening directly affects the most important channel that links inflation to an overwhelming fiscal burden: the domestic cost of debt.
asserted
that → affect → debt
The government should continue to work on structural reprofiling to address the sovereign portfolio’s repricing sensitivity
The correlation between debt servicing and headline inflation in the period 2006-16 was negligible and became moderate to strong post the 2022-23 spiral.
asserted
correlation → continue → spiral
The central bank’s rate hike to tackle price shocks reprices the government’s huge domestic floating debt stock.
asserted
hike → tackle → stock
This means that the policy rate hikes get quickly and vigorously passed on through the sovereign debt portfolio to fiscal expenditures.
asserted
hikes → mean → expenditures
This transmission is a delayed pass-through, with the sensitivity of debt servicing being highest after two to three quarters as floating instruments reprice at successive auctions.
asserted
instruments → float → auctions
The costs of servicing the debt take up a large share of the federal budget.
asserted
costs → service → budget
Despite three consecutive years of contractionary fiscal policy delivering consistent primary surpluses, debt servicing consumes 40 per cent of the federal budget.
asserted
servicing → deliver → budget
The government had no choice but to cut development spending and investment in productive capital.
asserted
government → have → capital
An anti-price policy, used to control prices, ends up increasing fiscal pressure, deteriorating the composition of public finances, and consuming public investments that can no longer be used for long-term structural productivity spending.
asserted
that → use → spending
This structural problem would need to be significantly addressed by improving sovereign debt indicators.
asserted
problem → need → indicators
The Debt Management Office has achieved good results in the past few years, with its efforts to reprofile domestic maturities, increase fixed-rate debt issuances, and extend the average maturity of the public debt stock.
asserted
Office → achieve → stock
Added to these fiscal weaknesses are the severe climate and geopolitical vulnerabilities facing Pakistan.
asserted
climate → add → Pakistan
It is still one of the most climate-sensitive countries in the world and continues to suffer from devastating floods, heatwaves, and yield losses that displace millions of people, destroy infrastructure, trigger food inflation, and erode fiscal buffers.
asserted
that → continue → buffers
There is an urgent need to build dedicated infrastructure for climate change adaptation, modernise water management, improve storage logistics, and make agriculture climate-smart in Pakistan to reduce vulnerability to frequent environmental shocks.
asserted
agriculture → be → shocks
At the same time, Pakistan has to deal with its extreme geoeconomic vulnerabilities in a fracturing global order.
asserted
Pakistan → have → order
The domestic economy is highly vulnerable to cross-border commodity price fluctuations, given its high reliance on imported fuel.
asserted
economy → give → fuel
The geopolitical and climate vulnerabilities have resulted in stagflationary pressures, leading to severe episodes of macroeconomic instability.
asserted
vulnerabilities → result → instability
The need to protect the economy requires proactive fiscal measures to overcome acute climate and geopolitical vulnerabilities, as recurring price spirals are not the result of runaway domestic demand but of price disruptions from outside the economy.
asserted
spirals → protect → economy
State agencies need to invest in climate-smart agricultural infrastructure, streamline storage logistics, and limit dependence on imported energy to shield the real economy from likely and unpredictable supply-side shocks.
asserted
agencies → need → shocks
The Debt Management Office, on the other hand, should continue working on structural reprofiling, which involves increasing the proportion of fixed-rate debt and lengthening debt maturities, to address the sovereign portfolio’s repricing sensitivity.
asserted
which → continue → sensitivity
The government has to address these structural and debt-market fault lines, so that conventional monetary interventions will no longer exacerbate the sovereign’s fiscal difficulties.
asserted
interventions → have → difficulties
The Aporia
